Before (end of 2010) (39 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 26 · Liberal Democrats 8 · Labour 4 · Other 1
After (end of 2011) (39 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 29 · Labour 5 · Liberal Democrats 4 · Other 1
Ward results
Ashbourne North2 seats · turnout 30.9%
| Steve Bull | Conservative | 785 ✓ |
| Tony Millward | Conservative | 673 ✓ |
| Rob Whyman | Labour | 407 |
Ashbourne South2 seats · turnout 36.8%
| Andrew Lewer | Conservative | 883 ✓ |
| Tom Donnelly | Conservative | 583 ✓ |
| Che Page | Labour | 464 |
Bakewell3 seats · turnout 37.7%
| Judith Twigg | Conservative | 1,378 ✓ |
| Carol Ann Walker | Conservative | 1,245 ✓ |
| Philippa Tilbrook | Conservative | 1,121 ✓ |
| Pam Russell | Labour | 773 |
Bradwell1 seat · turnout 50.9%
| Janet Goodison | Conservative | 430 ✓ |
| Christopher Furness | Independent | 364 |
Brailsford1 seat · turnout 51.8%
| Angus David Jenkins | Conservative | 517 ✓ |
| Alan Hodkinson | Independent | 181 |
Calver1 seat
| Maxine Hunt | Conservative | 0 |
Carsington Water1 seat
| Lewis Michael Rose | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Chatsworth1 seat
| Michael Longden | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Clifton and Bradley1 seat · turnout 66.4%
| Andrew John Sewallis Carr Shirley | Conservative | 512 ✓ |
| Ian Bates | Independent | 326 |
| Charles Swabey | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 86 |
Darley Dale3 seats · turnout 43.9%
| David Fearn | Liberal Democrats | 731 ✓ |
| David Burton | Liberal Democrats | 729 ✓ |
| Andrew Paul Statham | Conservative | 720 ✓ |
| Nigel Allwood | Liberal Democrats | 694 |
| Katherine Staves | Conservative | 688 |
| Neil MacPherson | Conservative | 610 |
| Julie Morrison | Labour | 578 |
| Finn Page | Labour | 554 |
| Phil Rogers | Labour | 512 |
Dovedale and Parwich1 seat · turnout 54.7%
| Richard Ranulph Fitzherbert | Conservative | 594 ✓ |
| Eric Page | Labour | 181 |
Doveridge & Sudbury1 seat · turnout 52.5%
| Albert Joseph Phineous Catt | Conservative | 660 ✓ |
| Katy Brown | Labour | 148 |
Hartington & Taddington1 seat
| David Chapman | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Hathersage and Eyam2 seats
| Jacqueline Bevan | Conservative | 962 ✓ |
| Jean Monks | Conservative | 728 ✓ |
| Briony Robinson | Labour | 605 |
| Valerie Robinson | Labour | 562 |
| David Hoskin | Liberal Democrats | 359 |
| Jim Tweeddale | Liberal Democrats | 352 |
Hulland1 seat
| Richard Bright | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Lathkill and Bradford1 seat · turnout 55.5%
| David Frederickson | Independent | 390 ✓ |
| Mitch Blythe | Conservative | 349 |
Litton and Longstone1 seat
| Neil Horton | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Masson2 seats · turnout 45.3%
| Garry William Purdy | Conservative | 593 ✓ |
| Bob Cartwright | Labour | 571 ✓ |
| Peter Hume | Conservative | 566 |
| Nick Whitehead | Labour | 534 |
Matlock All Saints3 seats · turnout 42.2%
| Sue Burfoot | Liberal Democrats | 931 ✓ |
| Garrick Stevens | Conservative | 808 ✓ |
| Aaron Elliott | Conservative | 796 ✓ |
| David Barker | Liberal Democrats | 789 |
| Sam Gregory | Conservative | 730 |
| David Jones | Liberal Democrats | 715 |
| Andrew Botham | Labour | 709 |
Matlock St Giles3 seats · turnout 52.1%
| Steve Flitter | Liberal Democrats | 950 ✓ |
| Barrie Tipping | Conservative | 716 ✓ |
| Jacquie Stevens | Conservative | 691 ✓ |
| Barry Hopkinson | Liberal Democrats | 670 |
| Cate Hopkinson | Liberal Democrats | 655 |
| Sally Belinda Davies | Labour | 632 |
| Richard Philip Walsh | Conservative | 604 |
| Simon Peters | Labour | 562 |
Norbury1 seat
| J Wild | Conservative | 246 |
| J Morrison | Labour | 173 |
| Anthony Allwood | Liberal Democrats | 84 |
| Kenneth Bull | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Stanton1 seat · turnout 34.1%
| J. Wild | Conservative | 246 ✓ |
| J. Morrison | Labour | 173 |
| A. Allwood | Liberal Democrats | 84 |
Tideswell1 seat · turnout 71.6%
| Gwyn Bowers | Conservative | 338 |
| Susan Barber | Liberal Democrats | 244 |
| Lytton Page | Labour | 157 |
Winster and South Darley1 seat · turnout 62.1%
| Colin Swindell | Labour | 690 ✓ |
| Rebecca Swindell | Conservative | 187 |
Wirksworth3 seats · turnout 42.8%
| Irene Ratcliffe | Labour | 1,293 ✓ |
| Peter Slack | Labour | 1,048 ✓ |
| Mike Ratcliffe | Labour | 1,023 ✓ |
| Philip Cope | Conservative | 626 |
| Christopher John Spencer | Green | 532 |
| Sue Bull | Conservative | 517 |
| Josh Stockell | Green | 484 |
| John Russell Smith | Conservative | 474 |
