Before (end of 1990) (42 seats, Elections Centre)
Other 17 · Liberal Democrats 17 · Conservative 8 · Labour 0
After (end of 1991) (42 seats, Elections Centre)
Liberal Democrats 20 · Other 14 · Conservative 6 · Labour 2
Ward results
Amotherby1 seat · turnout 50.7%
| A. Mayo | Liberal Democrats | 466 |
| N. Farquharson | Conservative | 455 |
Ampleforth1 seat
| Neil Campbell | Independent | 0 |
Clifton Without1 seat · turnout 48.8%
| S Tarry | Liberal Democrats | 750 |
| R. Binns | Conservative | 529 |
Ebberston1 seat · turnout 50.5%
| K. Binks | Independent | 301 |
| H. Schroeder | Liberal Democrats | 293 |
Haxby North East2 seats
| A. Carter | Liberal Democrats | 1,220 ✓ |
| H Briggs | Liberal Democrats | 1,160 ✓ |
| J Hollingsworth | Conservative | 643 |
| J Wreglesworth | Conservative | 633 |
| P. Newby | Labour | 210 |
Haxby West2 seats · turnout 33.0%
| A Fisher | Liberal Democrats | 1,126 |
| M Watson | Liberal Democrats | 952 |
| J Steele | Labour | 244 |
Hovingham1 seat · turnout 63.8%
| R. Smith | Independent | 410 |
| C Wainwright | Independent | 318 |
| A. Bulmer | Liberal Democrats | 218 |
| H. Cooper | Independent | 209 |
| J Bradley | Independent | 47 |
Huntington North2 seats
| J. Vaughan | Liberal Democrats | 1,093 ✓ |
| R Ormond | Liberal Democrats | 1,050 ✓ |
| E. Dickson | Conservative | 575 |
| T Horner | Labour | 199 |
| D Jackson | Labour | 179 |
Huntington South3 seats
| E Thomas | Liberal Democrats | 1,367 ✓ |
| J Kirby | Liberal Democrats | 1,139 ✓ |
| R Alexander | Liberal Democrats | 1,120 ✓ |
| D Atlay | Independent | 458 |
| GA Thompson | Labour | 344 |
| J Horner | Labour | 325 |
| S Flanagan | Labour | 297 |
Kirby Misperton1 seat · turnout 43.3%
| E. Ibbotson | Independent | 509 |
| A. Dobson | Liberal Democrats | 239 |
Kirkbymoorside2 seats
| M. Waind | Conservative | 859 ✓ |
| G. Hobbs | Labour | 706 ✓ |
| J. Lindley | Independent | 533 |
| P Huteson | Liberal Democrats | 495 |
Malton2 seats
| M. Parkinson | Conservative | 770 ✓ |
| F. Wiggle | Independent | 648 ✓ |
| L. Burr | Liberal Democrats | 562 |
| R. Tyrie | Labour | 339 |
| D. Meegan | Labour | 331 |
New Earswick1 seat
| J. Barklem | Labour | 411 ✓ |
| S. Hudson | Liberal Democrats | 381 |
Norton3 seats · turnout 31.4%
| Elizabeth Lois Shields | Liberal Democrats | 1,067 |
| A. Jenkins | Liberal Democrats | 884 |
| Mary Taylor | Conservative | 815 |
| H Spencer | Liberal Democrats | 560 |
| C. Rawling | Conservative | 549 |
| G. Cooper | Independent | 450 |
| R. Hall | Conservative | 414 |
Osbaldwick and Heworth3 seats
| M Bradley | Liberal Democrats | 1,386 |
| B Horn | Liberal Democrats | 1,372 |
| R Johnson | Liberal Democrats | 1,215 |
| W Horwell | Conservative | 712 |
| C Marwood | Conservative | 569 |
| S Ramsey | Conservative | 532 |
| S. Varley | Labour | 479 |
Osbaldwick/Heworth3 seats · turnout 53.2%
| M. Bradley | Liberal Democrats | 1,386 ✓ |
| B. Horn | Liberal Democrats | 1,372 ✓ |
| R. Johnson | Liberal Democrats | 1,215 ✓ |
| W. Horwell | Conservative | 712 |
| C. Marwood | Conservative | 569 |
| S. Ramsey | Conservative | 532 |
| S. Varley | Labour | 479 |
Pickering3 seats · turnout 38.9%
| J. Taylor | Independent | 1,196 |
| A. Aslett | Liberal Democrats | 690 |
| L. Cowling | Conservative | 665 |
| M Dales | Conservative | 641 |
| G. De Barr | Liberal Democrats | 636 |
| H. Washington | Independent | 628 |
| A Avery | Labour | 486 |
| S. Langton | Liberal Democrats | 458 |
| J. Baxter | Independent | 372 |
| V. Richards | Independent | 310 |
Rawcliffe2 seats
| D. Stead | Independent | 1,027 ✓ |
| R Eccles | Independent | 739 ✓ |
| Mark Waudby | Liberal Democrats | 403 |
| B. Meek | Labour | 365 |
Rillington1 seat · turnout 51.4%
| G. Wilkinson | Liberal Democrats | 598 |
| R. Gooder | Independent | 473 |
Sherburn1 seat · turnout 38.9%
| C. Todd | Independent | 435 |
| M. Broadbent | Liberal Democrats | 305 |
Sheriff Hutton1 seat · turnout 60.9%
| A. Farnaby | Independent | 605 |
| J. Wardell | Conservative | 514 |
Skelton1 seat
| M. Kirk | Liberal Democrats | 0 ✓ |
| Madeleine Kirk | Liberal Democrats | 0 |
Stockton & Bossall1 seat · turnout 57.8%
| K. Knaggs | Conservative | 486 |
| Pat Hearn | Liberal Democrats | 374 |
| C. Harrison | Independent | 248 |
Strensall1 seat · turnout 50.0%
| W. Chapman | Conservative | 754 |
| D. Curtis | Liberal Democrats | 554 |
| R Cundall | Labour | 248 |
| A. Bilsborough | Independent | 18 |
Thornton Dale1 seat
| W. Garbutt | Independent | 531 ✓ |
| D. Longman | Liberal Democrats | 205 |
| G. Donnor | Labour | 95 |
Wigginton1 seat · turnout 51.9%
| A Hall | Liberal Democrats | 733 |
| N David | Conservative | 617 |
| N. Stewart | Labour | 197 |
Wolds1 seat · turnout 60.8%
| R. Butler | Conservative | 392 |
| P. Adlington | Ind Con | 129 |
| R. Crawley | Labour | 48 |
