Before (end of 2008) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 39 · Other 8 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Labour 1
After (end of 2009) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 39 · Other 8 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Labour 1
Ward results
| Fabian King | Conservative | 1,902 ✓ |
| Anthony Lambell | Liberal Democrats | 895 |
| Joseph Brian Fox | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 759 |
| Rosemary Norgrove | Labour | 556 |
| Peter Phillips | BNP | 282 |
Horley East1 seat · turnout 35.7%
| Dorothy Ross-Tomlin | Conservative | 1,819 ✓ |
| Timothy Brooke-Harte | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 653 |
| Barry Hamilton | Liberal Democrats | 634 |
| Linda Jane Mabbett | Labour | 299 |
| Bernard Gudgeon | BNP | 251 |
Horley West1 seat · turnout 36.1%
| Kay Hammond | Conservative | 1,352 ✓ |
| Denese Brooke-Harte | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 588 |
| Christopher Howell | Liberal Democrats | 458 |
| Gabriella Upton | Labour | 234 |
| Stephen Horne | BNP | 228 |
Reigate Central1 seat · turnout 45.5%
| Peter Lambell | Liberal Democrats | 1,666 ✓ |
| Natalie Bramhall | Conservative | 1,470 |
| Christopher Thomas Henry Whinney | Independent | 1,262 |
| Deirdre Hicks | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 370 |
| Paul Selby | Labour | 197 |
