Before (end of 2010) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 39 · Other 8 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Labour 1
After (end of 2011) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 38 · Other 10 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Labour 0
Ward results
Banstead Village1 seat · turnout 43.6%
| Lynne Hack | Conservative | 1,805 ✓ |
| Christopher Byrne | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 373 |
| Andrew Bonser | Labour | 320 |
| Christopher Howell | Liberal Democrats | 302 |
Chipstead, Hooley and Woodmansterne1 seat · turnout 40.0%
| John Matthew Stephenson | Conservative | 1,780 ✓ |
| Moray Carey | Liberal Democrats | 464 |
| Peter Richards-Jones | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 410 |
Earlswood & Whitebushes1 seat · turnout 38.2%
| Barbara Thomson | Conservative | 1,011 ✓ |
| Bob Fromant | Labour | 706 |
| Jane Kulka | Liberal Democrats | 448 |
| Joseph Brian Fox | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 304 |
Horley Central1 seat · turnout 34.9%
| Anna Lynch | Conservative | 1,067 ✓ |
| Linda Jane Mabbett | Labour | 460 |
| Tim Deevoy | Liberal Democrats | 356 |
| Christian Stevens | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 276 |
Horley West1 seat · turnout 38.1%
| Michael Miller | Conservative | 1,156 ✓ |
| Gerry O'Dwyer | Labour | 380 |
| Denese Brooke-Harte | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 343 |
| Barry Hamilton | Liberal Democrats | 337 |
Kingswood with Burgh Heath1 seat · turnout 42.2%
| Ros Mill | Conservative | 1,745 ✓ |
| Robert Cambridge | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 535 |
Meadvale & St John's1 seat
| Graham Norman | Liberal Democrats | 1,294 ✓ |
| Patricia Shillinglaw | Conservative | 1,071 |
| Natalie Walton | Labour | 330 |
Merstham1 seat · turnout 40.5%
| Frank Kelly | Conservative | 1,008 ✓ |
| Stephen O'Shea | Liberal Democrats | 541 |
| Patricia Johnson | Labour | 478 |
| Phyllis Cambridge | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 295 |
Nork1 seat · turnout 43.5%
| Michael Selby | NorkRA | 1,902 ✓ |
| Pauline Tweedale | Conservative | 630 |
Preston1 seat · turnout 33.9%
| Gemma Harper-Adamson | Independent | 250 ✓ |
| Victor Parks | Labour | 205 |
| Anthony Blackcoe | Conservative | 203 |
Redhill East1 seat · turnout 41.5%
| Sarah Finch | Green | 1,281 ✓ |
| Michael Blacker | Conservative | 901 |
| Rosemary Norgrove | Labour | 370 |
| Robert Kulka | Liberal Democrats | 219 |
| John Hill | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 131 |
Redhill West1 seat · turnout 44.4%
| Julian Marc Ellacott | Conservative | 1,174 ✓ |
| Ronald Williams | Labour | 575 |
| Philip Wilson | Green | 350 |
| Andrew James Cressy | Liberal Democrats | 293 |
| Tony Pearson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 224 |
Reigate Central1 seat · turnout 47.2%
| Steve Farrer | Conservative | 1,236 ✓ |
| Helen Kulka | Liberal Democrats | 892 |
| Graham Richard Wildridge | Labour | 282 |
| Stephen Smith | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 168 |
Salfords and Sidlow1 seat · turnout 42.4%
| Dorothy Ross-Tomlin | Conservative | 673 ✓ |
| Terry Fromant | Labour | 197 |
South Park & Woodhatch1 seat
| Carol Eleanor Poulter | Conservative | 1,033 ✓ |
| John Michael Berge | Labour | 552 |
| Anthony Lambell | Liberal Democrats | 382 |
| Philip Taylor | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 261 |
Tadworth and Walton1 seat · turnout 47.7%
| Michael Vivona | Conservative | 1,885 ✓ |
| Alanna Coombes | Liberal Democrats | 442 |
| Vicky Moore | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 293 |
Tattenhams1 seat · turnout 42.2%
| Nick Harrison | TattsRA | 1,850 ✓ |
| Philip Abimbola Olanipekun | Conservative | 402 |
| Sarah Mabika-Buwu | Labour | 127 |