Before (end of 2010) (43 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 25 · Other 14 · Liberal Democrats 4 · Labour 0
After (end of 2011) (43 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 27 · Other 13 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Labour 0
Ward results
| Ian Cartwright | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| Geoff Whittle | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Bassingham and Brant Broughton2 seats · turnout 36.5%
| Susan Howe | Conservative | 1,209 ✓ |
| Patricia Woodman | Conservative | 1,090 ✓ |
| Jamie Corney | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 438 |
| Gillian Ogden | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| Michael Powell | Independent | 0 ✓ |
Bracebridge Heath and Waddington East3 seats · turnout 26.3%
| Peter Burley | Conservative | 1,459 ✓ |
| Mike Gallagher | Conservative | 1,335 ✓ |
| Lindsey Cawrey | Conservative | 1,239 ✓ |
| Pat Nurse | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 708 |
| Tony Richardson | Liberal Democrats | 560 |
Branston2 seats · turnout 32.2%
| Ray Cucksey | Conservative | 1,059 ✓ |
| Jason Frost | Conservative | 805 ✓ |
| Bob Hill | Independent | 738 |
Cliff Villages2 seats · turnout 60.2%
| Marianne-Jane Overton | LincsInd | 1,538 ✓ |
| Laura Conway | LincsInd | 968 ✓ |
| Michael Wylie | Conservative | 870 |
| Jim Dixon | Conservative | 571 |
| Peter Carrell | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 164 |
| Sally Appleby | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| Barbara Wells | Independent | 0 ✓ |
Heckington Rural2 seats · turnout 40.7%
| Andrew Michael Key | Conservative | 1,369 ✓ |
| Stewart Ogden | Conservative | 1,098 ✓ |
| Liz Peto | LincsInd | 647 |
| Steven Talton | Labour | 440 |
Heighington & Washingborough3 seats · turnout 32.7%
| Ron Oxby | Conservative | 1,617 ✓ |
| Marion Brighton | Conservative | 1,537 ✓ |
| Ian Carrington | Conservative | 1,258 ✓ |
| Graham Peck | LincsInd | 890 |
Kirkby la Thorpe & South Kyme1 seat · turnout 44.7%
| David Dickinson | Conservative | 491 ✓ |
| Ken Hanslip | Independent | 254 |
| Robert Greetham | Liberal Democrats | 98 |
Leasingham and Rauceby1 seat · turnout 53.9%
| Susan Waring | Conservative | 544 ✓ |
| Fay Cooper | LincsInd | 398 |
Metheringham2 seats
| Rob Kendrick | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| John Frank Money | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
North Hykeham Forum1 seat · turnout 49.3%
| Kimberly Barrett | Liberal Democrats | 373 ✓ |
| Bob Jackling | Conservative | 357 |
| Ivan Hall | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 163 |
North Hykeham Memorial1 seat · turnout 38.9%
| Wallace Lee | Liberal Democrats | 334 ✓ |
| Mark Nind | Conservative | 320 |
| Fay Price | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 168 |
North Hykeham Mill2 seats · turnout 28.9%
| Andrea Clarke | Conservative | 495 ✓ |
| Helen Clark | Independent | 463 ✓ |
| Susannah Spencer | — | 458 |
| Eric Moss-Wright | Conservative | 314 |
North Hykeham Moor1 seat · turnout 37.6%
| John Bishop | Liberal Democrats | 410 ✓ |
| Dan Ridgeway-Adams | Conservative | 320 |
North Hykeham Witham1 seat
| Ross Little | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Osbournby1 seat · turnout 50.9%
| Jim Cook | Independent | 661 ✓ |
| Lucille Hagues | Conservative | 289 |
Ruskington2 seats
| Richard Andrew Wright | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| Terry Boston | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Skellingthorpe2 seats · turnout 40.7%
| Christopher Goldson | Independent | 975 ✓ |
| Shirley Flint | Independent | 798 ✓ |
| Mike Thompson | Conservative | 263 |
| Mark Heaton | Conservative | 151 |
| Nick Smith | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 78 |
Sleaford Castle1 seat · turnout 36.9%
| Keith Dolby | Independent | 492 ✓ |
| Tim Conning | Conservative | 225 |
Sleaford Holdingham1 seat · turnout 37.5%
| Peter Haysum | Independent | 470 ✓ |
| Becky Dunbar-Beckford | Conservative | 254 |
Sleaford Navigation1 seat · turnout 37.6%
| David Suiter | — | 545 ✓ |
| Alan Ford | Conservative | 185 |
Sleaford Quarrington & Mareham3 seats · turnout 31.0%
| Geoffrey Hazelwood | Conservative | 1,014 ✓ |
| Ian Dolby | Independent | 941 ✓ |
| Mark Guy Allan | Conservative | 863 ✓ |
| Garry Titmus | Conservative | 813 |
| Stewart James | Independent | 698 |
| Ken Fernandes | LincsInd | 611 |
Sleaford Westholme1 seat · turnout 36.9%
| Brian Walter Joseph Edward Watson | Independent | 581 ✓ |
| Rachel Hubbard | Conservative | 150 |
Waddington West1 seat
| Lance Pennell | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
