Before (end of 1990) (57 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 42 · Liberal Democrats 13 · Other 2 · Labour 0
After (end of 1991) (57 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 28 · Liberal Democrats 27 · Labour 2 · Other 0
Ward results
Alfold & Dunsfold1 seat
| B. Ames | Conservative | 503 |
| K. Newnham | Independent | 417 |
Blackheath and Wonersh1 seat
| C. Pike | Conservative | 499 ✓ |
| F Scott | Liberal Democrats | 306 |
| S. Roberts | Labour | 71 |
| M. Goldring | ANP | 11 |
Bramley2 seats
| F. Baker | Conservative | 707 ✓ |
| A. Shaw | Conservative | 648 ✓ |
| P. Scattergood | Liberal Democrats | 502 |
| G. Wilkinson | Labour | 236 |
| D. Kinsella | Conservative | 396 |
| D. Henderson | Liberal Democrats | 228 |
| I. Clark | Green | 67 |
Chiddingfold1 seat
| A. Mugford | Conservative | 585 |
| W. Gray | Liberal Democrats | 363 |
| A. Johnson | Labour | 118 |
Cranleigh East3 seats
| C. Savage | Liberal Democrats | 1,403 |
| J. Savage | Liberal Democrats | 1,182 |
| G Tresman | Liberal Democrats | 1,100 |
| A. Alexander | Conservative | 1,046 |
| A. Bridge | Conservative | 1,040 |
| B. Brewis | Conservative | 830 |
| J Reynolds | Labour | 401 |
Cranleigh West2 seats
| G. Davis | Conservative | 836 ✓ |
| A. Lazarus | Conservative | 810 ✓ |
| B Montague-Butlin | Liberal Democrats | 709 |
| A Prowse | Liberal Democrats | 621 |
| P. Mitchell | Liberal Democrats | 808 |
| R. Terry | Liberal Democrats | 801 |
| L. Fenn | Conservative | 677 |
| S. Herrett | Conservative | 578 |
Ewhurst1 seat
| M. Lockwood | Conservative | 430 |
| A. Masterton-Smith | Liberal Democrats | 360 |
Farnham Bourne3 seats
| Peter Burden | Conservative | 1,213 ✓ |
| R Moore | Conservative | 1,197 ✓ |
| D. Morgan | Conservative | 1,166 ✓ |
| E Beeson | Liberal Democrats | 1,155 |
| A Kershaw | Liberal Democrats | 1,152 |
| S. Hunt | Liberal Democrats | 1,125 |
| D Protheroe | Labour | 177 |
Farnham Castle3 seats
| M. King-Hele | Liberal Democrats | 1,417 ✓ |
| Z Bransby-Williams | Liberal Democrats | 1,392 ✓ |
| J. Wootton | Liberal Democrats | 1,249 ✓ |
| M. Fawkes | Conservative | 707 |
| K. Butterfield | Conservative | 682 |
| Patricia Catherine Mary Quigley | Labour | 187 |
Farnham Hale and Heath End2 seats
| W. Marshall | Liberal Democrats | 794 |
| M. Hunt | Liberal Democrats | 674 |
| C. Harland | Conservative | 398 |
| D. Newman | Conservative | 352 |
| G. Wolverson | Labour | 71 |
| E. Anson | Conservative | 1,279 |
| Munro J. | Liberal Democrats | 1,224 |
| A. Rice | Liberal Democrats | 1,130 |
| P. Howd | Conservative | 1,123 |
| R. Backett | Conservative | 1,092 |
| D Steel | Liberal Democrats | 1,068 |
| R. Smith | Labour | 280 |
Farnham Upper Hale2 seats
| J. Harris | Liberal Democrats | 797 |
| S. Lang | Liberal Democrats | 725 |
| R Cordier | Conservative | 627 |
| J. Darker | Conservative | 547 |
Farnham Waverly3 seats
| M. Blower | Liberal Democrats | 1,119 ✓ |
