Before (end of 1994) (41 seats, Elections Centre)
Liberal Democrats 21 · Conservative 11 · Other 8 · Labour 1
After (end of 1995) (41 seats, Elections Centre)
Liberal Democrats 20 · Conservative 11 · Other 8 · Labour 2
Ward results
ASHTEAD COMMON1 seat
| B. Douglass | Independent | 769 ✓ |
| E. Webster | Liberal Democrats | 581 |
ASHTEAD VILLAGE1 seat
| S. Cunliffe | Independent | 1,228 ✓ |
| P. Shimmin | Liberal Democrats | 273 |
| Jennifer Huggett | Green | 138 |
Bookham South1 seat
| M. Anderson | Liberal Democrats | 1,464 ✓ |
| M Glenister | Conservative | 652 |
Box Hill1 seat
| P. Tatham | Conservative | 645 ✓ |
| G Lawrie | Liberal Democrats | 485 |
| J. Jeffreys | Labour | 106 |
Charlwood1 seat
| H. Sewill | Independent | 470 ✓ |
| P Vallance | Ind Con | 106 |
| A Nicholls | Liberal Democrats | 102 |
| G. Corey | Labour | 66 |
Holmwood & Beare Green1 seat
| A. Allsop | Liberal Democrats | 545 ✓ |
| Pamela Pulling-Smith | Conservative | 287 |
| A. Burnage | Labour | 142 |
Leatherhead North1 seat
| M. Ward | Labour | 689 ✓ |
| Justine Baker | Liberal Democrats | 621 |
| C. Salsbury | Conservative | 476 |
| D. Smith | Green | 61 |
Leatherhead South1 seat
| Rosemary Dickson | Conservative | 900 ✓ |
| T Spoors | Liberal Democrats | 661 |
Leith Hill1 seat
| N. Maltby | Conservative | 467 ✓ |
| P Hall | Liberal Democrats | 189 |
| J Steele | Independent | 94 |
North Holmwood1 seat
| Watson M. | Liberal Democrats | 1,097 ✓ |
| G Eason | Conservative | 333 |
| F. Wolf | Labour | 301 |
Rural East1 seat
| J. Pharo-Tomlin | Conservative | 704 ✓ |
| G Hawkins | Liberal Democrats | 386 |
| E Peck | Labour | 60 |
Rural South1 seat
| N. O'Shea | Liberal Democrats | 683 ✓ |
| B. Mackinnon | Independent | 359 |
| N. Roger | Labour | 80 |