Before (end of 2008) (43 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 24 · Labour 9 · Liberal Democrats 6 · Other 4
After (end of 2009) (43 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 24 · Labour 9 · Liberal Democrats 6 · Other 4
Ward results
Buxton North And East1 seat · turnout 35.8%
| Pam Reddy | Conservative | 1,349 ✓ |
| Barbara Wilson | Labour | 1,101 |
| Karl Dunscombe | Liberal Democrats | 631 |
Buxton West1 seat · turnout 42.2%
| Robin Baldry | Conservative | 2,292 ✓ |
| Chris Weaver | Liberal Democrats | 832 |
| Jenny McGrother | Labour | 831 |
Chapel And Hope Valley1 seat · turnout 43.9%
| Tracy Critchlow | Conservative | 2,058 ✓ |
| Terry Norton | Labour | 753 |
| David Mount | Green | 645 |
| Jane Margaret Simm | Liberal Democrats | 593 |
Etherow1 seat · turnout 31.7%
| David Wilcox | Labour | 1,103 ✓ |
| Stephen Foote | Conservative | 983 |
| Rosa Kuppan | Liberal Democrats | 530 |