Before (end of 2018) (35 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 21 · Labour 13 · Other 1
After (end of 2019) (35 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 21 · Labour 14
Ward results
Arley & Whitacre3 seats · turnout 27.8%
| Jodie Gosling | Labour | 613 ✓ |
| Kerry Parker | Conservative | 567 ✓ |
| Ann McLauchlan | Labour | 562 ✓ |
| Sandra Anne Smith | Conservative | 523 |
| Helen Clare Zgraja | Conservative | 508 |
| Nigel Turley | Labour | 484 |
Atherstone Central2 seats · turnout 22.8%
| Neil Dirveiks | Labour | 306 ✓ |
| Dawn Downes | Labour | 261 ✓ |
| Mark Jodda Jordan | Conservative | 248 |
| Dan Hancocks | Conservative | 213 |
| Luke Haslam | Green | 118 |
Atherstone North2 seats · turnout 31.3%
| Ray Jarvis | Conservative | 403 ✓ |
| Mejar Singh | Conservative | 371 ✓ |
| Sara Bishop | Labour | 340 |
| Brian Henney | Labour | 333 |
| Robert Gisbourne | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 180 |
| Richard Freer | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 156 |
Atherstone South & Mancetter2 seats · turnout 29.4%
| Denise Clews | Conservative | 511 ✓ |
| Tony Clews | Conservative | 482 ✓ |
| Susan Allan-Stubbs | Labour | 354 |
| Martin Short | Labour | 329 |
Baddesley & Grendon2 seats · turnout 36.3%
| Andy Wright | Conservative | 718 ✓ |
| Bernadette Davey | Conservative | 676 ✓ |
| John Moore | Labour | 456 |
| Ian Driver | Labour | 429 |
Coleshill North2 seats · turnout 31.4%
| Jack Deakin | Labour | 433 ✓ |
| Jane Farrow | Labour | 387 ✓ |
| Richard Habgood | Conservative | 357 |
| Julie Marie Hobster | Conservative | 325 |
Coleshill South2 seats · turnout 37.3%
| Caroline Symonds | Conservative | 552 ✓ |
| Colin Hayfield | Conservative | 494 ✓ |
| Claire Breeze | Labour | 378 |
| Chelsea Collis | Labour | 332 |
| David James Ellis Williams | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 123 |
| Mandy Williams | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 107 |
Curdworth2 seats · turnout 30.4%
| Mark Simpson | Conservative | 668 ✓ |
| Shelly Ann Lebrun | Conservative | 651 ✓ |
| Lauren Naylor | Labour | 168 |
| Susan Hammond | Labour | 161 |
Dordon2 seats · turnout 31.5%
| Jacky Chambers | Labour | 387 ✓ |
| Peter Frank Morson | Labour | 326 ✓ |
| Dave Hanratty | Conservative | 173 |
| Stuart Trevor Taylor | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 165 |
| Daniel Thomas Welch | Conservative | 113 |
Fillongley2 seats · turnout 29.8%
| Leslie John Smith | Conservative | 610 ✓ |
| David Wright | Conservative | 542 ✓ |
| Sue Kelly | Labour | 191 |
| Olwen Dutton | Labour | 178 |
Hartshill2 seats · turnout 32.7%
| Margaret Bell | Conservative | 458 ✓ |
| Barry Lees | Conservative | 389 ✓ |
| Cerys Howell | Labour | 327 |
| Elinor Parsons | Labour | 261 |
| Ian Bourne | Green | 156 |
Hurley & Wood End2 seats · turnout 25.4%
| Hayden Phillips | Labour | 416 ✓ |
| Owen Phillips | Labour | 371 ✓ |
| Robert John Hobster | Conservative | 327 |
| Martin Lee Watson | Conservative | 320 |
Kingsbury2 seats · turnout 41.4%
| Andy Jenns | Conservative | 752 ✓ |
| Brian Peter Moss | Conservative | 632 ✓ |
| Patrick Silke | Labour | 246 |
| Carol Ann Ayasamy | Independent | 221 |
| Alexandra Catherine Elizabeth Phillips | Labour | 218 |
Newton Regis & Warton2 seats · turnout 36.8%
| David Humphreys | Conservative | 579 ✓ |
| Marian Humphreys | Conservative | 561 ✓ |
| Fin Wood | Labour | 434 |
| Chris Clark | Labour | 422 |
Polesworth East2 seats · turnout 30.6%
| David Parsons | Labour | 588 ✓ |
| Adam Farrell | Labour | 487 ✓ |
| John Smitten | Conservative | 265 |
| Karen Marie Tracey | Conservative | 211 |
Polesworth West2 seats · turnout 27.1%
| Michael Osborne | Labour | 354 ✓ |
| Simon Rose | Labour | 351 ✓ |
| Susan Hanratty | Conservative | 346 |
| Richard Philip James Freakley | Conservative | 339 |
Water Orton2 seats · turnout 35.1%
| David Reilly | Conservative | 706 ✓ |
| Judy Macdonald | Conservative | 676 ✓ |
| Daniel Hodkinson | Labour | 280 |
| Alistair Brett | Labour | 195 |