Before (end of 2010) (30 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 14 · Other 9 · Liberal Democrats 7 · Labour 0
After (end of 2011) (30 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 20 · Other 8 · Liberal Democrats 2 · Labour 0
Ward results
Amotherby1 seat · turnout 44.9%
| John Hicks | Conservative | 451 ✓ |
| Jane Wilford | Liberal Democrats | 253 |
Ampleforth1 seat
| James Bailey | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Cropton1 seat · turnout 60.2%
| John Clark | LIB | 359 ✓ |
| Ena Dent | Conservative | 353 |
| Allan Richard Reynolds | Liberal Democrats | 57 |
Dales1 seat
| Janet Frank | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Derwent2 seats · turnout 42.2%
| John Fraser | Conservative | 719 ✓ |
| Caroline Goodrick | Conservative | 628 ✓ |
| Judith Scott | Independent | 410 |
| Marian Hodgson | Liberal Democrats | 329 |
| Heather Milner | Labour | 265 |
Helmsley2 seats
| George Hawkins | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| Stephen Arnold | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Hovingham1 seat
| R. Wainwright | Independent | 0 ✓ |
Kirkbymoorside2 seats · turnout 48.0%
| Sarah Ward | LIB | 730 ✓ |
| David Cussons | Conservative | 662 ✓ |
| Valerie Arnold | Conservative | 632 |
| Nelly Trevelyan | LIB | 562 |
| Peter Lerew | Liberal Democrats | 129 |
Malton3 seats · turnout 29.1%
| Paul Andrews | Independent | 639 ✓ |
| Lindsay Burr | Liberal Democrats | 559 ✓ |
| Adrian Hopkinson | Conservative | 518 ✓ |
| Howard Croft | Independent | 451 |
| Stephen Preston | Liberal Democrats | 361 |
| Martin Beaumont | Conservative | 351 |
| David White | Liberal Democrats | 292 |
| Tim Prest | Labour | 260 |
Norton East2 seats · turnout 25.8%
| Peter Walker | Independent | 418 ✓ |
| Elizabeth Lois Shields | Liberal Democrats | 405 ✓ |
| Howard Keal | Liberal Democrats | 332 |
| Stephen Shaw | Conservative | 270 |
| Hilary Lockwood | Conservative | 154 |
Norton West2 seats · turnout 32.6%
| Judith Denniss | Conservative | 353 ✓ |
| Luke Ives | Conservative | 327 ✓ |
| Dinah Keal | Liberal Democrats | 306 |
| Hugh Spencer | Liberal Democrats | 287 |
| Jeremy Powell | Independent | 263 |
| Karl Reveley | Labour | 137 |
| Phil Hancock | LIB | 102 |
Pickering East2 seats · turnout 52.0%
| Vivienne Knaggs | Conservative | 529 ✓ |
| Tommy Woodward | LIB | 474 ✓ |
| Nick King | Conservative | 432 |
| Sue Cowan | LIB | 419 |
| John Stott | Liberal Democrats | 192 |
| Geoff Randall | Labour | 181 |
Pickering West2 seats · turnout 30.0%
| Linda Cowling | Conservative | 588 ✓ |
| Luke Richardson | LIB | 472 ✓ |
| Natalie Warriner | Independent | 360 |
| Fred Downes | Labour | 225 |
| Adrian Wilford | Independent | 76 |
Rillington1 seat
| Brian Maud | Independent | 0 ✓ |
Ryedale South West1 seat · turnout 52.4%
| Keith Knaggs | Conservative | 458 ✓ |
| Denys Townsend | Independent | 256 |
Sherburn1 seat · turnout 34.9%
| John Raper | Conservative | 362 ✓ |
| Mike Beckett | Liberal Democrats | 190 |
Sheriff Hutton1 seat
| Eric Hope | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Sinnington1 seat · turnout 50.4%
| John Windress | Conservative | 533 ✓ |
| Abigail Stokell Beckett | Liberal Democrats | 189 |
Thornton Dale2 seats · turnout 38.7%
| Janet Sanderson | Conservative | 794 ✓ |
| Geoffrey Acomb | Conservative | 763 ✓ |
| David Porter | Liberal Democrats | 557 |
Wolds1 seat
| Edward Legard | Conservative | 0 ✓ |