Before (end of 2018) (36 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 24 · Liberal Democrats 7 · Labour 3 · Other 2
After (end of 2019) (36 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 19 · Liberal Democrats 12 · Other 5
Ward results
Bardney1 seat · turnout 35.5%
| Ian Gordon Fleetwood | Conservative | 479 ✓ |
| Robert John Webb | Independent | 154 |
| Charles William Shaw | Independent | 92 |
Caistor and Yarborough2 seats · turnout 29.3%
| Angela Lawrence | Conservative | 934 ✓ |
| Owen Bierley | Conservative | 904 ✓ |
| Nancy Barr | Labour | 358 |
| Andrea Maria Clarke | Labour | 354 |
Cherry Willingham3 seats · turnout 34.1%
| Chris Darcel | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 1,154 ✓ |
| Sharon Cherie Hill | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 979 ✓ |
| Anne Welburn | Conservative | 690 ✓ |
| Thomas Longley | Conservative | 592 |
| Maureen Palmer | Conservative | 570 |
| Trevor John Bridgwood | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 433 |
Dunholme & Welton3 seats · turnout 31.6%
| Diana Rodgers | Independent | 1,180 ✓ |
| Steve England | Conservative | 865 ✓ |
| Caralyne Margaret Grimble | Conservative | 718 ✓ |
| Paul Swift | Liberal Democrats | 707 |
| Malcolm Parish | Conservative | 656 |
| Anjum Sawhney | Independent | 499 |
GAINSBOROUGH EAST3 seats · turnout 15.6%
| Tim Davies | Independent | 290 ✓ |
| David Dobbie | Liberal Democrats | 268 ✓ |
| Mick Devine | Independent | 257 ✓ |
| Richard William Oaks | Independent | 254 |
| Richard John Craig | Liberal Democrats | 246 |
| Kristan Jorge Smith | Liberal Democrats | 188 |
| Angelene Janet Wright | Labour | 152 |
| David Patrick Bond | Labour | 144 |
| Jonathan Mark Harper | Labour | 130 |
| Joy Jones | Conservative | 125 |
| Peter Morris | Conservative | 116 |
Gainsborough North3 seats · turnout 24.5%
| Matthew Boles | Liberal Democrats | 568 ✓ |
| Jim Snee | Liberal Democrats | 517 ✓ |
| Keith Richard Panter | Liberal Democrats | 416 ✓ |
| Sheila Christine Bibb | Conservative | 297 |
| John Patrick | Conservative | 229 |
| Gary John Austen | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 221 |
| Sophie May Austen | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 213 |
| John Saxon | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 209 |
| Sheila Frances Jennings | Labour | 198 |
| Peter Francis McNeill | Conservative | 193 |
| Robert Andrew Adderley | Labour | 176 |
| Harry Eddowes | Labour | 161 |
GAINSBOROUGH SOUTH WEST2 seats · turnout 25.3%
| Judy Rainsforth | Liberal Democrats | 534 ✓ |
| Trevor Young | Liberal Democrats | 529 ✓ |
| David John Cormack | Labour | 163 |
| Perry Smith | Labour | 138 |
| Neville Shaun Jones | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 125 |
| Denise Mary Schofield | Independent | 88 |
| Henry Speer | Conservative | 71 |
| Steve Schofield | Independent | 57 |
Hemswell1 seat · turnout 29.9%
| Paul Howitt-Cowan | Conservative | 418 ✓ |
| Karen Dawn Bacon | Liberal Democrats | 214 |
KELSEY WOLD1 seat · turnout 39.1%
| Lewis Strange | Conservative | 546 ✓ |
| Louise Amanda Reece | Liberal Democrats | 305 |
Lea1 seat · turnout 37.0%
| Jessie Milne | Conservative | 452 ✓ |
| Susan Kathleen Greenall | Green | 215 |
Market Rasen3 seats · turnout 28.6%
| Stephen Bunney | Liberal Democrats | 1,030 ✓ |
| John McNeill | Conservative | 896 ✓ |
| Cordelia Emma Julia McCartney | Conservative | 893 ✓ |
| Thomas Smith | Conservative | 853 |
| June Clark | Liberal Democrats | 762 |
| Robert David Henri Levison | Liberal Democrats | 727 |
| Colin Saywell | Labour | 262 |
| Geoffrey Barnes | Labour | 243 |
| Lee Martin Simpson | Labour | 204 |
Nettleham2 seats · turnout 37.4%
| Giles McNeill | Conservative | 635 ✓ |
| Angela May White | Liberal Democrats | 632 ✓ |
| Christopher Higham | Liberal Democrats | 580 |
| John Stephen Barrett | Conservative | 506 |
Saxilby2 seats · turnout 37.6%
| Jago Barnabas York Brockway | Conservative | 841 ✓ |
| David John Cotton | Liberal Democrats | 555 ✓ |
| Jayne Ellis | Conservative | 513 |
| Simon John Cowell | Green | 299 |
Scampton1 seat
| Roger Patterson | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Scotter and Blyton3 seats · turnout 28.5%
| Lesley Rollings | Liberal Democrats | 992 ✓ |
| Liz Clews | Liberal Democrats | 946 ✓ |
| Mandy Snee | Liberal Democrats | 830 ✓ |
| Sally Pamela Loates | Conservative | 745 |
| Ken Woolley | Conservative | 737 |
| Ian Richard Bradley | Conservative | 668 |
STOW1 seat
| Tracey Coulson | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
SUDBROOKE1 seat
| Bob Waller | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Torksey1 seat
| Stuart Kinch | Conservative | 472 ✓ |
| Noel Joseph Mullally | Liberal Democrats | 334 |
Waddingham and Spital1 seat · turnout 36.2%
| Jeff Summers | Conservative | 492 ✓ |
| Neil Taylor | Liberal Democrats | 223 |