Before (end of 2018) (31 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 22 · Labour 7 · Other 2
After (end of 2019) (31 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 16 · Labour 8 · Other 7
Ward results
| Richard Musgrave | Conservative | 1,072 ✓ |
| Keith Ellis | Conservative | 1,036 ✓ |
| Andrew Lowe | Labour | 489 |
| John Rushby | Labour | 465 |
Barlby Village1 seat · turnout 23.5%
| Stephanie Duckett | Labour | 295 ✓ |
| Ian Rodney Lawton | Conservative | 265 |
Brayton2 seats · turnout 29.9%
| Mark Crane | Conservative | 898 ✓ |
| Ian Chilvers | Conservative | 879 ✓ |
| Eva Lambert | Labour | 553 |
Byram and Brotherton1 seat
| Eleanor Jordan | YORKS | 320 ✓ |
| Bryn Sage | Conservative | 245 |
| Craig Laskey | Labour | 142 |
Camblesforth and Carlton2 seats
| Paul Welburn | YORKS | 799 ✓ |
| Mike Jordan | YORKS | 702 ✓ |
| Craig Blakey | Conservative | 365 |
| David Leake | Labour | 345 |
| Connor Brocklesby | Conservative | 330 |
Cawood and Wistow1 seat
| John Cattanach | Conservative | 582 ✓ |
| Susan Andrew | Labour | 193 |
Derwent2 seats · turnout 27.1%
| Mark Topping | Conservative | 781 ✓ |
| Karl Arthur | Conservative | 657 ✓ |
| Neal Seargent | Labour | 407 |
Eggborough1 seat · turnout 33.7%
| Mary McCartney | Independent | 673 ✓ |
| Alexander Bruce | Conservative | 124 |
Escrick1 seat · turnout 36.4%
| Neil Reader | Conservative | 471 ✓ |
| Kevin Barry Riley | Labour | 231 |
Hambleton1 seat · turnout 35.9%
| Clive Pearson | Conservative | 383 ✓ |
| Scott Conor | YORKS | 277 |
| Anne Riley | Labour | 116 |
Monk Fryston1 seat · turnout 32.3%
| John Mackman | Conservative | 590 ✓ |
| Claire Stephenson | Labour | 171 |
Riccall1 seat · turnout 35.9%
| John Michael Duggan | Labour | 357 ✓ |
| Charles Richardson | Conservative | 353 |
Selby East3 seats · turnout 17.4%
| Wendy Ruth Nichols | Labour | 570 ✓ |
| Steve Shaw-Wright | Labour | 529 ✓ |
| Paul Welch | Labour | 520 ✓ |
| Joshua Nathan Crane | Conservative | 365 |
| Caroline Dickinson | Conservative | 355 |
Selby West3 seats · turnout 26.5%
| Judith Ann Chilvers | Conservative | 875 ✓ |
| Jennifer Winifred Shaw-Wright | Labour | 847 ✓ |
| Keith Franks | Labour | 798 ✓ |
| Malik Mohd Rofidi | Labour | 677 |
| Ian Wilson | SOC LAB | 216 |
Sherburn in Elmet3 seats · turnout 43.0%
| David Brook | YORKS | 925 ✓ |
| David Buckle | Conservative | 816 ✓ |
| Bob Packham | Labour | 769 ✓ |
| Alexander Tant-Brown | Conservative | 682 |
| Scott Baillie | Labour | 521 |
South Milford1 seat · turnout 30.8%
| Tim Grogan | Conservative | 426 ✓ |
| Tracey Woods | Labour | 206 |
Tadcaster3 seats · turnout 49.7%
| Donald Bain-Mackay | Independent | 1,526 ✓ |
| Richard Sweeting | Conservative | 1,056 ✓ |
| Andrew Lee | Conservative | 801 ✓ |
| Stephen Cobb | Labour | 611 |
| David John Bowgett | Labour | 454 |
Thorpe Willoughby1 seat · turnout 28.9%
| Cliff Lunn | Conservative | 480 ✓ |
| Gavin Nigel Xavier Harding | Labour | 230 |
Whitley1 seat · turnout 40.2%
| John McCartney | Independent | 565 ✓ |
| Laura Watkinson-Teo | Conservative | 269 |
| Neil William Lockwood | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 106 |