Before (end of 2008) (37 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 20 · Liberal Democrats 16 · Other 1 · Labour 0
After (end of 2009) (37 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 21 · Liberal Democrats 15 · Other 1 · Labour 0
Ward results
Bardney And Cherry Willingham1 seat · turnout 40.5%
| Ian Gordon Fleetwood | Conservative | 1,443 ✓ |
| Carol Pearson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 570 |
| Stephen Trevor | Liberal Democrats | 548 |
| Melaine Tointon | Labour | 257 |
Gainsborough Rural South1 seat · turnout 43.9%
| Stuart Kinch | Conservative | 1,785 ✓ |
| Peter Heath | Liberal Democrats | 1,514 |
| Malcolm Porter | BNP | 379 |
Market Rasen Wolds1 seat · turnout 35.4%
| Burton Keimach | Conservative | 1,085 ✓ |
| Kenneth Bridger | Liberal Democrats | 1,050 |
Nettleham And Saxilby1 seat · turnout 41.8%
| Raymond Sellars | Liberal Democrats | 2,012 ✓ |
| Roger Pilgrim | Conservative | 1,129 |
| Victoria Street | Labour | 184 |
North Wolds1 seat · turnout 38.2%
| Tony Turner | Conservative | 1,763 ✓ |
| Robert Smith | Liberal Democrats | 794 |
Scotter Rural1 seat · turnout 40.4%
| Christopher Underwood-Frost | Conservative | 1,447 ✓ |
| Lesley Rollings | Liberal Democrats | 791 |
| Mark Raeburn | Labour | 204 |
Welton Rural1 seat · turnout 41.9%
| Sue Rawlins | Conservative | 1,937 ✓ |
| Roger Hiscox | Liberal Democrats | 1,589 |
