Before (end of 2014) (30 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 18 · Other 9 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Labour 0
After (end of 2015) (30 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 20 · Other 8 · Liberal Democrats 2 · Labour 0
Ward results
Amotherby1 seat · turnout 68.8%
| Fiona Anne Farnell | Conservative | 570 ✓ |
| Darren Allanson | Independent | 485 |
Ampleforth1 seat · turnout 72.5%
| James Bailey | Conservative | 619 ✓ |
| Barbara Jane Hickman | Green | 334 |
Cropton1 seat · turnout 77.5%
| John Clark | LIB | 526 ✓ |
| Lorraine Allanson | Conservative | 471 |
Dales1 seat · turnout 74.0%
| Janet Frank | Conservative | 534 ✓ |
| Nelly Trevelyan | LIB | 281 |
Derwent2 seats
| Michael Joseph Thomas Cleary | Conservative | 1,077 ✓ |
| Phil Evans | Conservative | 750 ✓ |
| Stephen Shaw | Independent | 659 |
| Abigail Stokell-Becket | Liberal Democrats | 574 |
Helmsley2 seats
| Stephen Arnold | Conservative | 982 ✓ |
| Snowy Windress | Conservative | 832 ✓ |
| George Hawkins | Independent | 584 |
| Erica Rose | Green | 407 |
Hovingham1 seat · turnout 73.6%
| Robert Wainwright | Independent | 599 ✓ |
| Nicholas Burton | Green | 439 |
Kirkbymoorside2 seats · turnout 74.4%
| Bob Gardiner | Conservative | 763 ✓ |
| David Cussons | Conservative | 757 ✓ |
| Martin Brampton | Green | 477 |
| Jill Louise Wells | Labour | 436 |
| Luke Richardson | LIB | 374 |
| Nicky Hollins | LIB | 280 |
Malton3 seats · turnout 63.5%
| Lindsay Marie Burr | Independent | 1,020 ✓ |
| Paul Andrews | Independent | 838 ✓ |
| Ed Jowit | Independent | 664 ✓ |
| Kerry Ennis | Conservative | 624 |
| David Hoggard | Conservative | 566 |
| Adrian Hopkinson | Conservative | 558 |
| Peter Ash | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 532 |
| Sam Prest | Labour | 456 |
| Tim Prest | Labour | 385 |
Norton East2 seats · turnout 59.8%
| Keane Charles Duncan | Conservative | 745 ✓ |
| Elizabeth Lois Shields | Liberal Democrats | 440 ✓ |
| Kevin Anderson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 402 |
| Ben Mehrtens | Liberal Democrats | 320 |
| Jeanne Harrison | Conservative | 319 |
| Raymond King | Independent | 309 |
Norton West2 seats
| Luke Ives | Conservative | 704 ✓ |
| Di Keal | Liberal Democrats | 631 ✓ |
| Liz Johnson | Conservative | 518 |
| Jeremy Powell | Independent | 388 |
| Howard Keal | Liberal Democrats | 325 |
| Philip Mooring | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 200 |
| Christodoulos Cooper | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 181 |
| Alasdair Clark | LIB | 82 |
| Eddie Thornton | LIB | 52 |
Pickering East2 seats
| William Mark Peter Oxley | Conservative | 739 ✓ |
| Joy Andrews | LIB | 643 ✓ |
| Tommy Woodward | LIB | 496 |
| Susan Cowan | Independent | 373 |
| Eileen Randall | Labour | 247 |
| Jane Haigh | Liberal Democrats | 169 |
| Charles Henry Hopkinson | Independent | 163 |
Pickering West2 seats · turnout 73.8%
| Tim Thornton | LIB | 893 ✓ |
| Linda Cowling | Conservative | 817 ✓ |
| Mike Potter | LIB | 607 |
| Geoff Randall | Labour | 314 |
Rillington1 seat · turnout 63.8%
| Brian Maud | Independent | 492 ✓ |
| Trevor Golding | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 220 |
| Janice Every | Green | 145 |
Ryedale South West1 seat
| Caroline Goodrick | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Sherburn1 seat · turnout 71.3%
| John Raper | Conservative | 464 ✓ |
| Barry Waite | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 340 |
| Selma Khan | Green | 193 |
Sheriff Hutton1 seat · turnout 69.1%
| Eric Hope | Conservative | 726 ✓ |
| Chris Picles | Independent | 337 |
Sinnington1 seat · turnout 73.8%
| Valerie Arnold | Conservative | 664 ✓ |
| Glyn Wild | Green | 289 |
| Mike Martin | Labour | 106 |
Thornton Dale2 seats
| Geoffrey Acomb | Conservative | 1,099 ✓ |
| Janet Sanderson | Conservative | 1,045 ✓ |
| Sandra Kathleen Bell | Green | 510 |
| Maurice Johnston | Labour | 425 |
Wolds1 seat
| Tharik Jainu-Deen | Conservative | 0 ✓ |