Before (end of 2010) (41 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 29 · Labour 9 · Other 3 · Liberal Democrats 0
After (end of 2011) (41 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 29 · Labour 10 · Other 2 · Liberal Democrats 0
Ward results
Appleton Roebuck1 seat · turnout 57.7%
| Richard Musgrave | Conservative | 537 ✓ |
| Brian Percival | Independent | 168 |
| Laurence Waterhouse | Labour | 132 |
Barlby2 seats · turnout 33.7%
| Stephanie Duckett | Labour | 673 ✓ |
| Brian Marshall | Labour | 655 ✓ |
| Karl Arthur | Conservative | 414 |
| Mark Sutherland | Conservative | 332 |
Brayton3 seats · turnout 41.1%
| Iain Nutt | Conservative | 1,159 ✓ |
| Mark Crane | Conservative | 1,159 ✓ |
| Ian Chilvers | Conservative | 1,149 ✓ |
| Brian Rogerson | Labour | 843 |
| Andy Williams | Labour | 821 |
| Graham Gatman | Labour | 779 |
Camblesforth2 seats · turnout 30.6%
| Ann Spetch | Conservative | 704 ✓ |
| Rodney Price | Labour | 656 ✓ |
| Rachael Hudson | Conservative | 653 |
Cawood with Wistow2 seats · turnout 44.2%
| John Cattanach | Conservative | 1,254 ✓ |
| Keith Ellis | Conservative | 1,035 ✓ |
| Karen Packham | Labour | 495 |
| Eric Beechey | Labour | 392 |
Eggborough2 seats · turnout 44.0%
| John McCartney | Independent | 819 ✓ |
| Mary McCartney | Independent | 691 ✓ |
| Liam Cooper | Conservative | 395 |
| Lynne Hutchinson | Conservative | 351 |
| Anne Riley | Labour | 162 |
| Kevin Barry Riley | Labour | 136 |
Fairburn with Brotherton2 seats · turnout 37.1%
| Jack Crawford | Labour | 593 ✓ |
| Andrew Pound | Conservative | 550 ✓ |
| Damian White | Conservative | 485 |
| Ian Mason | Labour | 422 |
Hambleton3 seats · turnout 42.0%
| Clive Pearson | Conservative | 1,236 ✓ |
| Cliff Lunn | Conservative | 1,158 ✓ |
| Ruth Sayner | Conservative | 1,063 ✓ |
| Rosie Corrigan | Labour | 647 |
| Susan Andrew | Labour | 625 |
| Gavin Nigel Xavier Harding | Labour | 619 |
Hemingbrough2 seats · turnout 37.5%
| Kay McSherry | Conservative | 713 ✓ |
| James Deans | Conservative | 633 ✓ |
| David McSherry | Independent | 606 |
| Ian Stevens | Labour | 436 |
Monk Fryston and South Milford2 seats · turnout 41.6%
| Carol Mackman | Conservative | 831 ✓ |
| John Mackman | Conservative | 794 ✓ |
| Judy Snowball | Labour | 494 |
| Barry Johnson | Labour | 476 |
North Duffield1 seat · turnout 46.8%
| Bill Inness | Conservative | 506 ✓ |
| Margaret Thurlow | Labour | 203 |
Riccall with Escrick2 seats · turnout 39.0%
| Elizabeth Casling | Conservative | 909 ✓ |
| Ian Reynolds | Conservative | 713 ✓ |
| John Duggan | Independent | 608 |
| Paul Harvey | Labour | 378 |
Saxton and Ulleskelf1 seat · turnout 47.8%
| Eileen Metcalfe | Conservative | 546 ✓ |
| Gregory Lodge | Labour | 302 |
Selby North3 seats · turnout 25.4%
| Melanie Davis | Labour | 738 ✓ |
| Jude Thurlow | Labour | 711 ✓ |
| Steve Shaw-Wright | Labour | 711 ✓ |
| Ian Rodney Lawton | Conservative | 470 |
| Rachael Peacock | Conservative | 414 |
| Jonathan Meehan | Conservative | 379 |
Selby South2 seats · turnout 28.4%
| Doreen Davies | Labour | 647 ✓ |
| Wendy Ruth Nichols | Labour | 590 ✓ |
| Douglas Calvert | Conservative | 317 |
| John Warburton | Conservative | 273 |
Selby West2 seats · turnout 41.4%
| Michael Dyson | Conservative | 666 ✓ |
| Dave Peart | Conservative | 665 ✓ |
| Jennifer Winifred Shaw-Wright | Labour | 631 |
| Craig Laskey | Labour | 571 |
Sherburn in Elmet3 seats · turnout 39.4%
| Mike Jordan | Conservative | 1,117 ✓ |
| Bob Packham | Labour | 1,035 ✓ |
| Melvin Hobson | Conservative | 1,025 ✓ |
| Neville Martin | Labour | 1,024 |
| Janet Marshall | Labour | 957 |
| Andrew Parmenter | Conservative | 907 |
Tadcaster East2 seats · turnout 31.9%
| Richard Sweeting | Conservative | 595 ✓ |
| Pat Mackay | Conservative | 580 ✓ |
| Stephen Cobb | Labour | 404 |
| Roderick Parker | Liberal Democrats | 344 |
Tadcaster West2 seats · turnout 37.2%
| Don Mackay | Conservative | 867 ✓ |
| Chris Metcalfe | Conservative | 757 ✓ |
| Ted Mansfield | Labour | 451 |
Whitley2 seats · turnout 40.8%
| Gillian Ivey | Conservative | 1,003 ✓ |
| Susan Ryder | Conservative | 884 ✓ |
| Jeremy Islwyn Trevor Davies | Labour | 506 |
| Rodney Possnett | Labour | 378 |
