Before (end of 2011) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 38 · Other 10 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Labour 0
After (end of 2012) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 37 · Other 12 · Liberal Democrats 2 · Labour 0
Ward results
Banstead Village1 seat
| Eddy Humphreys | Conservative | 1,163 ✓ |
| Christopher Byrne | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 338 |
| Andrew Bonser | Labour | 214 |
| Philip Wilson | Green | 146 |
| Keith Foreman | Conservative | 895 ✓ |
| Richard Wagner | — | 757 |
| Steven David Alfred Russell | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 215 |
| Patricia Johnson | Labour | 185 |
| Moray Carey | Liberal Democrats | 103 |
Earlswood & Whitebushes1 seat
| James Durrant | Conservative | 597 ✓ |
| Helen Young | Labour | 560 |
| Jane Kulka | Liberal Democrats | 260 |
| Katie Smith | Green | 242 |
| Joseph Brian Fox | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 229 |
Horley Central1 seat · turnout 25.3%
| Abdul Kayum | Conservative | 724 ✓ |
| Christian Stevens | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 348 |
| Linda Jane Mabbett | Labour | 326 |
| Tim Deevoy | Liberal Democrats | 178 |
Horley East1 seat
| Tony Schofield | Conservative | 824 ✓ |
| Bob Fromant | Labour | 222 |
| Sally Deevoy | Liberal Democrats | 201 |
Horley West1 seat
| Daniel Powell | Conservative | 666 ✓ |
| Denese Brooke-Harte | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 433 |
| Gerry O'Dwyer | Labour | 247 |
| Barry Hamilton | Liberal Democrats | 168 |
| Simon Parnall | Conservative | 1,115 ✓ |
| Bob Cambridge | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 413 |
| Gruffydd Williams | Labour | 155 |
Meadvale & St John's1 seat
| Patricia Shillinglaw | Conservative | 867 ✓ |
| Alanna Coombes | Liberal Democrats | 854 |
| Natalie Walton | Labour | 284 |
Merstham1 seat · turnout 30.0%
| Mark Brunt | Conservative | 785 ✓ |
| Julie Halford | Labour | 402 |
| Stephen O'Shea | Liberal Democrats | 251 |
| Vicky Moore | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 182 |
| Drummond Richardson | Green | 105 |
Nork1 seat
| Norman Harris | — | 1,361 ✓ |
| Julie Tomlinson | Conservative | 417 |
Redhill East1 seat · turnout 34.8%
| Bryn Truscott | Green | 1,216 ✓ |
| Rois Amiah | Conservative | 787 |
| Ronald Williams | Labour | 390 |
| Robert Kulka | Liberal Democrats | 108 |
Redhill West1 seat · turnout 32.6%
| Natalie Bramhall | Conservative | 812 ✓ |
| Stewart James Dack | Labour | 396 |
| Stephen McKenna | Green | 313 |
| Tony Pearson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 258 |
| Andrew James Cressy | Liberal Democrats | 164 |
Reigate Central1 seat
| Christopher Thomas Henry Whinney | Independent | 869 ✓ |
| Richard Coad | Conservative | 643 |
| Helen Kulka | Liberal Democrats | 314 |
| Graham Richard Wildridge | Labour | 167 |
| Stephen Smith | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 114 |
Reigate Hill1 seat · turnout 33.5%
| Roger Charles Newstead | Conservative | 853 ✓ |
| Christopher Howell | Liberal Democrats | 198 |
| Yvonne Larg | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 186 |
| Andrew David Saunders | Labour | 152 |
South Park & Woodhatch1 seat
| Stephen Thomas Bramhall | Conservative | 690 ✓ |
| John Michael Berge | Labour | 457 |
| Anthony Lambell | Liberal Democrats | 300 |
Tadworth and Walton1 seat
| Victor William Broad | Conservative | 1,154 ✓ |
| Phyllis Cambridge | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 292 |
| Hannah Martin | Liberal Democrats | 145 |
| Alistair Patrick Galbraith Morten | Green | 105 |
| Rebecca Spencer | Labour | 102 |
Tattenhams1 seat
| Jill Bray | — | 1,399 ✓ |
| Philip Abimbola Olanipekun | Conservative | 276 |