Before (end of 2003) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 33 · Liberal Democrats 7 · Other 6 · Labour 5
After (end of 2004) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 37 · Other 6 · Liberal Democrats 5 · Labour 3
Ward results
Banstead Village1 seat · turnout 40.2%
| Brian Cowle | Conservative | 1,647 ✓ |
| Helen Trenaman | Liberal Democrats | 499 |
| Rosemary Norgrove | Labour | 210 |
Earlswood & Whitebushes1 seat · turnout 40.2%
| Ben Mearns | Conservative | 818 ✓ |
| Alan Stein | Liberal Democrats | 663 |
| Victor Parks | Labour | 501 |
| Stephen Smith | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 403 |
Horley Central1 seat · turnout 31.5%
| Abdul Kayum | Conservative | 751 ✓ |
| Geoffrey Southall | Liberal Democrats | 429 |
| Timothy Brooke-Harte | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 395 |
| Katherine Humphreys | Labour | 209 |
Horley East1 seat · turnout 33.1%
| John Meech | Conservative | 728 ✓ |
| Cherry Larcombe | Liberal Democrats | 278 |
| Janice Gall | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 238 |
| Richard Monk | Labour | 114 |
Horley West1 seat
| Andrea Benn | Conservative | 751 ✓ |
| Denese Brooke-Harte | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 447 |
| Diana Andrews | Liberal Democrats | 402 |
| Linda Jane Mabbett | Labour | 222 |
Kingswood with Burgh Heath1 seat · turnout 39.0%
| Gaenor Circus | Conservative | 1,156 ✓ |
| Jeremy Wraith | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 431 |
| Jacqueline Cooper | Liberal Democrats | 208 |
| Andrew Dunsmuir | Labour | 141 |
Meadvale & St John's1 seat
| Thomas Stoddart | Conservative | 1,049 ✓ |
| Christopher Howell | Liberal Democrats | 929 |
| Patricia Johnson | Labour | 226 |
| Peter Kefford | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 179 |
Merstham1 seat · turnout 42.6%
| Mark Brunt | Conservative | 1,049 ✓ |
| Susanna Merritt | Liberal Democrats | 1,000 |
| John Michael Berge | Labour | 295 |
Nork1 seat · turnout 43.7%
| Norman Harris | — | 1,422 ✓ |
| John Harcourt-Groome | Conservative | 548 |
| Stephen Gee | Liberal Democrats | 433 |
Redhill East1 seat · turnout 39.0%
| John Frederick Jones | Conservative | 714 ✓ |
| Paul Selby | Labour | 494 |
| Susan McBride | Liberal Democrats | 414 |
| Joseph Brian Fox | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 298 |
Redhill West1 seat · turnout 40.8%
| Natalie Bramhall | Conservative | 970 ✓ |
| John Stuart Gosling | Labour | 486 |
| Stephen O'Shea | Liberal Democrats | 482 |
| Angie Morita | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 286 |
Reigate Central1 seat · turnout 46.2%
| Scott Colvin | Conservative | 1,176 ✓ |
| John Vincent | Liberal Democrats | 849 |
| Deirdre Hicks | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 176 |
| Rebecca Spencer | Labour | 168 |
Reigate Hill1 seat · turnout 44.5%
| Roger Charles Newstead | Conservative | 1,069 ✓ |
| Sue Vincent | Liberal Democrats | 339 |
| Yvonne Larg | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 185 |
| Janet Margaret Thomas | Labour | 158 |
South Park & Woodhatch1 seat
| Andrew Mountney | Conservative | 1,004 ✓ |
| Robert Fromant | Labour | 628 |
| Anthony Lambell | Liberal Democrats | 500 |
Tadworth and Walton1 seat · turnout 43.2%
| Richard Bennett | Conservative | 1,488 ✓ |
| Edward Maxfield | Liberal Democrats | 426 |
| Robert Cambridge | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 406 |
Tattenhams1 seat · turnout 36.5%
| Edward Russell | — | 1,213 ✓ |
| Susan Mary Wilson | Conservative | 517 |
| David Royle | Liberal Democrats | 151 |
| Ghufran Syed | Labour | 120 |
vote share1 seat
| Marion Brewster | Conservative | 1,481 ✓ |
| J. Hughes | Independent | 496 ✓ |
| Georgina Regan | Liberal Democrats | 461 |
| Clare Moonan | Labour | 190 |