Before (end of 2014) (57 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 54 · Other 3 · Labour 0 · Liberal Democrats 0
After (end of 2015) (57 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 53 · Other 4 · Labour 0 · Liberal Democrats 0
Ward results
| Kevin Neil Deanus | Conservative | 678 ✓ |
| John Armstrong | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 178 |
| Connor Carey | Labour | 113 |
| Peter Hartley | Independent | 109 |
Blackheath and Wonersh1 seat
| Michael Goodridge | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| Maurice Byham | Conservative | 1,893 ✓ |
| Thomas Seaborne | Conservative | 1,707 ✓ |
| Carles Martinez | Labour | 555 |
Chiddingfold and Dunsfold2 seats
| Simon Inchbald | Conservative | 1,445 ✓ |
| John Wray | Conservative | 1,306 ✓ |
| Tony Johnson | Labour | 460 |
| Ian Mitchell | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 418 |
Cranleigh East3 seats · turnout 72.0%
| Mary Foryszewski | Conservative | 1,652 ✓ |
| Jeanette Stennett | Conservative | 1,600 ✓ |
| Stewart John Stennett | Conservative | 1,570 ✓ |
| Ken Reed | Liberal Democrats | 901 |
| Ruth Coleman-Taylor | Liberal Democrats | 879 |
| Ruth Reed | Liberal Democrats | 831 |
| David Inman | Independent | 600 |
| Michael West | Labour | 509 |
| Mark Liversedge | Labour | 490 |
Cranleigh West2 seats · turnout 72.4%
| Patricia Ellis | Conservative | 1,269 ✓ |
| Brian Ellis | Conservative | 1,155 ✓ |
| Louise Jones | Liberal Democrats | 685 |
| Chris Tew | Liberal Democrats | 515 |
| Lynda MacDermott | Labour | 321 |
| Daniel Nunn | Labour | 192 |
Elstead and Thursley2 seats
| Jenny Else | Conservative | 1,593 ✓ |
| David Else | Conservative | 1,376 ✓ |
| Bryn Morgan | Independent | 846 |
Ewhurst1 seat · turnout 78.6%
| Val Henry | Conservative | 703 ✓ |
| Diane James | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 406 |
| Gus Reed | Liberal Democrats | 137 |
Farnham Bourne2 seats
| Martin Jonathon Lear | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| Carole Cockburn | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Farnham Castle2 seats
| John Williamson | — | 1,043 ✓ |
| Paddy Blagden | Conservative | 797 ✓ |
| Stewart Edge | Liberal Democrats | 736 |
| Geoffrey Swann | Conservative | 641 |
| Celia Sandars | Labour | 438 |
Farnham Firgrove2 seats
| Jill Hargreaves | Conservative | 1,260 ✓ |
| Sam Pritchard | Conservative | 934 ✓ |
| Jon Austen | Green | 733 |
| Sylvia Jacobs | Liberal Democrats | 716 |
| David Paul Savage | Labour | 426 |
Farnham Hale and Heath End2 seats
| Mike Hodge | Conservative | 1,170 ✓ |
| Denise Marie-Reine Le Gal | Conservative | 917 ✓ |
| David Beaman | Independent | 696 |
| Maureen Hunt | Liberal Democrats | 523 |
| Rebecca Louise Kaye | Labour | 501 |
Farnham Moor Park2 seats
| Stephen Hill | Conservative | 1,086 ✓ |
| Andrew Macleod | Independent | 1,006 ✓ |
| Rachel Morris | Conservative | 918 |
| Judith Edge | Liberal Democrats | 638 |
| David Watts | Labour | 437 |
| David Munro | Conservative | 1,064 ✓ |
| Kika Mirylees | — | 958 ✓ |
| John Ward | Conservative | 806 |
| Jane Sinclair | — | 781 |
| Joan Anniballi | Labour | 337 |
Farnham Upper Hale2 seats · turnout 63.5%
| John Fraser | — | 1,061 ✓ |
| Julia Potts | Conservative | 927 ✓ |
| Jerry Hyman | — | 819 |
| Donal O'Neill | Conservative | 724 |
