Before (end of 2018) (28 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 27 · Other 1
After (end of 2019) (28 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 24 · Other 2 · Labour 1 · Liberal Democrats 1
Ward results
| Stephen Watson | Conservative | 595 ✓ |
| Fiona Yorke | Green | 246 |
| Jane Elizabeth Richardson | Labour | 63 |
Bagby and Thorntons1 seat
| Andrew Robinson | Independent | 573 ✓ |
| Bob Baker | Conservative | 513 |
Bedale3 seats · turnout 28.8%
| John Noone | Conservative | 1,168 ✓ |
| Michael Barningham | Conservative | 1,147 ✓ |
| Carl Les | Conservative | 1,032 ✓ |
| Michael Edwin Chaloner | Green | 670 |
| Patricia Mary Fairey | Green | 617 |
| Matthew James Sawyer | Green | 548 |
| Carl Walter | Labour | 246 |
Easingwold3 seats · turnout 38.3%
| Nigel Knapton | Conservative | 1,463 ✓ |
| Malcolm Taylor | Conservative | 1,312 ✓ |
| Paula Ruth Thompson | Conservative | 1,092 ✓ |
| Shirley Ann Shepherd | Independent | 927 |
| Bryony Hart | Labour | 734 |
| Nicholas Howarth Pulleyn | Labour | 689 |
| Deanna Maria Pearce | Labour | 638 |
Great Ayton2 seats · turnout 38.3%
| Ron Kirk | Conservative | 909 ✓ |
| Richard William Hudson | Conservative | 851 ✓ |
| Richard Thomas Short | Liberal Democrats | 537 |
| Nicholas Mark Land | Liberal Democrats | 472 |
| Glyn Pauline Mucklow | Labour | 352 |
Huby1 seat
| Di Watkins | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Hutton Rudby1 seat · turnout 40.2%
| Bridget Susan Fortune | Conservative | 633 ✓ |
| Pauline Mary Reed | Labour | 259 |
| Nicholas Ryan | Liberal Democrats | 180 |
Morton-on-Swale1 seat
| Brian Phillips | Conservative | 934 ✓ |
| Trevor Mitchell | Labour | 229 |
| Paul Anthony Atkin | Independent | 702 ✓ |
| Isobel Sanderson | Conservative | 504 ✓ |
| Joseph Andrew Clarke Lambert | Independent | 473 |
| David Maurice Blades | Conservative | 469 |
| Sally Anne Anderson | Labour | 431 |
Northallerton South2 seats · turnout 26.4%
| Caroline Dickinson | Conservative | 844 ✓ |
| Gerald Ramsden | Labour | 527 ✓ |
| Michael Heasman | Conservative | 526 |
Osmotherley and Swainby1 seat
| David Hugill | Conservative | 648 ✓ |
| Jackie Griffiths | Liberal Democrats | 163 |
| John Yorke | Green | 121 |
| Joseph James Body | Labour | 79 |
Raskelf and White Horse1 seat
| Jillian Mortimer | Conservative | 560 ✓ |
| John Timothy Law | Green | 396 |
Romanby2 seats · turnout 32.9%
| Kevin George Hardisty | Conservative | 1,096 ✓ |
| Peter Wilkinson | Conservative | 1,012 ✓ |
| Brian Leslie Hazeldine | Labour | 576 |
Sowerby and Topcliffe2 seats
| Mark Stewart Robson | Conservative | 1,002 ✓ |
| Peter Bardon | Conservative | 993 ✓ |
| Rosemary Kett | Labour | 561 |
| Jerome Scott Dawson Wright | Labour | 519 |
Stokesley2 seats · turnout 42.2%
| Bryn Griffiths | Liberal Democrats | 1,184 ✓ |
| Andrew Wake | Conservative | 927 ✓ |
| Peter Jeffrey Chapman | Liberal Democrats | 813 |
| Claire Gill | Conservative | 659 |
| Eileen Driver | Labour | 341 |
Tanfield1 seat · turnout 33.4%
| David Webster | Conservative | 600 ✓ |
| Anne Evelyn Mannix | Labour | 209 |
Thirsk2 seats · turnout 30.3%
| Gareth Dadd | Conservative | 1,151 ✓ |
| Dave Elders | Conservative | 990 ✓ |
| Diane Louise Brown | Green | 413 |
| Marcus Ridley Missen | Labour | 236 |
| Paul Hinton Smith | Labour | 219 |