Before (end of 2011) (63 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 43 · Conservative 9 · Liberal Democrats 6 · Other 5
After (end of 2012) (63 seats, Elections Centre)
Labour 50 · Conservative 9 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Other 1
Ward results
Adwick1 seat · turnout 24.5%
| Ted Kitchen | Labour | 2,058 ✓ |
| David Farrell | Liberal Democrats | 358 |
| Kerry Wood | Conservative | 286 |
Armthorpe1 seat · turnout 28.9%
| Sue McGuinness | Labour | 1,677 ✓ |
| Scott Andrew Pickles | Independent | 1,289 |
| Chris Allen | Conservative | 226 |
Askern Spa1 seat · turnout 32.4%
| Austen William White | Labour | 2,269 ✓ |
| Martin Damian Greenhalgh | Conservative | 954 |
Balby1 seat · turnout 27.9%
| Nuala Fennelly | Labour | 1,436 ✓ |
| Mark Thompson | Independent | 1,136 |
| Richard Eaton | Conservative | 435 |
| Edwin Simpson | Liberal Democrats | 135 |
Bentley1 seat · turnout 27.0%
| Jane Nightingale | Labour | 1,750 ✓ |
| Barbara Hewitt | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 681 |
| Alexandra Allen | Conservative | 282 |
Bessacarr and Cantley1 seat
| Martin Cuthbert | Liberal Democrats | 1,764 ✓ |
| Paul Bissett | Labour | 1,230 |
| Mark Wells | Conservative | 623 |
| Glenn Bluff | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 535 |
Central1 seat · turnout 25.9%
| Glyn Jones | Labour | 1,957 ✓ |
| Howard Dove | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 533 |
| Ian Hutchinson | Conservative | 297 |
| Barbara Bell | Liberal Democrats | 226 |
Conisbrough and Denaby1 seat
| Christine Mills | Labour | 2,420 ✓ |
| Joanne Broughton | Conservative | 352 |
| Pat Hall | Labour | 1,409 ✓ |
| Keith Hewitt | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 731 |
| Karen Hampson | Liberal Democrats | 579 |
| Barbara Fletcher | Conservative | 518 |
| Karl Goodman | Independent | 437 |
Edlington And Warmsworth1 seat · turnout 32.7%
| Phil Cole | Labour | 1,830 ✓ |
| Raymond Mullis | Independent | 1,356 |
| Liz Jones | Conservative | 261 |
Finningley1 seat · turnout 36.6%
| Yvonne Woodcock | Conservative | 1,803 ✓ |
| Thomas Scott-Chambers | Labour | 1,237 |
| Nigel Berry | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 1,163 |
| John Brown | Liberal Democrats | 270 |
Great North Road1 seat · turnout 32.1%
| Debbie Hutchinson | Labour | 2,378 ✓ |
| Frank Calladine | Conservative | 643 |
| Stephen Platt | Green | 575 |
| Joan Butterfield | Liberal Democrats | 227 |
Hatfield1 seat · turnout 31.1%
| Pat Haith | Labour | 1,049 ✓ |
| Mick Glynn | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 827 |
| Jessie Jamieson Credland | Independent | 791 |
| James Vincent Hart | Conservative | 343 |
| Stewart Rayner | CG | 176 |
Mexborough1 seat · turnout 24.4%
| Tracey Joan Leyland-Jepson | Labour | 1,577 ✓ |
| Alan Pickering | Independent | 687 |
| Malcolm Jevons | Liberal Democrats | 472 |
| Phyllis Calladine | Conservative | 98 |
Rossington1 seat · turnout 28.0%
| Richard Cooper-Holmes | Labour | 1,581 ✓ |
| Terry Wilde | Independent | 880 |
| Margaret Beard | Conservative | 240 |
| Richard Andrew Johnson | Liberal Democrats | 108 |
Sprotbrough1 seat · turnout 36.4%
| Jonathan Blundell Wood | Conservative | 1,637 ✓ |
| Peter Millar | Labour | 1,565 |
| Diana Simpson | Liberal Democrats | 312 |
Stainforth and Moorends1 seat
| Ken Keegan | Labour | 1,627 ✓ |
| Martin Drake | Conservative | 436 |
| Dave Owen | DemNat | 410 |
Thorne1 seat · turnout 28.4%
| Martin Williams | CG | 1,442 ✓ |
| Susan Durant | Labour | 1,176 |
| Richard Walker | Conservative | 467 |
Torne Valley1 seat · turnout 36.6%
| Bob Ford | Conservative | 1,563 ✓ |
| Shane McAleavey | Labour | 1,112 |
| Rebecca Walters | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 643 |
| David Adgar | Liberal Democrats | 339 |
Town Moor1 seat · turnout 30.9%
| Paul Wray | Labour | 1,569 ✓ |
| Clifford Hampson | Liberal Democrats | 831 |
| Stephen Cox | Conservative | 432 |
| Michelle Goodman | Independent | 373 |
Wheatley1 seat · turnout 28.6%
| Eva Theresa Hughes | Labour | 1,696 ✓ |
| Roy Penketh | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 806 |
| Malcolm Knight | Conservative | 351 |