| Carole Thomas | Labour | 328 |
| Christopher Neil Storey | Conservative | 985 ✓ |
| Nabeel Ahmed Nasir | Conservative | 964 ✓ |
| William Marshall | Liberal Democrats | 816 |
| Mike Bryan | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 741 |
| Andrew Richard Jones | Labour | 453 |
| Penelope Frost | Conservative | 1,429 ✓ |
| Robert Ramsdale | Conservative | 1,281 ✓ |
| Mark Westcott | Independent | 688 |
| Anthony Watts | Labour | 555 |
| James Burroughs | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 517 |
| Ged Hall | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| Brian Adams | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Godalming Binscombe2 seats
| David Malcolm Hunter | Conservative | 999 ✓ |
| Julia Wheatley | Conservative | 898 ✓ |
| Paul Rivers | Liberal Democrats | 730 |
| Stephen Williams | Labour | 677 |
Godalming Central & Ockford2 seats
| Andrew John Campbell Bolton | Conservative | 1,180 ✓ |
| Simon Thornton | Conservative | 1,024 ✓ |
| George Adam Davies | Labour | 743 |
| Paul Robinson | — | 485 |
| Brian Francis Albert Egan | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 437 |
Godalming Charterhouse2 seats
| Tony Gordon-Smith | Conservative | 1,260 ✓ |
| Stefan Reynolds | Conservative | 1,067 ✓ |
| James Howard Coope | Green | 708 |
| Eleanor Griffiths | Labour | 549 |
| Ross Adrian Welland | Conservative | 1,152 ✓ |
| Nick Williams | Conservative | 1,030 ✓ |
| Penny Rivers | Liberal Democrats | 712 |
| Shirley Wardell | Green | 518 |
| Robert Park | Labour | 465 |
| Miranda Williams | Labour | 448 |
| Patrick Haveron | Liberal Democrats | 345 |
Godalming Holloway2 seats
| Peter Ernest Charles Martin | Conservative | 1,844 ✓ |
| Tom Martin | Conservative | 1,688 ✓ |
| Luis Pullen | Labour | 770 |
| Jim Edwards | Conservative | 1,658 ✓ |
| Carole Ann King | Conservative | 1,508 ✓ |
| Libby Piper | Conservative | 1,417 ✓ |
| Jacquie Keen | Liberal Democrats | 1,075 |
| Peter Nicholson | Liberal Democrats | 794 |
| John Robini | Liberal Democrats | 762 |
| Shafik Hansraj | Labour | 563 |
Haslemere East and Grayswood3 seats
| Stephen Mulliner | Conservative | 2,052 ✓ |
| Robert Knowles | Conservative | 1,966 ✓ |
| David Round | Conservative | 1,818 ✓ |
| Lesley Banfield | Independent | 1,128 |
| Elizabeth Ann Pamplin | Liberal Democrats | 879 |
| Paul Croshaw | Labour | 605 |
| Gail Weingartner | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 543 |
Hindhead2 seats
| Peter Brigstocke Isherwood | Conservative | 1,416 ✓ |
| Christiaan Hesse | Conservative | 1,380 ✓ |
| Sasha Brooks | Green | 408 |
| Susan Ryland | Independent | 393 |
| Jerome Davidson | Liberal Democrats | 373 |
| Geoffrey Conrad Whitby | Liberal Democrats | 325 |
Milford2 seats · turnout 67.8%
| Denis Leigh | Conservative | 1,436 ✓ |
| Bob Upton | Conservative | 845 ✓ |
| Jack Lee | Independent | 808 |
| Guy Jones | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 521 |
| Michael Band | Conservative | 819 ✓ |
| Fabian Peter Cole | Liberal Democrats | 211 |
Witley and Hambledon2 seats
| Nick Holder | Conservative | 1,414 ✓ |
| Anna Catherine James | Conservative | 1,204 ✓ |
| Dennis Hall | Independent | 515 |
| Yvonne Manning | Labour | 386 |
| Rosaleen Egan | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 374 |
