Before (end of 2008) (39 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 30 · Conservative 5 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Other 1
After (end of 2009) (39 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 30 · Conservative 5 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Other 1
Ward results
Old Stevenage1 seat
| John Fraser | Conservative | 1,708 ✓ |
| Michael Downing | Labour | 1,501 |
| Rik Seddon | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 515 |
| Clive Hearmon | Liberal Democrats | 484 |
| Stuart Madgin | Green | 298 |
| Reginald Norgan | BNP | 219 |