Before (end of 2018) (43 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 28 · Other 15
After (end of 2019) (43 seats, Open Council Data)
Other 22 · Conservative 21
Ward results
| Steve Clegg | Independent | 934 ✓ |
| Jim Clarke | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 747 ✓ |
| Amanda Rebecca Redsell | Conservative | 385 |
| Mary Louise Green | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 783 ✓ |
| Chris Spray | — | 772 ✓ |
| Patricia Woodman | Conservative | 626 |
| Susan Howe | Conservative | 586 |
| Gillian Ogden | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
| Jordan Moran | — | 985 ✓ |
| Peter Burley | Conservative | 940 ✓ |
| Lindsey Cawrey | Conservative | 916 ✓ |
| Mike Gallagher | Conservative | 901 |
| John Kilcoyne | — | 876 |
| Funmi Adeyemi | Labour | 485 |
Branston2 seats · turnout 38.6%
| Peter Lundgren | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 903 ✓ |
| Ray Cucksey | Conservative | 641 ✓ |
| Greg Tebb | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 603 |
| Denise Frances Elizabeth Christine Penistan | Conservative | 358 |
Cliff Villages2 seats · turnout 36.3%
| Marianne Jane Overton | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 1,467 ✓ |
| Lucille Hagues | Conservative | 1,098 ✓ |
| Kay Anne Johnson | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 493 |
| Charles Peter Overton | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 703 ✓ |
| Sally Appleby | Conservative | 568 ✓ |
| Peter Gelly Rothwell | Conservative | 525 |
Heckington Rural2 seats · turnout 32.9%
| Sally Tarry | Conservative | 914 ✓ |
| Stewart Ogden | Conservative | 833 ✓ |
| Michael Juan Overton | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 570 |
Heighington & Washingborough3 seats · turnout 37.8%
| Glenn Nigel Tinsley | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 1,259 ✓ |
| Ian Carrington | Conservative | 886 ✓ |
| Carola Goodwin | Conservative | 731 ✓ |
| Dean Harlow | Conservative | 580 |
Kirkby la Thorpe & South Kyme1 seat · turnout 38.1%
| Mervyn Paul Head | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 634 ✓ |
| Robert Charles Greetham | Independent | 126 |
Leasingham and Rauceby1 seat
| Susan Waring | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Metheringham2 seats · turnout 31.5%
| Nick Byatt | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 814 ✓ |
| Laura Pearson | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 807 ✓ |
| John Frank Money | Conservative | 544 |
| Margaret Clarke | Conservative | 489 |
North Hykeham Forum1 seat · turnout 28.7%
| Kay Esme Gilliland | Independent | 296 ✓ |
| Paul James Johnson | Conservative | 226 |
North Hykeham Memorial1 seat · turnout 23.6%
| Nikki Dillon | — | 417 ✓ |
| Gary John Edwards | Conservative | 208 |
North Hykeham Mill2 seats · turnout 19.9%
| Stephen Roe | Conservative | 561 ✓ |
| Susannah Barker-Milan | Conservative | 478 ✓ |
| Corinne Byron | Liberal Democrats | 332 |
North Hykeham Moor1 seat · turnout 26.2%
| Pam Whittaker | Conservative | 308 ✓ |
| George Michael Tipler | Independent | 175 |
North Hykeham Witham1 seat
| Ross Little | Conservative | 0 ✓ |
Osbournby1 seat · turnout 39.8%
| Russell Michael Jackson | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 471 ✓ |
| Andrew Hagues | Conservative | 312 |
Ruskington2 seats · turnout 30.0%
| Richard Andrew Wright | Conservative | 695 ✓ |
| Terry Boston | Conservative | 654 ✓ |
| Tracy Jane Giannasi | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 643 |
| Tom Head | — | 495 |
Skellingthorpe2 seats · turnout 49.3%
| Christopher Goldson | Independent | 757 ✓ |
| Richard Johnston | — | 332 ✓ |
| Robert Andrew Walshaw | Independent | 306 |
| Jennifer Rosalind Drummond Gordon | Conservative | 229 |
| Tony Richardson | Liberal Democrats | 104 |
Sleaford Castle1 seat · turnout 25.2%
| Cara Jade Sandy | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 194 ✓ |
| Linda Edwards-Shea | Labour | 172 |
| Steve Fields | Conservative | 172 |
Sleaford Holdingham1 seat · turnout 24.3%
| Robert Oates | Lincolnshire Independents Lincolnshire First | 253 ✓ |
| Ken Fernandes | Independent | 114 |
| Stephen Shanahan-Kluth | Conservative | 103 |
| Linda Margaret Lowndes | Labour | 89 |
Sleaford Navigation1 seat · turnout 28.9%
| David Suiter | Independent | 274 ✓ |
| Dan Gray | Conservative | 181 |
| Tarek Hayat | Labour | 126 |
Sleaford Quarrington & Mareham3 seats · turnout 32.8%
| Bozena Allan | Independent | 827 ✓ |
| Michael Kent | Conservative | 640 ✓ |
| Melody Shanahan-Kluth | Conservative | 614 ✓ |
| Tim Conning | Conservative | 581 |
| Paul Andrew Edwards-Shea | Labour | 447 |
Sleaford Westholme1 seat · turnout 23.9%
| Anthony Brand | Independent | 239 ✓ |
| Heather Katherine Lorimer | Independent | 204 |
Waddington West1 seat · turnout 25.6%
| Lance Pennell | Conservative | 333 ✓ |
| Matt Newman | Labour | 183 |
