Before (end of 2010) (63 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 50 · Conservative 10 · Other 3 · Liberal Democrats 0
After (end of 2011) (63 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 54 · Conservative 7 · Other 2 · Liberal Democrats 0
Ward results
Anston & Woodsetts1 seat
| Judith Dalton | Labour | 1,562 ✓ |
| S. Edmundson | Conservative | 965 |
| C. Jepson | Independent | 462 |
| S. Thornton | Independent | 406 |
| Denise Hickson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 326 |
| C. Foulstone | Green | 164 |
Boston Castle1 seat · turnout 44.0%
| Peter Wootton | Labour | 1,836 ✓ |
| Ashiq Hussain | Conservative | 1,156 |
| Harry Woffenden | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 606 |
| Eric Shaw | Liberal Democrats | 303 |
| Christopher Bingham | TUSC | 211 |
Brinsworth and Catcliffe1 seat
| Andrew Scott Roddison | Labour | 2,147 ✓ |
| Michael Cooke | Conservative | 668 |
| Terry Fieldhouse | BNP | 581 |
Dinnington1 seat · turnout 35.0%
| Jane Havenhand | Labour | 1,725 ✓ |
| Patricia Beighton | Conservative | 761 |
| David Smith | Independent | 465 |
| Martin Hickson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 324 |
Hellaby1 seat · turnout 41.8%
| Jennifer Andrews | Labour | 1,638 ✓ |
| Brian Cutts | Conservative | 1,550 |
| Douglas Fairfax | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 664 |
Holderness1 seat · turnout 37.3%
| Lyndsay Pitchley | Labour | 2,450 ✓ |
| Keith Hunter | Conservative | 1,089 |
Hoober1 seat · turnout 35.9%
| Jane Elizabeth Hamilton | Labour | 1,948 ✓ |
| Michael Pallant | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 572 |
| Brian Taylor | Conservative | 549 |
| Steven Scutt | Liberal Democrats | 155 |
Keppel1 seat · turnout 39.6%
| Barry Kaye | Labour | 1,812 ✓ |
| David Cutts | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 866 |
| Michael Robinson | Conservative | 699 |
| Janice Middleton | Liberal Democrats | 314 |
Maltby1 seat · turnout 35.0%
| Christine Beaumont | Labour | 1,881 ✓ |
| Michael Burke | BNP | 388 |
| J Kirk | Independent | 370 |
| Derek Johnson | Conservative | 322 |
| Michael Conlon | Independent | 215 |
Rawmarsh1 seat · turnout 33.0%
| Neil Hamilton | Labour | 1,911 ✓ |
| Matthew Nichols | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 470 |
| James Taylor | Conservative | 446 |
| William Baldwin | BNP | 327 |
Rother Vale1 seat · turnout 33.8%
| John Swift | Labour | 1,884 ✓ |
| David Ridgeway | Independent | 628 |
| Doris Hunter | Conservative | 562 |
Rotherham East1 seat · turnout 33.5%
| Barry Dodson | Labour | 1,951 ✓ |
| Matthew Stevenson | BNP | 369 |
| Mozalfa Ilyas | Liberal Democrats | 328 |
| Christian Carl Backer Kramer | Conservative | 269 |
| Barry Ross | Lilburne | 128 |
Rotherham West1 seat · turnout 37.3%
| John Foden | Labour | 2,130 ✓ |
| Caven Vines | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 941 |
| Anne Middleton | Conservative | 368 |
Silverwood1 seat · turnout 37.0%
| Roger Stone | Labour | 1,700 ✓ |
| John Wilkinson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 1,079 |
| Steve Jones | Conservative | 750 |
Sitwell1 seat · turnout 46.1%
| John Gilding | Conservative | 1,899 ✓ |
| Tajamal Khan | Labour | 1,545 |
| Valerie Wilkinson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 938 |
Swinton1 seat · turnout 38.2%
| John Doyle | Labour | 2,135 ✓ |
| Shaun O'Dell | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 823 |
| Beryl Brown | Conservative | 463 |
Valley1 seat · turnout 34.8%
| Paul Lakin | Labour | 2,034 ✓ |
| Valerie Todd | Conservative | 639 |
| Jason Pearson | BNP | 468 |
Wales1 seat · turnout 44.6%
| Dominic Edward Beck | Labour | 2,089 ✓ |
| Gillian Shaw | Conservative | 1,160 |
| Dennis Flynn | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 600 |
Wath1 seat · turnout 38.6%
| William Sangster | Labour | 2,080 ✓ |
| B Bailey | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 917 |
| Leigh Higgins | Conservative | 524 |
Wickersley1 seat · turnout 41.1%
| Christopher Read | Labour | 1,717 ✓ |
| Robert Foulds | Independent | 1,058 |
| Donald Ross | Conservative | 596 |
| Tina Dowdall | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 483 |
| Tina Dowdall | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 458 |
Wingfield1 seat · turnout 33.3%
| Terence Sharman | Labour | 1,648 ✓ |
| Marlene Guest | BNP | 514 |
| Maureen Vines | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 481 |
| Basil Hammond | Conservative | 363 |
