Before (end of 2011) (34 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 11 · Liberal Democrats 10 · Other 7 · SNP 6 · Labour 0
After (end of 2012) (34 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 10 · Other 9 · SNP 9 · Liberal Democrats 6 · Labour 0
Ward results
East Berwickshire3 seats
| Michael Fife Cook | Independent | 1,236 ✓ |
| Jim Fullarton | Conservative | 730 ✓ |
| Joan Campbell | SNP | 541 ✓ |
| Kenryck Lloyd-Jones | Labour | 435 |
| Ken Webb | Liberal Democrats | 226 |
| Jack Johnston | Independent | 136 |
| Cat Macdonald-Home | — | 133 |
Galashiels and District4 seats
| Sandy Aitchison | — | 822 ✓ |
| Bill Herd | SNP | 766 ✓ |
| Bill White | Independent | 501 ✓ |
| John Mitchell | SNP | 492 ✓ |
| Rick Kenney | Liberal Democrats | 417 |
| Fiona Lackenby | Conservative | 386 |
| Robbie Tatler | Labour | 273 |
Hawick and Denholm3 seats
| Stuart Marshall | Independent | 1,734 ✓ |
| Zandra Elliot | Conservative | 427 ✓ |
| Alastair Cranston | SNP | 381 ✓ |
| Watson McAteer | Liberal Democrats | 263 |
| Michael Grieve | Labour | 147 |
| Mary Douglas | — | 75 |
| Craig Bryson | Independent | 30 |
Hawick and Hermitage3 seats
| Davie Paterson | Independent | 1,302 ✓ |
| Ronald Smith | Liberal Democrats | 525 ✓ |
| George Turnbull | Conservative | 513 ✓ |
| Tommy Stevenson | SNP | 239 |
| Bill Cumming | Labour | 191 |
| Frank Little | — | 82 |
| Kevin Ferguson | Green | 46 |
Jedburgh and District3 seats
| Jim Brown | SNP | 759 ✓ |
| Sandy Scott | Conservative | 702 ✓ |
| Rory Stewart | Independent | 549 ✓ |
| Len Wyse | Conservative | 413 |
| John Bathgate | Liberal Democrats | 388 |
| Trevor Jackson | — | 258 |
| David Sharp | Labour | 169 |
Kelso and District3 seats
| Tom Weatherston | Conservative | 777 ✓ |
| Alec Nicol | Liberal Democrats | 729 ✓ |
| Simon Mountford | Conservative | 463 ✓ |
| Maggie Stanfield | SNP | 413 |
| Yvonne Huggins-Haig | Independent | 324 |
| Diana Miers | — | 253 |
| Colin McGrath | Independent | 165 |
| Michael Scott | Green | 116 |
Leaderdale and Melrose3 seats
| David Parker | Independent | 1,304 ✓ |
| Nicholas Watson | — | 621 ✓ |
| Jim Torrance | SNP | 558 ✓ |
| Peter Duncan | Conservative | 441 |
| John Paton Day | Liberal Democrats | 439 |
| Agnes Craig | Labour | 225 |
Mid Berwickshire3 seats
| Donald Moffat | SNP | 1,133 ✓ |
| John Greenwell | Conservative | 747 ✓ |
| Frances Renton | Liberal Democrats | 635 ✓ |
| Tom Miers | — | 534 |
| Trevor Jones | Conservative | 432 |
Selkirkshire3 seats
| Michelle Ballantyne | Conservative | 799 ✓ |
| Kenneth Gunn | SNP | 671 |
| Vicky Davidson | Liberal Democrats | 649 ✓ |
| Gordon Edgar | Independent | 597 ✓ |
| Leven Brown | — | 299 |
| Gordon Harrison | Independent | 276 |
Tweeddale East3 seats
| Stuart Bell | SNP | 990 ✓ |
| Gavin Logan | Conservative | 929 ✓ |
| Graham Garvie | Liberal Democrats | 614 ✓ |
| Robin Tatler | Labour | 571 |
| Frances Pringle | — | 345 |
| David Cox | Independent | 300 |
Tweeddale West3 seats
| Catriona Bhatia | Liberal Democrats | 919 ✓ |
| Nathaniel Buckingham | Conservative | 885 ✓ |
| Willie Archibald | SNP | 780 ✓ |
| Julia Reid | Labour | 336 |
| Nancy Norman | Liberal Democrats | 334 |
| David Pye | — | 333 |