| R. Thomas | Liberal Democrats | 964 ✓ |
| Stewart Edge | Liberal Democrats | 923 ✓ |
| M Anderson | Conservative | 830 |
| A. Hoath | Conservative | 819 |
| S Grinham | Conservative | 775 |
| N Madgwick | Labour | 156 |
| G. Beel | Liberal Democrats | 1,029 ✓ |
| S. Shapiro | Liberal Democrats | 943 ✓ |
| P Hawkins | Conservative | 625 |
| K Barnes | Conservative | 624 |
| C. Merry-Price | Conservative | 1,016 ✓ |
| O Davey | Conservative | 994 ✓ |
| J Rodgers | Liberal Democrats | 591 |
| John Petty | Liberal Democrats | 576 |
Godalming North2 seats
| E. Cooper | Liberal Democrats | 617 ✓ |
| A. Thomson | Liberal Democrats | 567 ✓ |
| C Blake | Conservative | 477 |
| C Read | Conservative | 389 |
| A Tozer | Labour | 238 |
| L Dollery | Labour | 226 |
Godalming North East & S.W.3 seats
| H Denningberg | Labour | 949 ✓ |
| B. Sharpe | Liberal Democrats | 905 ✓ |
| E. Denningberg | Labour | 830 ✓ |
| C Eley | Liberal Democrats | 775 |
| Christopher Slyfield | Liberal Democrats | 694 |
| S Williams | Labour | 619 |
| K. Cruden | Conservative | 539 |
| M West | Conservative | 513 |
| N Bedrock | Green | 215 |
Godalming North West2 seats
| D. Darbishire | Liberal Democrats | 1,183 |
| D. Teller | Liberal Democrats | 1,006 |
| D. Jack | Conservative | 732 |
| R. Gordon-Smith | Conservative | 722 |
| P Whitehead | Green | 157 |
Godalming South East3 seats
| M. Goodridge | Conservative | 1,274 ✓ |
| H. McCulloch | Conservative | 1,123 ✓ |
| G Stackpole | Conservative | 1,088 ✓ |
| E Edgington | Liberal Democrats | 1,009 |
| D Hassall | Liberal Democrats | 1,004 |
| N Thomson | Liberal Democrats | 954 |
| M Lawn | Green | 302 |
| J Sheppard | ANP | 87 |
Haslemere North & Grayswood2 seats
| C. Stevens | Conservative | 635 ✓ |
| I Bawarchi | Conservative | 629 ✓ |
| P Nicholson | Liberal Democrats | 416 |
| G McCracken | Independent | 396 |
| Suzan Lelliott | Liberal Democrats | 384 |
| A Martin | Green | 170 |
Haslemere South2 seats
| J. Mansley | Conservative | 827 ✓ |
| B. Ashford | Conservative | 804 ✓ |
| C. Cole | Liberal Democrats | 482 |
| N. Godden | Liberal Democrats | 455 |
Hindhead2 seats
| Dixon J. | Conservative | 727 |
| Caroline Brook | Conservative | 687 |
| G Whitby | Liberal Democrats | 382 |
| P. Mazzotti | Liberal Democrats | 356 |
| P Stubbs | Green | 346 |
Milford2 seats
| J. Graham-Stewart | Liberal Democrats | 790 ✓ |
| S. Harman | Liberal Democrats | 750 ✓ |
| S. Hill | Conservative | 688 |
| M. Cummings | Conservative | 643 |
| R. Mintern | ANP | 49 |
Shamley Green1 seat
| J. Powell-Jones | Conservative | 447 |
| P. Frere | Labour | 124 |
Shottermill2 seats
| M. Biddiscombe | Liberal Democrats | 748 |
| R. Gould | Conservative | 702 |
| R. Jackson | Conservative | 608 |
| T. Pamplin | SDP | 528 |
| M. Smith | Labour | 211 |
Witley2 seats
| Ramon Gray | Conservative | 755 ✓ |
| D. Inman | Conservative | 666 ✓ |
| E. Farrow | Liberal Democrats | 638 |
| J. Gainey-Brown | Liberal Democrats | 571 |
