Before (end of 1990) (53 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 32 · Conservative 15 · Other 5 · Liberal Democrats 1
After (end of 1991) (53 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 35 · Conservative 10 · Other 5 · Liberal Democrats 3
Ward results
Barlow & Holmesfield1 seat
| J. Grice | Conservative | 500 ✓ |
| I. Carter | Labour | 253 |
| R. Boyes | Independent | 165 |
Brampton & Walton3 seats
| Thompson H. | Conservative | 889 ✓ |
| P. Needham | Conservative | 858 ✓ |
| J. Hutchinson | Independent | 619 ✓ |
| J. Hague | Labour | 305 |
| N. Long | Labour | 237 |
Clay Cross North3 seats
| J. Nuttall | Labour | 1,208 |
| M. Simpson | Labour | 1,148 |
| S. Fisher | Labour | 1,091 |
| R. Drake | Conservative | 614 |
Clay Cross South2 seats
| P. Booker | Labour | 0 |
| D. Nuttall | Labour | 0 |
Coal Aston2 seats · turnout 41.6%
| T Clark | Conservative | 567 |
| C. Gill | Conservative | 559 |
| M. Emmens | Ind Con | 446 |
| D Steele | Labour | 389 |
| M. Machin | Labour | 364 |
Dronfield North3 seats
| Christine Smith | Labour | 929 ✓ |
| G. Baxter | Labour | 926 ✓ |
| M. Cooper | Labour | 916 ✓ |
| S. Davies | Conservative | 664 |
| A. Moorcroft | Conservative | 662 |
| G. Owen | Conservative | 641 |
Dronfield South3 seats
| R. Lindley | Ind Con | 893 ✓ |
| K. Marr | Conservative | 888 ✓ |
| J. Thorpe | Ind Con | 774 ✓ |
| R. Carnell | Conservative | 685 |
| N Foster | Labour | 635 |
| M. Foster | Labour | 633 |
| J. Holden | Labour | 625 |
| C. Pryce | Liberal Democrats | 501 |
| R. Kay | Liberal Democrats | 458 |
| W. Temple | Liberal Democrats | 438 |
Dronfield Woodhouse1 seat · turnout 51.4%
| C. Batty | Conservative | 437 |
| R. Rutherford | Labour | 240 |
| S Temple | Liberal Democrats | 176 |
Eckington North2 seats · turnout 33.5%
| J. Dargue | Labour | 668 |
| P. Brown | Labour | 664 |
| W Feasey | Conservative | 387 |
| P. Robinson | Independent | 330 |
Eckington South2 seats
| R. Capps | Labour | 0 |
| S. Pickering | Labour | 0 |
erihsybreD3 seats · turnout 32.1%
| J. Nuttall | Labour | 1,208 |
| M. Simpson | Labour | 1,148 |
| S. Fisher | Labour | 1,091 |
| D'Souza R. | Conservative | 614 |
| Clay | Cross North | 0 |
Gosforth Valley3 seats · turnout 47.7%
| D. Smillie | Liberal Democrats | 1,145 ✓ |
| D Duncan | Liberal Democrats | 975 ✓ |
| M. Knowles | Liberal Democrats | 957 ✓ |
| E Batty | Conservative | 918 |
| D Bennett | Conservative | 865 |
| R Cartwright | Conservative | 837 |
| B Moor | Labour | 350 |
| B. Moor | Labour | 342 |
| K. Steele | Labour | 296 |
Grassmoor2 seats
| A. Woolven | Labour | 0 |
| T. Lide | Labour | 0 |
Holmewood & Heath2 seats
| R. Brunt | Labour | 0 |
| J. Glasby | Labour | 0 |
Killamarsh East1 seat
| L. Laycock | Labour | 0 |
Killamarsh West3 seats
| H. Laws | Labour | 0 |
| K. Warns | Labour | 0 |
| Robinson C. | Labour | 0 |
Morton1 seat
| M. Treeweek | Labour | 0 |
North Wingfield Central3 seats
| George Butler | Labour | 1,136 ✓ |
| J. Bradley | Labour | 1,130 ✓ |
| D. Ward | Labour | 1,083 ✓ |
| W. Gent | Conservative | 461 |
| J. Renshaw | Conservative | 397 |
Renishaw1 seat
| P. Cousins | Labour | 0 |
Ridgeway & Marsh Lane1 seat · turnout 48.5%
| J. Greer | Labour | 369 |
| B. Spooner | Conservative | 336 |
Shirland3 seats
| D. Cotterell | Labour | 0 |
| H. Howard | Labour | 0 |
| H. Howard | Labour | 0 ✓ |
| D. Cotterell | Labour | 0 ✓ |
| S. Wareing | Labour | 0 ✓ |
| S. Wareing | Labour | 0 |
Sutton2 seats · turnout 32.5%
| I. Beresford | Labour | 784 |
| P. Kerry | Labour | 706 |
| G. Booth | Independent | 575 |
Tupton2 seats · turnout 41.0%
| G. Marshall | Labour | 835 |
| P. Broadhead | Labour | 550 |
| G. Whitmore | Independent | 516 |
Unstone1 seat · turnout 45.4%
| F. Hopkinson | Labour | 409 |
| S. Emmens | Conservative | 293 |
Wingerworth3 seats · turnout 41.4%
| G. Wade | Conservative | 1,462 |
| M. Holmes | Conservative | 1,456 |
| W. Pickford | Conservative | 1,451 |
| T Moss | Labour | 858 |
| Cain S. | Labour | 848 |
| M. Kitchener | Labour | 770 |