Before (end of 2018) (52 seats, Open Council Data)
Labour 25 · Conservative 22 · Other 4 · Liberal Democrats 1
After (end of 2019) (39 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 17 · Labour 15 · Other 4 · UK Independence Party (UKIP) 1 · Green 1 · Liberal Democrats 1
Ward results
Belah and Kingmoor3 seats
| David Morton | Conservative | 860 ✓ |
| Gareth Ellis | Conservative | 831 ✓ |
| Helen Davison | Green | 719 ✓ |
| Patricia Vasey | Conservative | 622 |
| Alan Toole | Independent | 558 |
| Steven John William Bowditch | Labour | 502 |
| Jessica Riddle | Labour | 387 |
| Anne Quilter | Labour | 362 |
| Niall James Scott | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 351 |
| Michael Anthony Gee | Liberal Democrats | 218 |
Botcherby and Harraby North3 seats
| Robert Betton | Independent | 1,016 ✓ |
| Jeffrey Thomas Bomford | Independent | 696 ✓ |
| Jack Paton | Independent | 647 ✓ |
| Susan Crawford | Labour | 503 |
| David Graham | Labour | 441 |
| Mohammed Abdul Harid | Labour | 415 |
| Jacklyn Freda Hunton | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 326 |
| Lawrence Neil Fisher | Conservative | 229 |
| Suzanne Mary Greenwood | Conservative | 194 |
| Val Marriner | Conservative | 159 |
| Fiona Marie Prior | Green | 149 |
| Mark Smith | CumbriaFirst | 112 |
| Laura Ward | CumbriaFirst | 76 |
Brampton and Fellside3 seats
| Mike Mitchelson | Conservative | 1,150 ✓ |
| Raymond Tinnion | Independent | 1,052 ✓ |
| Keith Meller | Conservative | 877 ✓ |
| Sharon Seymour | Green | 793 |
| Doreen Parsons | Conservative | 690 |
| Elizabeth Furneaux | Labour | 675 |
| Rosemary Logie | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 377 |
Cathedral and Castle3 seats
| Anne Glendinning | Labour | 817 ✓ |
| Louise Atkinson | Labour | 763 ✓ |
| Christopher Peter Robinson | Labour | 695 ✓ |
| Rachael Hunt | Green | 430 |
| Pauline Dorothy Finlayson | Conservative | 364 |
| Michael Jon Story | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 336 |
| Kathleen Mary Rowley | Conservative | 333 |
| Stephen Ronald Sidgwick | Independent | 312 |
| William Stuart | Conservative | 303 |
| David John Wood | Liberal Democrats | 200 |
Currock and Upperby3 seats
| Colin William Glover | Labour | 798 ✓ |
| Lucy Patrick | Labour | 667 ✓ |
| John Denholm | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 556 ✓ |
| Robert Rynn | Labour | 555 |
| Max Joseph Graham | Conservative | 326 |
| Neville John Lishman | Conservative | 293 |
| Hannah Dolan | Conservative | 283 |
| Sky Higgins | Green | 251 |
| James Ernest Osler | Liberal Democrats | 237 |
Dalston and Burgh3 seats
| Trevor Allison | Liberal Democrats | 1,449 ✓ |
| Ann Vipond McKerrell | Conservative | 1,089 ✓ |
| John Collier | Conservative | 923 ✓ |
| Rachael Mitchell | Conservative | 614 |
| Paul Anthony Cross | Green | 572 |
| Erin Reed | Labour | 469 |
| Phil Douglass | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 357 |
| Christopher Southward | Labour | 734 ✓ |
| Ruth Elizabeth Alcroft | Labour | 725 ✓ |
| Lisa Brown | Labour | 690 ✓ |
| John Duncan Warmingham | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 376 |
| Colin May | CumbriaFirst | 366 |
| Barbara Eden | Conservative | 336 |
| Robin Finlayson | Conservative | 336 |
| Rob Morrison | Green | 331 |
| Charles Henry McKerrell | Conservative | 325 |
Harraby South and Parklands3 seats
| Lee Barbara Sherriff | Labour | 721 ✓ |
| Niall Daniel McNulty | Labour | 689 ✓ |
| Joanne Ellis-Williams | Labour | 649 ✓ |
| Linda Margaret Mitchell | Conservative | 543 |
| Gillian Marie Dobson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 537 |
| Geoffrey Osborne | Conservative | 487 |
| Syed Ajmol Ali | Conservative | 438 |
| Alan Peters | Green | 263 |
| Fiona Kelly | Independent | 236 |
Longtown and the Border3 seats
| Valerie Tarbitt | Conservative | 1,028 ✓ |
| John Mallinson | Conservative | 906 ✓ |
| David Shepherd | Conservative | 885 ✓ |
| Henry Bryson Goodwin | Green | 471 |
| Fiona Mills | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 438 |
| Pete Sunter | Labour | 361 |
Newtown and Morton North3 seats
| Leslie Tickner | Labour | 739 ✓ |
| Pamela Birks | Labour | 709 ✓ |
| Calvin Rodgerson | Labour | 647 ✓ |
| Robbie Reid-Sinclair | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 459 |
| Hugh Boyd McKerrell | Conservative | 455 |
| Olive Bloxham | Conservative | 425 |
| James Porter | Conservative | 386 |
| Harry Atkinson | Green | 315 |
Sandsfield and Morton West3 seats
| James Bainbridge | Conservative | 976 ✓ |
| Christina Agnes Finlayson | Conservative | 878 ✓ |
| Jeanette Bradley | Labour | 867 ✓ |
| Robert Currie | Conservative | 835 |
| Timothy Linford | Labour | 732 |
| Reginald Watson | Labour | 646 |
| Hayley Danielle Wright | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 481 |
| Jeffrey Coates | Liberal Democrats | 423 |
| Penelope Bothepa Foster | Green | 333 |
Stanwix and Houghton3 seats
| Elizabeth Mallinson | Conservative | 1,292 ✓ |
| Fiona Robson | Conservative | 1,134 ✓ |
| Paul Nedved | Conservative | 1,131 ✓ |
| John Bernard Reardon | Green | 720 |
| Joanne Burke | Labour | 695 |
| Julie Simpson | Labour | 668 |
| Afsah Oomar-Snaith | Labour | 507 |
| John James Harding | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 426 |
Wetheral and Corby3 seats
| Stephen Michael Higgs | Conservative | 1,101 ✓ |
| Nigel Edward Christian | Conservative | 1,023 ✓ |
| Marilyn Louise Bowman | Conservative | 953 ✓ |
| William Graham | Independent | 649 |
| Dallas Jane Brewis | Green | 593 |
| Christopher Stanley Moss | Liberal Democrats | 501 |
| George Colin Stothard | Labour | 451 |
| Geoff Round | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 330 |