Before (end of 2015) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 40 · Other 10 · Liberal Democrats 1 · Labour 0
After (end of 2016) (51 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 39 · Other 10 · Liberal Democrats 2 · Labour 0
Ward results
Banstead Village1 seat
| Eddy Humphreys | Conservative | 1,205 ✓ |
| Christopher Byrne | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 365 |
| James Fowler | Liberal Democrats | 271 |
| Pete Kermally | Labour | 231 |
| Keith Foreman | Conservative | 1,280 ✓ |
| Steven David Alfred Russell | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 427 |
| Evan Patrick Raymond Gregory | Labour | 409 |
Earlswood & Whitebushes1 seat
| James Durrant | Conservative | 715 ✓ |
| Graham Richard Wildridge | Labour | 468 |
| Colin Brian Stiff | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 363 |
| Stephen Fenton | Green | 303 |
| Jane Kulka | Liberal Democrats | 230 |
Horley Central1 seat · turnout 29.9%
| Daniel Powell | Conservative | 803 ✓ |
| Malcolm Roger Brighting | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 565 |
| Linda Jane Mabbett | Labour | 483 |
Horley East1 seat
| Tony Schofield | Conservative | 949 ✓ |
| Joanna Barnett | Independent | 488 |
| Thomas Turner | Labour | 250 |
Horley West1 seat
| Liam Marshall Ascough | Conservative | 716 ✓ |
| André Edward Grant | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 352 |
| Geoff Smith | Labour | 321 |
| Geoffrey Southall | Liberal Democrats | 183 |
| Sarah Finch | Green | 139 |
| Simon Parnall | Conservative | 1,174 ✓ |
| Bob Cambridge | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 381 |
| Isabella Lane | Labour | 205 |
Meadvale & St John's1 seat
| Anna Tarrant | Liberal Democrats | 768 ✓ |
| Stephen Thomas Bramhall | Conservative | 764 |
| Malcolm Kemp Savidge | Labour | 207 |
| Alastair Dewar Richardson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 169 |
| Sarah Josephine Vaci | Green | 156 |
Merstham1 seat · turnout 31.8%
| Mark Brunt | Conservative | 858 ✓ |
| Stewart James Dack | Labour | 377 |
| Phyllis Cambridge | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 262 |
| Christopher Howell | Liberal Democrats | 155 |
| Kenneth Tze Ken Yau | Green | 137 |
Nork1 seat
| Jonathan Charles White | — | 1,545 ✓ |
| Philip Abimbola Olanipekun | Conservative | 306 |
| Kimberley Marie Griffin | Labour | 168 |
Redhill East1 seat · turnout 33.9%
| Stephen Hugh McKenna | Green | 1,160 ✓ |
| Ben Leslie | Conservative | 749 |
| Toby Brampton | Labour | 271 |
| Leigh Jones | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 201 |
| Stuart Nicholas Holmes | Liberal Democrats | 99 |
Redhill West1 seat · turnout 35.5%
| Natalie Bramhall | Conservative | 874 ✓ |
| Gregory James Clack | Labour | 422 |
| Rob Jarrett | Green | 324 |
| Tony Pearson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 324 |
| Andrew James Cressy | Liberal Democrats | 181 |
Reigate Central1 seat
| Christopher Thomas Henry Whinney | Independent | 810 ✓ |
| Helen Jane Foreman | Conservative | 562 |
| Helen Mary Samuel | Liberal Democrats | 262 |
| Rebecca Spencer | Labour | 186 |
| Gerard Martin Hever | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 150 |
| Soo Abram | Green | 142 |
Reigate Hill1 seat · turnout 35.0%
| Roger Charles Newstead | Conservative | 920 ✓ |
| Gregory Alec Edwin Ardan | Liberal Democrats | 231 |
| Andrew David Saunders | Labour | 201 |
| Laurence James Clack | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 135 |
South Park & Woodhatch1 seat
| James Paul King | Conservative | 806 ✓ |
| Mark Peter Collins | Labour | 344 |
| Joseph Brian Fox | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 335 |
| Nicola Dodgson | Green | 167 |
| Moray Carey | Liberal Democrats | 163 |
Tadworth and Walton1 seat
| Victor William Broad | Conservative | 1,020 ✓ |
| Margaret Caroline Deirdre Walkling | Independent | 445 |
| Valerie Ann Moore | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 269 |
| Sonja Begley-Moore | Liberal Democrats | 131 |
| David Anthony Burnley | Labour | 91 |
| Alistair Patrick Galbraith Morten | Green | 78 |
Tattenhams1 seat
| Jill Bray | — | 1,255 ✓ |
| John Illingworth | Conservative | 383 |
| Jacob Bonner | Labour | 141 |
| Roger Baizeley Ponsford | Green | 59 |