Before (end of 2008) (44 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 30 · Liberal Democrats 12 · Other 2 · Labour 0
After (end of 2009) (44 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 30 · Liberal Democrats 12 · Other 2 · Labour 0
Ward results
Billingshurst1 seat
| Amanda Jane Jupp | Conservative | 1,701 ✓ |
| David Duke | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 694 |
| L. Rowe | Liberal Democrats | 588 |
| Christine Conibear | Labour | 160 |
Bramber Castle1 seat
| Derek Deedman | Liberal Democrats | 2,252 ✓ |
| David Howard Barling | Conservative | 1,669 |
| Stuart Bower | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 351 |
| Donna Bailey | BNP | 226 |
| Arleene Piercy | Labour | 117 |
Henfield1 seat
| Lionel Barnard | Conservative | 2,221 ✓ |
| Andrew Purches | Liberal Democrats | 830 |
| Tony Aldous | BNP | 257 |
| Malcolm Uhlhorn | Labour | 191 |
Horsham Riverside1 seat
| Morwen Elizabeth Millson | Liberal Democrats | 1,985 ✓ |
| Andrew Baldwin | Conservative | 1,283 |
| Jim Duggan | PEACE | 159 |
| Jonathan Austin | Labour | 137 |
Pulborough1 seat
| Pat Arculus | Conservative | 2,871 ✓ |
| Rosalyn Deedman | Liberal Democrats | 829 |
| Antony Bignell | Labour | 222 |
Southwater And Nuthurst1 seat
| Barney Watson | Conservative | 1,934 ✓ |
| Peter Stainton | Liberal Democrats | 1,075 |
| Harry Aldridge | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 519 |
| Tristan Loraine | Green | 261 |
| Jane Field | Labour | 113 |
Storrington1 seat
| Frank Wilkinson | Conservative | 2,677 ✓ |
| S. Stokes | Liberal Democrats | 771 |
| Henry Powell | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 523 |
| Margaret Cornwell | Labour | 215 |