Before (end of 2004) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 37 · Other 6 · Liberal Democrats 5 · Labour 3
After (end of 2005) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 37 · Other 6 · Liberal Democrats 5 · Labour 3
Ward results
| Fabian King | Conservative | 2,690 ✓ |
| Christopher Booton | Labour | 2,255 |
| Christopher Howell | Liberal Democrats | 1,794 |
| Colin Brian Stiff | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 488 |
Horley East1 seat · turnout 59.4%
| Dorothy Ross-Tomlin | Conservative | 2,882 ✓ |
| Geoffrey Southall | Liberal Democrats | 1,479 |
| Gerard O'Dwyer | Labour | 1,095 |
| Janice Gall | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 452 |
Horley West1 seat · turnout 62.9%
| Kay Hammond | Conservative | 2,062 ✓ |
| Heather Smith | Liberal Democrats | 1,044 |
| Andrew Richard Jones | Labour | 929 |
| Jane Eyles | Independent | 481 |
| Denese Brooke-Harte | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 417 |
Reigate Central1 seat · turnout 67.2%
| Simon Harding | Conservative | 3,134 ✓ |
| Peter Lambell | Liberal Democrats | 3,056 |
| Clare Moonan | Labour | 1,057 |
Tattenhams1 seat
| Jo Bray | TattsRA | 1,973 ✓ |
| Unknown | Conservative | 998 |
| Unknown | Labour | 433 |