Before (end of 2015) (42 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 35 · Liberal Democrats 6 · Other 1 · Labour 0
After (end of 2016) (42 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 33 · Liberal Democrats 7 · Other 2 · Labour 0
Ward results
Bletchingley And Nutfield1 seat · turnout 36.6%
| Debbie Vickers | Conservative | 796 ✓ |
| Ian Crabb | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 294 |
| Richard Barry Fowler | Liberal Democrats | 269 |
| Linda Ruth Baharier | Labour | 174 |
Burstow, Horne and Outwood1 seat · turnout 34.2%
| Harry Fitzgerald | Conservative | 749 ✓ |
| Mark Adrian Fowler | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 414 |
| Judy Wilkinson | Liberal Democrats | 180 |
| Fern Warwick-Ching | Labour | 170 |
Godstone1 seat · turnout 38.3%
| Eileen Ruth Blake-Thomas | Conservative | 670 ✓ |
| Marjory Broughton | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 649 |
| Sarah Catherine MacDonnell | Labour | 171 |
| Dave Wilkes | Liberal Democrats | 142 |
Harestone1 seat · turnout 37.1%
| Michael John William Cooper | Conservative | 612 ✓ |
| Ann Bell | Liberal Democrats | 215 |
| Gordon Bailey | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 160 |
| Jodie Watts | Labour | 139 |
OXTED NORTH & TANDRIDGE1 seat · turnout 56.7%
| Jackie Wren | OLRG | 1,721 ✓ |
| Gordon Keymer | Conservative | 622 |
| Donald Mahon | Labour | 80 |
Oxted South1 seat · turnout 41.9%
| Elizabeth Parker | Conservative | 826 ✓ |
| Liz Parker | Conservative | 826 ✓ |
| Katherine Elizabeth Saunders | Labour | 404 |
| Carol Dean | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 364 |
| Michaela O'Brien | Green | 140 |
| Brigid Noreen McIntosh | Liberal Democrats | 111 |
Portley1 seat · turnout 35.7%
| Chris Botten | Liberal Democrats | 520 ✓ |
| Robin Gwynn | Conservative | 387 |
| Alex Standen | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 136 |
| Lucy Blue McNally | Labour | 117 |
QUEENS PARK1 seat · turnout 38.3%
| Geoffrey Duck | Conservative | 529 ✓ |
| Costel Petre | Liberal Democrats | 288 |
| Dick Grant | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 162 |
| Ollie Chamberlain | Labour | 104 |
Valley1 seat
| Alun Jones | Liberal Democrats | 428 ✓ |
| Liz Goodwin | Conservative | 265 |
| Jeffrey Bolter | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 163 |
| Rachel Krengel | Labour | 143 |
| Mark Jones | Independent | 107 |
Warlingham East And Chelsham And Farleigh1 seat · turnout 42.1%
| Jeremy Pursehouse | Liberal Democrats | 853 ✓ |
| Perry Chotai | Conservative | 471 |
| Martin Arthur Haley | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 329 |
| Patrick Joseph Rogers | Labour | 106 |
Warlingham West1 seat
| David Cooley | Conservative | 593 ✓ |
| Celia Caulcott | Liberal Democrats | 218 |
| John Hill | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 144 |
| Jenifer Susan Dugdale | Labour | 82 |
Westway1 seat · turnout 36.7%
| Caroline Jane Warner | Liberal Democrats | 416 ✓ |
| James Robert Richardson | Conservative | 335 |
| Sarah Louise Peay | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 220 |
| Sally Rebecca Eason | Labour | 183 |
Whyteleafe1 seat · turnout 35.2%
| David Lee | Liberal Democrats | 535 ✓ |
| Matthew Groves | Conservative | 361 |
| Fatima Kamara | Labour | 121 |
Woldingham1 seat · turnout 35.0%
| Keith Martin Jecks | Conservative | 367 ✓ |
| Joe Branco | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 75 |
| Neill Simon Cooper | Liberal Democrats | 36 |
| Thomas Rowley Ebbs | Labour | 34 |