Before (end of 2018) (47 seats, Open Council Data)
Labour 15 · Conservative 12 · Liberal Democrats 12 · Other 4 · Green 4
After (end of 2019) (47 seats, Open Council Data)
Liberal Democrats 21 · Labour 17 · Green 4 · Other 3 · Conservative 2
Ward results
Acomb2 seats · turnout 39.8%
| Katie Lomas | Labour | 1,105 ✓ |
| Stuart Barnes | Labour | 1,021 ✓ |
| Keith Robert Myers | Conservative | 590 |
| Brian Walter Joseph Edward Watson | Independent | 465 |
| Matthew Keith Greenwood | Conservative | 429 |
| Jonathan Pitt | Green | 322 |
| Tom Franklin | Green | 270 |
| Quentin Macdonald | Liberal Democrats | 202 |
| Matt Ward-Perkins | Liberal Democrats | 142 |
Bishopthorpe1 seat · turnout 51.6%
| John Christopher Galvin | Independent | 568 ✓ |
| Carole Green | Green | 539 |
| Michael Nicholls | Conservative | 360 |
| Bob Scrase | Labour | 155 |
| Daniel Yameen Prakash Khan | Liberal Democrats | 99 |
Clifton2 seats
| Danny Myers | Labour | 1,291 ✓ |
| Margaret Wells | Labour | 1,126 ✓ |
| Alan Dunnett | Green | 408 |
| Alfie Robert Thomlinson | Conservative | 374 |
| Richard John Samuel Schofield | Conservative | 342 |
| John Walford | Green | 322 |
| Tobie Abel | Liberal Democrats | 241 |
| Mark Waudby | Liberal Democrats | 193 |
Copmanthorpe1 seat · turnout 43.0%
| David Terry Carr | Independent | 662 ✓ |
| Matthew Freckelton | Conservative | 258 |
| Richard Brown | Liberal Democrats | 254 |
| Lars Kramm | Green | 159 |
| William Owen | Labour | 99 |
Dringhouses & Woodthorpe3 seats · turnout 50.9%
| Stephen Fenton | Liberal Democrats | 2,402 ✓ |
| Paula Widdowson | Liberal Democrats | 2,263 ✓ |
| Ashley Mason | Liberal Democrats | 2,247 ✓ |
| Cathryn Auplish | Labour | 705 |
| Tracy White | Labour | 681 |
| Graham Gatman | Labour | 671 |
| Amanda Ashman | Conservative | 463 |
| David Redmand Atkinson | Conservative | 445 |
| Timothy John Ashman | Conservative | 425 |
| Bronwen Gray | Green | 410 |
| Scott Robert Marmion | Independent | 341 |
| Rob Gray | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 318 |
| John Gray | Green | 298 |
| Ginevra House | Green | 282 |
Fishergate2 seats · turnout 46.3%
| Andy d'Agorne | Green | 1,553 ✓ |
| Dave Taylor | Green | 1,381 ✓ |
| Barbara Boyce | Labour | 663 |
| Dan Kettlewell | Labour | 566 |
| Stephen Ian Munro | Conservative | 222 |
| Robin Matthew Willoughby | Conservative | 169 |
| Monta Drozdova | Liberal Democrats | 141 |
| Paul Mulvey | Liberal Democrats | 135 |
Fulford & Heslington1 seat · turnout 48.9%
| Keith Aspden | Liberal Democrats | 916 ✓ |
| Anne Kerr | Labour | 239 |
| Susie Taylor | Green | 99 |
| Eileen Margaret Dickinson | Conservative | 94 |
Guildhall3 seats · turnout 33.9%
| Denise Craghill | Green | 1,492 ✓ |
| Fiona Fitzpatrick | Labour | 1,198 ✓ |
| Janet Looker | Labour | 1,151 ✓ |
| June Tranmer | Green | 1,076 |
| James Alexander Flinders | Labour | 1,050 |
| Danni Makin | Green | 977 |
| Dawn Lucille Argyle | Conservative | 429 |
| David Barratt | Conservative | 409 |
| Robin Nicholas Dickson | Conservative | 374 |
