Before (end of 2018) (30 seats, Open Council Data)
Other 15 · Conservative 13 · Liberal Democrats 2
After (end of 2019) (30 seats, Open Council Data)
Other 16 · Conservative 12 · Liberal Democrats 2
Ward results
Amotherby1 seat · turnout 36.7%
| Steve Mason | Liberal Democrats | 307 ✓ |
| Fiona Anne Farnell | Conservative | 246 |
Ampleforth1 seat · turnout 39.3%
| James Bailey | Conservative | 259 ✓ |
| Christopher Pickles | Liberal Democrats | 251 |
Cropton1 seat · turnout 48.9%
| John Clark | The Liberal Party | 352 ✓ |
| Richard Adam Dent | Independent | 167 |
| Truda Lansdowne | Conservative | 128 |
Dales1 seat · turnout 47.9%
| Janet Frank | Independent | 333 ✓ |
| Fabia Tate | Conservative | 190 |
Derwent2 seats · turnout 46.8%
| Michael Joseph Thomas Cleary | Conservative | 518 ✓ |
| Sue Graham | Conservative | 453 ✓ |
| Naomi Fulvia Clare Baylay Cox | Liberal Democrats | 444 |
| Angela Helen Cole | Labour | 296 |
Helmsley2 seats · turnout 42.7%
| Snowy Windress | Independent | 501 ✓ |
| Steve Arnold | Independent | 461 ✓ |
| Joanne Welford | Conservative | 311 |
| Donald Ferguson Wallace | Conservative | 304 |
| Barbara Jane Hickman | Green | 271 |
Hovingham1 seat · turnout 42.3%
| Clarie Docwra | Conservative | 207 ✓ |
| Abbie Louise Knowlson | Independent | 184 |
| Barry Michael Doyle | Liberal Democrats | 143 |
| Helen Margaret Broxup-Yellen | Labour | 61 |
Kirkbymoorside2 seats · turnout 49.0%
| Tony Riby | Independent | 405 ✓ |
| David Edward Cussons | Independent | 285 ✓ |
| Derek Warren Chapman | Liberal Democrats | 271 |
| Bob Gardiner | Conservative | 259 |
| Paul Martin Ashley | Conservative | 258 |
| Martin Brampton | Green | 238 |
| David Mellen | Labour | 164 |
Malton3 seats · turnout 39.3%
| Lindsay Marie Burr | Independent | 896 ✓ |
| Paul Andrews | Independent | 721 ✓ |
| Angela Elizabeth Kirkham-Raine | Independent | 607 ✓ |
| Rory Craig Queen | Conservative | 499 |
| Stephen Shaw | Independent | 427 |
| Luke Campbell | Conservative | 383 |
| Sammie Delaney | Conservative | 377 |
| Jack Stanley George Ashton | Labour | 316 |
Norton East2 seats · turnout 34.0%
| Keane Charles Duncan | Conservative | 745 ✓ |
| Raymond King | Conservative | 554 ✓ |
| Elizabeth Lois Shields | Liberal Democrats | 264 |
| Nick Witteveen | Liberal Democrats | 130 |
| Rosalie Theresa Dennis Wilkinson | Labour | 127 |
Norton West2 seats · turnout 35.2%
| Di Keal | Liberal Democrats | 481 ✓ |
| John Mackenzie | Conservative | 427 ✓ |
| Thomas Pinder | Conservative | 413 |
| Howard Keal | Liberal Democrats | 382 |
Pickering East2 seats · turnout 53.4%
| Joy Andrews | LIB | 630 ✓ |
| Clive Miller Wass | The Liberal Party | 396 ✓ |
| Charles Henry Hopkinson | Independent | 376 |
| Paul Littlewood | Conservative | 345 |
| Greg White | Conservative | 285 |
| Douglas Sutherland | Labour | 122 |
| Peter Nicolas Winter | Liberal Democrats | 109 |
Pickering West2 seats · turnout 38.9%
| Carrie Brackstone | LIB | 592 ✓ |
| Mike Potter | LIB | 567 ✓ |
| Linda Cowling | Independent | 297 |
| Philip Robert Hall | Conservative | 209 |
| Matthew Jonathan Haynes | Conservative | 206 |
Rillington1 seat
| Nathan Garbutt Moore | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Ryedale South West1 seat
| Caroline Goodrick | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Sherburn1 seat · turnout 27.5%
| John Robert Raper | Independent | 217 ✓ |
| Paul Emberley | Conservative | 206 |
Sheriff Hutton1 seat · turnout 36.2%
| Eric Hope | Independent | 319 ✓ |
| Jeremy David Bleasdale | Conservative | 190 |
Sinnington1 seat · turnout 45.3%
| Simon Noel Roy Thackray | Independent | 498 ✓ |
| Angela Egan | Conservative | 147 |
Thornton Dale2 seats · turnout 49.5%
| Christopher Wayne Delaney | Conservative | 623 ✓ |
| William Oxley | Conservative | 569 ✓ |
| Sandra Kathleen Bell | Green | 445 |
| Maurice Johnston | Labour | 292 |
Wolds1 seat
| Tracie Middleton | Conservative | 0 ✓ |