Before (end of 2015) (36 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 24 · Liberal Democrats 9 · Labour 2 · Other 1
After (end of 2016) (30 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 17 · Liberal Democrats 7 · Labour 3 · Other 3
Ward results
Byfleet and West Byfleet3 seats
| Jill Bond | Independent | 1,474 ✓ |
| Amanda Jayne Boote | Independent | 1,385 ✓ |
| Mary Ann Bridgeman | Independent | 1,123 ✓ |
| Richard Wilson | Conservative | 1,011 |
| Pauline Hedges | Conservative | 933 |
| Gary Elson | Conservative | 929 |
| Anne Elizabeth Roberts | Liberal Democrats | 724 |
| Amanda Grimshaw | Liberal Democrats | 582 |
| Karon Jane Read | Liberal Democrats | 534 |
| Neil James Willetts | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 295 |
Canalside3 seats
| Tahir Aziz | Labour | 1,106 ✓ |
| Mohammad Ali | Labour | 1,071 ✓ |
| M Ilyas Raja | Labour | 1,060 ✓ |
| Paula Jane Marcus | Conservative | 868 |
| Matthew Provost | Conservative | 829 |
| Colin Patrick Scott | Conservative | 807 |
| David Simon Roe | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 383 |
| Judith Diana Squire | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 332 |
| Rebecca Elisabeth Whale | Liberal Democrats | 300 |
| Topher Dykes | Green | 281 |
| Gareth Davies | Liberal Democrats | 279 |
| Norman Grenville Johns | Liberal Democrats | 230 |
Goldsworth Park3 seats
| Ann-Marie Barker | Liberal Democrats | 894 ✓ |
| Ian Eastwood | Liberal Democrats | 885 ✓ |
| Chitra Rana | Conservative | 858 ✓ |
| Laura Ashall | Conservative | 847 |
| James Sanderson | Liberal Democrats | 806 |
| Rizwan Ali Shah | Conservative | 707 |
| John Scott-Morgan | Labour | 366 |
| Troy De Leon | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 356 |
| Robina Shaheen | Labour | 327 |
| William Owen | Labour | 327 |
| Eve Catherine Carnall | Green | 219 |
Heathlands3 seats
| Kevin Mark Davis | Conservative | 1,519 ✓ |
| Ayesha Azad | Conservative | 1,462 ✓ |
| John Kingsbury | Conservative | 1,375 ✓ |
| Margaret Marion Hill | Liberal Democrats | 586 |
| Henry David Kay | Liberal Democrats | 555 |
| Alison Jane Sanderson | Liberal Democrats | 482 |
| Anna Katharine Wright | Green | 380 |
| Richard Peter Farr Squire | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 336 |
| John Martin | Labour | 316 |
Hoe Valley3 seats
| Will Forster | Liberal Democrats | 1,126 ✓ |
| Louise Mary Nell Morales | Liberal Democrats | 1,022 ✓ |
| Deborah Hughes | Liberal Democrats | 967 ✓ |
| Nathalie Bourne | Conservative | 614 |
| John Frederick Lawrence | Conservative | 567 |
| Daryl Martin Smith | Conservative | 506 |
| Jim Gore | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 322 |
| Bob Shatwell | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 315 |
| Nigel Peter Jackson | Labour | 276 |
| Frances Louise Carpenter | Labour | 275 |
| Chris Martin | Labour | 249 |
Horsell3 seats
| Beryl Ann Hunwicks | Conservative | 1,744 ✓ |
| Colin Sidney Kemp | Conservative | 1,651 ✓ |
| Anne Murray | Conservative | 1,569 ✓ |
| Anthony Kremer | Liberal Democrats | 871 |
| Rosemary Peta Johnson | Liberal Democrats | 758 |
| Samuel David Watts | Liberal Democrats | 519 |
| Stephen Anthony Herbert | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 366 |
| Elizabeth Evans | Labour | 348 |
| Lucy Rhodes Dykes | Green | 310 |
| Colin Robert Bright | Labour | 285 |
| Tim Willis | Labour | 244 |
Knaphill3 seats · turnout 45.0%
| Raja Sakhawat Hussain | Conservative | 1,587 ✓ |
| Melanie Anne Whitehand | Conservative | 1,333 ✓ |
| Dean Robert Harlow | Conservative | 1,293 ✓ |
| James William Brierley | Green | 407 |
| Vanessa Ellicott | Liberal Democrats | 399 |
| David Barker | Liberal Democrats | 394 |
| Robert Ford | Labour | 384 |
| Tracey Knight | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 372 |
| Syed Waqar Haider Jaffri | Liberal Democrats | 223 |
Mount Hermon3 seats
| David John Bittleston | Conservative | 1,289 ✓ |
| Ian Johnson | Liberal Democrats | 1,168 ✓ |
| Mark Russell John Pengelly | Conservative | 1,159 ✓ |
| Carl William Thomson | Conservative | 1,146 |
| Liam Lyons | Liberal Democrats | 1,104 |
| Stuart Webster | Liberal Democrats | 980 |
| John Parkin | Green | 378 |
| Lyn Sage | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 229 |
Pyrford3 seats
| Graham Chrystie | Conservative | 1,892 ✓ |
| Andrea Bowes | Conservative | 1,853 ✓ |
| Rashid Mohammed | Conservative | 1,433 ✓ |
| Ian Michael Lachowicz | Liberal Democrats | 579 |
| Robin Deller Milner | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 523 |
| Misbah Zahid | Labour | 521 |
| David Williams | Labour | 492 |
| Richard Raymond William Sanderson | Liberal Democrats | 407 |
| Guy Cosnahan | Liberal Democrats | 373 |
St. Johns3 seats
| Graham Stephen Cundy | Conservative | 1,174 ✓ |
| Hilary Jane Addison | Conservative | 1,098 ✓ |
| Kenneth Howard | Liberal Democrats | 1,052 ✓ |
| Christina Liddington | Liberal Democrats | 1,043 |
| Paul Graham Smith | Conservative | 938 |
| Christopher Took | Liberal Democrats | 775 |
| Tim Read | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 442 |
| Joel Benjamin Street | Green | 375 |