| Jamie Butler | Liberal Democrats | 271 |
| Jack McAteer | Liberal Democrats | 226 |
| Matthew John Smithson | Liberal Democrats | 191 |
Haxby & Wigginton3 seats · turnout 49.6%
| Ian Cuthbertson | Liberal Democrats | 2,872 ✓ |
| Andrew Hollyer | Liberal Democrats | 2,819 ✓ |
| Edward Pearson | Liberal Democrats | 2,806 ✓ |
| Roy Watson-Smith | Conservative | 810 |
| Joe Pattinson | Conservative | 725 |
| Margaret Anne Young | Conservative | 673 |
| Tony Richardson | Independent | 515 |
| Neil Wyatt | Independent | 422 |
| Jess Dixon | Green | 284 |
| Caroline Hind | Labour | 274 |
| Lindsay Walter | Labour | 227 |
| Albert James Ward | Labour | 216 |
| Liz Scurfield | Green | 200 |
| David Williams | Green | 155 |
Heworth3 seats · turnout 39.9%
| Claire Douglas | Labour | 1,615 ✓ |
| Anna Catherine Perrett | Labour | 1,375 ✓ |
| Robert Webb | Labour | 1,308 ✓ |
| Nicola Normandale | Green | 629 |
| Sabine Janssen-Havercroft | Green | 542 |
| Teri Rhodes | Conservative | 527 |
| George Coxshall | Conservative | 461 |
| Jacob Jeroen Groet | Conservative | 451 |
| Steve Jones | Liberal Democrats | 424 |
| Andy Wilson | Green | 407 |
| Jonathan Morley | Liberal Democrats | 392 |
| Sally Duffin | WEP | 389 |
| Ben Rich | Liberal Democrats | 272 |
| Nigel Fenwick Smith | Socialist Alternative | 148 |
Heworth Without1 seat · turnout 51.6%
| Nigel Ayre | Liberal Democrats | 1,318 ✓ |
| Brannan Michael Coady | Conservative | 160 |
| Andrew David Garbutt | Labour | 136 |
| Alison Webb | Green | 124 |
Holgate3 seats · turnout 40.1%
| Kallum Taylor | Labour | 2,013 ✓ |
| Rachel Melly | Labour | 1,801 ✓ |
| David Heaton | Labour | 1,787 ✓ |
| Andreas Heinemeyer | Green | 641 |
| Pam Hanley | Green | 601 |
| Emma Claire Keef | Liberal Democrats | 574 |
| Caleb Rowan | Green | 540 |
| Emilie Knight | Liberal Democrats | 460 |
| Janet Christine Powell | Conservative | 418 |
| Aileen Hingston | Liberal Democrats | 399 |
| Terry Powell | Conservative | 367 |
| Sophie Elizabeth Alexandra Burn | Conservative | 338 |
Hull Road3 seats · turnout 35.2%
| Aisling Musson | Labour | 1,032 ✓ |
| Michael Pavlovic | Labour | 979 ✓ |
| George Norman | Labour | 912 ✓ |
| Patrick Thelwell | Green | 626 |
| John Cossham | Green | 523 |
| Candy Spillard | Green | 400 |
| Jordan Clark Henessey | Conservative | 328 |
| Robert Ward | Conservative | 322 |
| Carl Victor Mellor | Conservative | 304 |
| Hilary Shepherd | Independent | 268 |
| Katharine Macy | Liberal Democrats | 263 |
| Chris Small | Liberal Democrats | 253 |
| Ian Murphy | Liberal Democrats | 187 |
Huntington & New Earswick3 seats · turnout 39.8%
| Keith Orrell | Liberal Democrats | 2,114 ✓ |
| Carol Runciman | Liberal Democrats | 2,087 ✓ |
| Chris Cullwick | Liberal Democrats | 2,075 ✓ |
| Chloe Anderson | Labour | 710 |
| Ian Craven | Labour | 668 |
| Wendy Kathryn Loveday | Labour | 624 |
| Clive Woolley | Green | 385 |
| Martina Weitsch | Green | 372 |
| Fiona Anne Duncan | Conservative | 350 |
| Sandra Elisabeth Fairley | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 344 |
