Before (end of 2009) (63 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 27 · Other 15 · Liberal Democrats 12 · Conservative 9
After (end of 2010) (63 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 33 · Other 11 · Liberal Democrats 10 · Conservative 9
Ward results
Adwick1 seat
| John Mounsey | Labour | 2,948 ✓ |
| David Farrell | Liberal Democrats | 1,068 |
| Janine Clark | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 1,004 |
| Alan John Smith | Conservative | 650 |
Askern Spa1 seat
| Rosemary Jane Jones | Labour | 2,756 ✓ |
| Martin Damian Greenhalgh | Conservative | 1,502 |
| Malcolm Woodrow | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 1,415 |
Balby1 seat
| Andrew Bosmans | Labour | 2,505 ✓ |
| Matthew Brunning | Conservative | 1,462 |
| Garth Oxby | Independent | 1,289 |
| Margaret Thompson | Independent | 694 |
Bessacar & Cantley1 seat · turnout 64.1%
| E. Tatton-Kelly | Liberal Democrats | 2,496 ✓ |
| L. Sparrow | Conservative | 1,895 |
| S. Wilkinson | Labour | 1,626 |
| M Cooper | E Dem | 1,149 |
Central1 seat
| John McHale | Labour | 2,752 ✓ |
| Marie Lane | Liberal Democrats | 1,023 |
| Berny Boldry | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 783 |
| Ian Hutchinson | Conservative | 735 |
| Jim Davies | — | 115 |
Conisbrough and Denaby1 seat
| Sandra Mary Holland | Labour | 3,771 ✓ |
| Joan Butterfield | Liberal Democrats | 753 |
| Julie Bulcroft | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 722 |
| Erwin Toseland | BNP | 690 |
| Joanne Broughton | Conservative | 593 |
| David Andrew Nevett | Labour | 1,632 ✓ |
| Karl Goodman | Liberal Democrats | 1,585 |
| Nick Allen | Conservative | 1,383 |
| Fred Gee | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 1,100 |
| Michael Maye | Independent | 1,100 |
Edlington And Warmsworth1 seat · turnout 57.8%
| Elsie Butler | Labour | 2,242 ✓ |
| Wayne Crawshaw | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 1,024 |
| Liz Jones | Conservative | 863 |
| Dominic Patterson | Liberal Democrats | 777 |
| Margaret Ward | — | 722 |
| Rodger Lee | Independent | 352 |
Great North Road1 seat
| Kevin Terence Rodgers | Labour | 2,464 ✓ |
| Della Hughes | Independent | 1,236 |
| Steve Grocott | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 1,229 |
| Frank Calladine | Conservative | 1,222 |
| Stephen Platt | Green | 607 |
Hatfield1 seat · turnout 61.4%
| Liam Curran | Labour | 1,961 ✓ |
| James Vincent Hart | Conservative | 1,145 |
| Mick Glynn | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 801 |
| Jessie Jamieson Credland | Independent | 716 |
| Stewart Rayner | — | 699 |
| Vic Fairhead | Liberal Democrats | 602 |
| William Shaw | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 315 |
Mexborough1 seat · turnout 52.1%
| David Holland | Labour | 2,334 ✓ |
| Tracey Leyland | Liberal Democrats | 1,784 |
| Helen Ellis | BNP | 785 |
| Phyllis Calladine | Conservative | 512 |
| Ieva Parramore | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 413 |
Rossington1 seat
| Barry Johnson | Labour | 1,771 ✓ |
| Terry Wilde | Independent | 971 |
| John Cooke | — | 812 |
| Carol Young | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 733 |
| Rebecca Atkinson | Liberal Democrats | 638 |
| Margaret Beard | Conservative | 514 |
Stainforth and Moorends1 seat · turnout 52.0%
| Barbara Hedley | Labour | 1,884 ✓ |
| Martin Drake | Conservative | 1,000 |
| David Owen | BNP | 608 |
| Margaret Holt-Taylor | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 580 |
| Ronald Clegg | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 399 |
| Derek Troops | Independent | 302 |
| Mick Green | — | 175 |
Thorne1 seat
| Eddie Dobbs | Labour | 1,653 ✓ |
| Jenny Brown | Conservative | 1,383 |
| Richard Walker | Independent | 860 |
| John Brown | Liberal Democrats | 734 |
| Tony Brookes | — | 716 |
| Anthony Holt | BNP | 673 |
Torne Valley1 seat · turnout 69.4%
| Patricia Bartlett | Conservative | 2,863 ✓ |
| David Adgar | Liberal Democrats | 1,580 |
| Rachel Hodson | Labour | 1,325 |
| Bernie Aston | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 523 |
| Rebecca Walters | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 517 |
Town Moor1 seat · turnout 55.2%
| Jane Kidd | Labour | 1,906 ✓ |
| Kevin Abell | Liberal Democrats | 1,681 |
| Mark Wells | Conservative | 969 |
| Guy Aston | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 637 |
| John Andrews | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 270 |
| Darren Robinson | Green | 115 |
Wheatley1 seat · turnout 51.1%
| Moira Hood | Labour | 2,017 ✓ |
| Roy Penketh | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 1,539 |
| Liz Hall | Liberal Democrats | 1,429 |
