Before (end of 2017) (42 seats, Elections Centre)
Conservative 31 · Liberal Democrats 6 · Other 5 · Labour 0
After (end of 2018) (42 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 22 · Other 11 · Liberal Democrats 9
Ward results
Bletchingley And Nutfield1 seat · turnout 35.4%
| Tony Elias | Conservative | 775 ✓ |
| Helena Mary Windsor | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 343 |
| Richard Barry Fowler | Liberal Democrats | 267 |
| Linda Ruth Baharier | Labour | 178 |
Burstow, Horne and Outwood1 seat · turnout 38.1%
| Kevin Tom Bourne | Independent | 926 ✓ |
| Peter Edward Thomas Bond | Conservative | 695 |
| Fern Warwick-Ching | Labour | 119 |
| Judy Wilkinson | Liberal Democrats | 63 |
Dormansland and Felcourt1 seat
| Nicholas White | Independent | 520 ✓ |
| Maureen June Young | Conservative | 508 |
| Tony Hardisty | Liberal Democrats | 86 |
| Ann Seuret | Labour | 64 |
Godstone1 seat · turnout 44.2%
| Chris Farr | Independent | 1,305 ✓ |
| Rose Thorn | Conservative | 423 |
| Barbara Ann Wantling | Labour | 147 |
| Tamzie Hollands | Liberal Democrats | 115 |
Harestone1 seat · turnout 40.8%
| Brian Connolly | Conservative | 663 ✓ |
| Annette Evans | Liberal Democrats | 461 |
| Mark James Wood | Labour | 129 |
| Mark Adrian Fowler | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 36 |
Limpsfield1 seat · turnout 49.9%
| Phil Davies | — | 918 ✓ |
| Zee Grace Lapthorne | Conservative | 416 |
| Martin Caxton | Liberal Democrats | 59 |
| Alec McNally | Labour | 35 |
Lingfield and Crowhurst1 seat · turnout 37.6%
| Mark Ridge | Conservative | 525 ✓ |
| Michael Sydney | Independent | 410 |
| Dave Wilkes | Liberal Democrats | 150 |
| Robyn Carly Bone | Labour | 144 |
OXTED NORTH & TANDRIDGE1 seat · turnout 51.5%
| Catherine Mary Sayer | Oxted & Limpsfield Residents Group | 1,531 ✓ |
| David Courtenay Weightman | Conservative | 548 |
| Che Ramsden | Labour | 100 |
| Craig Shepherd | Liberal Democrats | 85 |
Oxted South1 seat · turnout 43.9%
| Lynn Mills | — | 1,206 ✓ |
| Julie Elizabeth Bird | Conservative | 480 |
| Katherine Elizabeth Saunders | Labour | 296 |
| Jonathan Salisbury | Liberal Democrats | 111 |
QUEENS PARK1 seat · turnout 43.6%
| John Orrick | Liberal Democrats | 755 ✓ |
| Rod Stead | Conservative | 415 |
| Eddington Tafara Pindura | Labour | 74 |
| Gordon Bailey | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 42 |
Warlingham East And Chelsham And Farleigh1 seat · turnout 38.4%
| Simon Morrow | Liberal Democrats | 833 ✓ |
| Nathan Adams | Conservative | 590 |
| Martin Arthur Haley | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 141 |
| Michael Snowden | Labour | 120 |
Warlingham West1 seat · turnout 38.5%
| Robin Bloore | Conservative | 654 ✓ |
| Celia Caulcott | Liberal Democrats | 286 |
| Patrick Joseph Rogers | Labour | 70 |
| Carol Dean | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 42 |
Westway1 seat · turnout 33.7%
| George Dennis | Liberal Democrats | 485 ✓ |
| Eithne Webster | Conservative | 398 |
| Lucy Blue McNally | Labour | 223 |
| Joe Branco | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 38 |
Whyteleafe1 seat · turnout 33.8%
| Jeffrey Gray | Liberal Democrats | 483 ✓ |
| Sakina Bradbury | Conservative | 391 |
| Fatima Kamara | Labour | 133 |
| Grayson Paul Clarke | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 32 |