Before (end of 2004) (33 seats, Elections Centre)
Other 16 · Labour 16 · Conservative 1 · Liberal Democrats 0
After (end of 2005) (33 seats, Elections Centre)
Other 16 · Labour 16 · Conservative 1 · Liberal Democrats 0
Ward results
| Edward Llewellyn-Jones | Labour | 2,301 ✓ |
| Charlotte Vernon | Conservative | 860 |
| Louise Bradshaw | Liberal Democrats | 731 |
| John Ross | Independent | 316 |
| Clifford Perry | Independent | 153 |
| Andrew Finlayson | Green | 151 |
Sutton in Ashfield East1 seat · turnout 53.9%
| Steven Carroll | Labour | 2,364 ✓ |
| Linda Joyce Mullaney | Liberal Democrats | 1,034 |
| Calvin Madin | Independent | 768 |
| Claire Davenport | Green | 326 |
Sutton in Ashfield North1 seat · turnout 56.8%
| Dick Anthony | Labour | 2,105 ✓ |
| John Baker | Conservative | 1,118 |
| Philip Birkitt | Liberal Democrats | 654 |
| Peter Thorpe | Independent | 598 |
| Fiona Keen | Green | 223 |
Sutton in Ashfield West1 seat · turnout 70.7%
| David Kirkham | Labour | 2,290 ✓ |
| Stephanie Lyons | Conservative | 1,140 |
| Andrew Fell | Liberal Democrats | 654 |
| Harry Greasley | Independent | 580 |
| Kevin Bradford | Green | 258 |