Before (end of 2010) (37 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 21 · Liberal Democrats 14 · Other 2 · Labour 0
After (end of 2011) (37 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 21 · Liberal Democrats 11 · Other 3 · Labour 2
Ward results
Bardney1 seat · turnout 41.6%
| Ian Gordon Fleetwood | Conservative | 508 ✓ |
| Sharon Ann Spicer | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 203 |
Caistor2 seats · turnout 42.0%
| Alan Caine | Independent | 779 ✓ |
| Angela Lawrence | Conservative | 665 ✓ |
| Deborah Barker | Conservative | 541 |
| Cheryl Turner | Liberal Democrats | 278 |
Cherry Willingham2 seats · turnout 43.8%
| Irmgard Parrott | Conservative | 980 ✓ |
| Anne Welburn | Conservative | 821 ✓ |
| Stephen Trevor | Liberal Democrats | 392 |
| Wendy Beckett | Labour | 368 |
| Brian Gulliver | Labour | 349 |
Dunholme1 seat · turnout 42.4%
| Sue Rawlins | Conservative | 565 ✓ |
| Melanie Jackson | Liberal Democrats | 260 |
Fiskerton1 seat · turnout 48.2%
| Christopher Darcel | Independent | 370 ✓ |
| Meg Davidson | Conservative | 351 |
| Carol Pearson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 49 |
| Ian Nelson | Liberal Democrats | 44 |
GAINSBOROUGH EAST3 seats · turnout 21.2%
| M Stankey | Liberal Democrats | 591 ✓ |
| Michael Tinker | Liberal Democrats | 583 ✓ |
| Richy Doran | Labour | 422 ✓ |
| Kristian Smith | Liberal Democrats | 358 |
| Dorothy Dawson | Conservative | 322 |
| Alexander Bridgwood | Conservative | 227 |
| Sebastian Stenson | Conservative | 196 |
Gainsborough North3 seats · turnout 23.4%
| Gillian Bardsley | Conservative | 675 ✓ |
| David Dobbie | Liberal Democrats | 498 ✓ |
| Nigel Bowler | Labour | 479 ✓ |
| Robin Perry | Liberal Democrats | 458 |
| Julian Myers | Conservative | 453 |
| Mark Binns | Liberal Democrats | 431 |
| Robert Webb | Conservative | 390 |
| Pearl Banyard | Independent | 325 |
GAINSBOROUGH SOUTH WEST2 seats · turnout 24.9%
| Judy Rainsforth | Liberal Democrats | 698 ✓ |
| Trevor Young | Liberal Democrats | 674 ✓ |
| Alan Beverley | Conservative | 236 |
| Stephen Beer | Conservative | 202 |
Hemswell1 seat · turnout 47.0%
| Paul Howitt-Cowan | Conservative | 444 ✓ |
| Steve Pritchard | Liberal Democrats | 332 |
| Tony Wells | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 78 |
Kelsey1 seat · turnout 47.6%
| Lewis Strange | Conservative | 817 ✓ |
| Robert Heathorn | Liberal Democrats | 219 |
Lea1 seat · turnout 50.2%
| Jessie Milne | Conservative | 598 ✓ |
| Ian Parsons | Independent | 259 |
| Callum Newton | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 59 |
Market Rasen2 seats · turnout 33.7%
| Burton Keimach | Conservative | 833 ✓ |
| Kenneth Bridger | Liberal Democrats | 791 ✓ |
| Adam Ramsey | Conservative | 771 |
| Brian Charles Richardson | Liberal Democrats | 520 |
Middle Rasen1 seat · turnout 48.7%
| Geoffrey Wiseman | Conservative | 578 ✓ |
| Guy Grainger | Liberal Democrats | 378 |
| Michael Ranby | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 232 |
Nettleham2 seats · turnout 55.8%
| Raymond Sellars | Liberal Democrats | 1,238 ✓ |
| Malcolm Leaning | Liberal Democrats | 1,108 ✓ |
| Giles McNeill | Conservative | 804 |
| Eleanor Ramsey | Conservative | 559 |
Saxilby2 seats · turnout 38.2%
| Jago Barnabas York Brockway | Conservative | 1,155 ✓ |
| David John Cotton | Liberal Democrats | 921 ✓ |
| Colin Sharples | Independent | 827 |
| Christopher Walker | Liberal Democrats | 369 |
Scampton1 seat · turnout 46.6%
| Roger Patterson | Conservative | 414 ✓ |
| Heather Shore | Liberal Democrats | 404 |
| Rachel Heskins | Labour | 223 |
| David Walton | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 70 |
Scotter2 seats · turnout 46.9%
| Christopher Underwood-Frost | Conservative | 1,164 ✓ |
| William Parry | Conservative | 934 ✓ |
| E. Clarke | Independent | 623 |
| Neil Taylor | Liberal Democrats | 332 |
STOW1 seat · turnout 49.9%
| Reginald Shore | Liberal Democrats | 650 ✓ |
| Peter Francis McNeill | Conservative | 299 |
SUDBROOKE1 seat · turnout 53.5%
| Stuart Curtis | Conservative | 860 ✓ |
| Melanie Tointon | Labour | 289 |
Thonock1 seat · turnout 37.3%
| Lesley Rollings | Liberal Democrats | 523 ✓ |
| Colin Wotherspoon | Conservative | 300 |
Torksey1 seat · turnout 46.2%
| Stuart Kinch | Conservative | 698 ✓ |
| John Ridley | Liberal Democrats | 401 |
Waddingham and Spital1 seat · turnout 48.5%
| Jeff Summers | Conservative | 643 ✓ |
| Andrew Heathorn | Liberal Democrats | 199 |
| John Beaver | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 126 |
Welton2 seats · turnout 37.6%
| Malcolm Parish | Conservative | 1,102 ✓ |
| Diana Rodgers | Independent | 997 ✓ |
| Adam Duguid | Conservative | 691 |
| Peter Heath | Liberal Democrats | 543 |
Wold View1 seat · turnout 39.3%
| Tom Regis | Conservative | 481 ✓ |
| John Hadlow | Liberal Democrats | 293 |
Yarborough1 seat · turnout 48.1%
| Owen Bierley | Conservative | 465 ✓ |
| John Indian | Labour | 377 |
| Paul Barrett | Liberal Democrats | 62 |