Before (end of 2018) (46 seats, Open Council Data)
Labour 31 · Other 10 · Conservative 5
After (end of 2019) (46 seats, Open Council Data)
Other 23 · Labour 20 · Conservative 3
Ward results
Acklam2 seats · turnout 46.9%
| Sheila Dean | Labour | 527 ✓ |
| Eric Polano | Independent | 518 ✓ |
| Tom Livingstone | Liberal Democrats | 517 |
| Shamal Biswas | Labour | 487 |
| Ken Hall | Conservative | 325 |
| Jack Stoker | Liberal Democrats | 271 |
| Becky Tyndall | Green | 166 |
Ayresome2 seats · turnout 40.2%
| Antony High | Independent | 862 ✓ |
| Denise Rooney | Labour | 418 ✓ |
| Vic Walkington | Labour | 323 |
| Anya Claire Heywood | Green | 138 |
| Pamela Waterfield | Conservative | 124 |
| Sophie Drumm | Liberal Democrats | 66 |
Berwick Hills & Pallister3 seats · turnout 20.9%
| Lee Garvey | Independent | 782 ✓ |
| Donna Jones | Independent | 652 ✓ |
| Raymond Michael Sands | Independent | 573 ✓ |
| Ian Blades | Labour | 369 |
| Edward Dryden | Labour | 294 |
| Julie McGee | Labour | 282 |
| Hannah Rose Clarke | Conservative | 67 |
| Alison Reynolds | Conservative | 48 |
Brambles & Thorntree3 seats · turnout 20.3%
| Graham Wilson | Independent | 519 ✓ |
| Geraldine Purvis | Labour | 302 ✓ |
| Janet Thompson | Labour | 293 ✓ |
| Terry Lawton | Best For Middlesbrough | 249 |
| Daniel Kerr | Labour | 246 |
| Kelly Watson | Best For Middlesbrough | 187 |
| Charmaine Moloney | Best For Middlesbrough | 172 |
| Hannah Louise Wilson | Conservative | 83 |
Central3 seats · turnout 37.4%
| Linda Lewis | Labour | 759 ✓ |
| Zafar Uddin | Labour | 712 ✓ |
| Matt Storey | Labour | 611 ✓ |
| Haji Jaber | Independent | 593 |
| Paul Kemp | Best For Middlesbrough | 290 |
| Nicola Fricker | — | 273 |
| Gordon Walker | Best For Middlesbrough | 259 |
| Ian Stewart Sturrock | Green | 155 |
| Paul Michael Hamilton | Liberal Democrats | 115 |
| Stephen Ali | Conservative | 112 |
Coulby Newham3 seats · turnout 26.5%
| Stefan Walker | Labour | 857 ✓ |
| David Philip Smith | Conservative | 827 ✓ |
| David Branson | Labour | 696 ✓ |
| Alex Law | Labour | 515 |
Hemlington2 seats · turnout 23.1%
| Allan Bell | Independent | 454 ✓ |
| Jeanette Ann Walker | Labour | 427 ✓ |
| Nicky Walker | Labour | 422 |
| Ken Walker | Independent | 365 |
| Val Beadnall | Conservative | 140 |
| John Cooper | Conservative | 104 |
Kader2 seats · turnout 42.5%
| Ron Arundale | Independent | 1,017 ✓ |
| Jim Platt | Independent | 970 ✓ |
| Rahana Islam | Labour | 428 |
| Bradley Nicholson | Conservative | 340 |
| Edward Clynch | Labour | 336 |
| Michael John Tomlin | Liberal Democrats | 131 |
Ladgate2 seats · turnout 23.9%
| June Goodchild | Labour | 561 ✓ |
| Craig Wright | Labour | 451 ✓ |
| Alison Mary Huggan | Conservative | 367 |
| Janet Linda Summers | Conservative | 310 |
Linthorpe2 seats · turnout 39.1%
| Naweed Hussain | Labour | 639 ✓ |
| Philippa Storey | Labour | 590 ✓ |
| Peter Allan | Independent | 588 |
| George Melville | Independent | 513 |
| Hugh Alberti | Green | 218 |
| Craig Jacques | Independent | 161 |
| Stephen John Armstrong | Conservative | 160 |
| Ian Jones | Liberal Democrats | 118 |
Longlands & Beechwood3 seats · turnout 29.7%
| Joan McTigue | Independent | 956 ✓ |
| Teresa Higgins | Labour | 503 ✓ |
| Mary Nugent | Labour | 482 ✓ |
| Charles Rooney | Labour | 371 |
| Cath Taylor | — | 276 |
| Lenore Sizer | Conservative | 171 |
Marton East2 seats · turnout 33.0%
| Dorothy Davison | Independent | 907 ✓ |
| Tom Mawston | Independent | 865 ✓ |
| Edward Arthur Davies | Conservative | 318 |
| Craig Andrew Chapman | Conservative | 304 |
| Stephen Hill | Independent | 254 |
| Mick Bone | Labour | 207 |
Marton West2 seats · turnout 47.6%
| Chris Hobson | Independent | 1,665 ✓ |
| John Hobson | Independent | 1,588 ✓ |
| Stephen James Cass | Labour | 193 |
| Jill Powles Coleman | Conservative | 190 |
| Tony Coleman | Conservative | 174 |
Newport3 seats · turnout 29.8%
| Christopher Cooke | Labour | 544 ✓ |
| Alma Hellaoui | Labour | 537 ✓ |
| Barrie Cooper | Independent | 520 ✓ |
| John Kabuye | Labour | 477 |
| David Whiteway | Green | 205 |
| Jaime Luan Latham | Conservative | 133 |
| Anish Patel | Liberal Democrats | 132 |
North Ormesby1 seat · turnout 29.8%
| Ashley Waters | Independent | 371 ✓ |
| Lewis Young | Labour | 142 |
| Kerry Luan Thompson Latham | Conservative | 17 |
NUNTHORPE2 seats · turnout 38.4%
| Jon Rathmell | Independent | 1,075 ✓ |
| Mieka Smiles | Conservative | 582 ✓ |
| Lesley McGloin | Independent | 573 |
| Michael King | Conservative | 346 |
| Morgan McClintock | Liberal Democrats | 284 |
| Tom Bailey | Liberal Democrats | 138 |
| Bernard Rooney | Labour | 135 |
Park3 seats · turnout 43.2%
| Julia Rostron | Labour | 984 ✓ |
| Theo Furness | Labour | 883 ✓ |
| Chris McIntyre | Independent | 816 ✓ |
| Margaret Walters | Labour | 814 |
| Emma Alberti | Green | 695 |
| Deborah Wardle | Conservative | 337 |
Park End & Beckfield3 seats
| Brian Hubbard | Independent | 1,050 ✓ |
| Michael Saunders | Independent | 979 ✓ |
| Jan Mohan | Independent | 910 ✓ |
| Dennis Burns | Labour | 178 |
| Jenny Dowsett | Labour | 118 |
| Paul McGrath | Labour | 117 |
| Mary Davies | Conservative | 46 |
Stainton & Thornton1 seat · turnout 35.0%
| David Philip Coupe | Conservative | 618 ✓ |
| James Sheldon | Labour | 151 |
Trimdon2 seats · turnout 39.8%
| Carolyn Dodds | Independent | 1,216 ✓ |
| Dennis McCabe | Independent | 1,135 ✓ |
| Jean Sharrocks | Labour | 197 |
| Peter Sharrocks | Labour | 172 |
| Dorothy Winifred Smith | Conservative | 125 |
| Barry Jobson | Green | 92 |