| Charles Everett | Green | 312 |
| Sally Page | Conservative | 310 |
| Benjamin Tate | Conservative | 296 |
Micklegate3 seats · turnout 56.9%
| Jonny Crawshaw | Labour | 2,408 ✓ |
| Rosie Baker | Green | 1,954 ✓ |
| Peter Kilbane | Labour | 1,913 ✓ |
| Sandi Redpath | Labour | 1,746 |
| Sam Biram | Green | 1,313 |
| Vera van Gool | Green | 1,052 |
| John Martin Brewin | Conservative | 457 |
| Jennie Gambold | Conservative | 449 |
| Bill Gambold | Conservative | 436 |
| Carlotta Allum | Liberal Democrats | 407 |
| Kate Webster | Liberal Democrats | 349 |
| Chris Gammie | Liberal Democrats | 293 |
Osbaldwick & Derwent2 seats · turnout 51.4%
| Mark Warters | Independent | 1,293 ✓ |
| Martin Andrew Rowley | Conservative | 755 ✓ |
| John Murdoch Zimnoch | Conservative | 511 |
| Ginnie Shaw | Green | 506 |
| Kevin Farnsworth | Labour | 325 |
| Ian Eiloart | Liberal Democrats | 325 |
| Lata Narayanaswamy | Labour | 300 |
| James Blanchard | Liberal Democrats | 263 |
| Paul Hutchinson | Green | 229 |
Rawcliffe & Clifton Without3 seats · turnout 42.3%
| Darryl Joshua Smalley | Liberal Democrats | 2,219 ✓ |
| Derek Wann | Liberal Democrats | 2,149 ✓ |
| Sam Waudby | Liberal Democrats | 2,128 ✓ |
| Charlotte Mary Milligan | Conservative | 746 |
| Rebecca Fewtrell | Labour | 729 |
| Peter Anthony Dew | Conservative | 721 |
| Stuart Richard Rawlings | Conservative | 711 |
| Dave Merrett | Labour | 692 |
| Will Bossman | Labour | 642 |
| Jill Armstrong | Green | 295 |
| Andy Dearden | Green | 281 |
| Rod Bell | Green | 211 |
Rural West York2 seats · turnout 49.4%
| Anne Hook | Liberal Democrats | 1,570 ✓ |
| James Barker | Liberal Democrats | 1,260 ✓ |
| Robin Eric Garland | Conservative | 1,019 |
| Chris Steward | Conservative | 952 |
| Andrew Nicholas Carter | Labour | 233 |
| Ginerva Gordon | Green | 214 |
| Mark Allan Windmill | Labour | 206 |
| Mark Havercroft | Green | 171 |
Strensall2 seats · turnout 34.0%
| Tony Fisher | Liberal Democrats | 1,200 ✓ |
| Paul Anthony Doughty | Conservative | 960 ✓ |
| Sian Wiseman | Conservative | 814 |
| Danielle Mason | Liberal Democrats | 738 |
| Paul Clarke | Labour | 213 |
| Catherine Love | Green | 211 |
| Ross Bennett | Green | 183 |
| Liam Penny | Labour | 182 |
Westfield3 seats
| Andrew Waller | Liberal Democrats | 2,048 ✓ |
| Sue Hunter | Liberal Democrats | 1,870 ✓ |
| Simon Daubeney | Liberal Democrats | 1,653 ✓ |
| Louise Corson | Labour | 945 |
| Jason Rose | Labour | 870 |
| Fasil Demsash | Labour | 836 |
| Sheena Cameron Jackson | Independent | 316 |
| Seb Butterworth | Green | 288 |
| Jonathan Tyler | Green | 245 |
| Mikael Hanson | Green | 226 |
| James Ronan Blenkinsop | Conservative | 178 |
| Charles Andrew Gilchrist Brooks | Conservative | 174 |
| Samuel Douglas Lisle | Conservative | 144 |
Wheldrake1 seat · turnout 48.4%
| Christian Vassie | Liberal Democrats | 537 ✓ |
| Wesley Neil Coultas | Conservative | 457 |
| Suzie Mercer | Independent | 333 |
| Will Dyson | Green | 134 |
| Jon Hughes | Labour | 112 |