Before (end of 2010) (35 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 20 · Labour 15 · Other 0 · Liberal Democrats 0
After (end of 2011) (35 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 18 · Conservative 17 · Liberal Democrats 0 · Other 0
Ward results
Arley & Whitacre3 seats · turnout 39.9%
| Karen Barber | Conservative | 852 ✓ |
| Nigel Turley | Labour | 823 ✓ |
| Carol Fox | Conservative | 788 ✓ |
| Sharon Moss | Labour | 770 |
| Pam Cotton | Conservative | 730 |
| Richard Hancocks | Independent | 252 |
Atherstone Central2 seats · turnout 31.8%
| Lorna Dirveiks | Labour | 555 ✓ |
| Neil Dirveiks | Labour | 524 ✓ |
| Tony Wright | Conservative | 431 |
| Denise Clews | Conservative | 423 |
Atherstone North2 seats · turnout 40.2%
| Anne Forwood | Labour | 599 ✓ |
| Derek Pickard | Labour | 554 ✓ |
| Gill Davis | Conservative | 522 |
| Martin Shaw | Conservative | 522 |
Atherstone South & Mancetter2 seats · turnout 42.8%
| Lorraine Freer | Conservative | 672 ✓ |
| Martin Davis | Conservative | 659 ✓ |
| Richard Jarvis | Labour | 603 |
| Ceri Short | Labour | 560 |
Baddesley & Grendon2 seats · turnout 36.1%
| John Moore | Labour | 712 ✓ |
| Raymond Sweet | Labour | 681 ✓ |
| Margaret Manley | Conservative | 468 |
| Margaret Smith | Conservative | 364 |
Coleshill North2 seats · turnout 42.2%
| Dominic Ferro | Labour | 566 ✓ |
| Peter Fowler | Conservative | 561 ✓ |
| Adam Farrell | Labour | 544 |
| Jeremy Bowden | Conservative | 516 |
Coleshill South2 seats · turnout 38.8%
| Amanda Watkins | Conservative | 681 ✓ |
| Gordon Sherratt | Conservative | 664 ✓ |
| Claire Breeze | Labour | 396 |
| Chris Bain | Labour | 381 |
Curdworth2 seats · turnout 39.0%
| Jeane Lea | Conservative | 906 ✓ |
| Mark Simpson | Conservative | 757 ✓ |
| Celia Banner | Labour | 249 |
| Michael Banner | Labour | 230 |
Dordon2 seats · turnout 33.4%
| Peter Frank Morson | Labour | 578 ✓ |
| John Winter | Labour | 541 ✓ |
| Dave Hanratty | Conservative | 229 |
| Susan Hanratty | Conservative | 190 |
| Steve Fowler | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 126 |
Fillongley2 seats · turnout 38.5%
| Colin Hayfield | Conservative | 812 ✓ |
| Leslie John Smith | Conservative | 733 ✓ |
| Roger Ball | Labour | 339 |
| Mary Phillips | Labour | 248 |
Hartshill2 seats · turnout 33.5%
| Kath Johnston | Conservative | 516 ✓ |
| Tim Wykes | Conservative | 502 ✓ |
| Kieren Moss | Labour | 500 |
| Carla Morson | Labour | 472 |
Hurley & Wood End2 seats · turnout 36.5%
| Ann Lewis | Labour | 671 ✓ |
| Hayden Phillips | Labour | 630 ✓ |
| Richard Freer | Conservative | 320 |
| Howard Smith | Conservative | 293 |
| Ian Thomas | Independent | 163 |
| Tony Moppett | Independent | 158 |
Kingsbury2 seats · turnout 39.9%
| Brian Moss | Labour | 674 ✓ |
| Margaret Moss | Labour | 604 ✓ |
| Stuart Thomas Swann | Conservative | 499 |
| Dave Moffatt | Conservative | 414 |
| Andy Jenns | Independent | 123 |
| Carol Ann Ayasamy | Independent | 93 |
Newton Regis & Warton2 seats · turnout 44.2%
| Tilly May | Conservative | 838 ✓ |
| David Humphreys | Conservative | 798 ✓ |
| Elanor Pugh | Labour | 457 |
| Owen Phillips | Labour | 383 |
Polesworth East2 seats · turnout 42.6%
| Matt Stanley | Labour | 815 ✓ |
| Yvette Stanley | Labour | 767 ✓ |
| Karen Mercer-West | Conservative | 351 |
| Colin Peat | Conservative | 342 |
Polesworth West2 seats · turnout 38.1%
| Daniel Butcher | Labour | 601 ✓ |
| Alison Stanley | Labour | 566 ✓ |
| Lee Clarke | Conservative | 485 |
| Wendy Smitten | Conservative | 476 |
Water Orton2 seats · turnout 47.5%
| Raymond Payne | Conservative | 878 ✓ |
| Allan Holland | Conservative | 726 ✓ |
| Daniel Hodkinson | Labour | 610 |
| Tom Foley | Labour | 504 |