Before (end of 2008) (42 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 33 · Liberal Democrats 8 · Other 1 · Labour 0
After (end of 2009) (42 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 33 · Liberal Democrats 8 · Other 1 · Labour 0
Ward results
Caterham Hill1 seat
| John Orrick | Liberal Democrats | 2,270 ✓ |
| Sakina Bradbury | Conservative | 1,811 |
| Helena Mary Windsor | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 475 |
| Rayhan Haque | Labour | 140 |
Oxted1 seat · turnout 47.6%
| Nicholas Skellett | Conservative | 2,925 ✓ |
| Robert Wingate | Liberal Democrats | 1,040 |
| Tony Stone | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 778 |
| Michaela O'Brien | Green | 380 |
| Jonathan Wheale | Labour | 345 |