Before (end of 2018) (63 seats, Open Council Data)
Labour 56 · Conservative 4 · Other 2 · Liberal Democrats 1
After (end of 2019) (63 seats, Open Council Data)
Labour 49 · Other 7 · Liberal Democrats 4 · Conservative 3
Ward results
Central1 seat · turnout 19.9%
| Martin Dyson | Labour | 750 ✓ |
| Christopher Michael Scarfe | Green | 474 |
| Adrian Thompson | Conservative | 289 |
| Connor Audsley | Liberal Democrats | 182 |
Cudworth1 seat · turnout 18.1%
| Charlie Wraith | Labour | 933 ✓ |
| John Ellis-Mourant | Liberal Democrats | 340 |
| Martin Brook | Conservative | 240 |
Darfield1 seat · turnout 25.0%
| Trevor Smith | — | 750 ✓ |
| Dorothy Coates | Labour | 666 |
| Kim Boon | Liberal Democrats | 198 |
| Maxine Spencer | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 191 |
| Delia Mary Weldon | Conservative | 165 |
Darton East1 seat · turnout 30.6%
| Steve Hunt | Liberal Democrats | 1,832 ✓ |
| Martin Andrew Flack | Labour | 570 |
| Debbie Toon | Conservative | 197 |
Darton West1 seat · turnout 24.8%
| Trevor Cave | Labour | 810 ✓ |
| Tom Heyes | Green | 499 |
| Lee Ogden | Conservative | 452 |
| Andy Waters | Liberal Democrats | 277 |
Dearne North1 seat · turnout 17.5%
| Alan Gardiner | Labour | 799 ✓ |
| Janus Polenceusz | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 485 |
| Cicely Anne Cowgill | Conservative | 134 |
Dearne South1 seat · turnout 24.8%
| Sam Danforth | Independent | 1,173 ✓ |
| Graham Jarvis | Labour | 801 |
| Adrian Morgan | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 175 |
| David Malcolm Hunter | Conservative | 119 |
Dodworth1 seat · turnout 34.1%
| Peter James Fielding | Liberal Democrats | 1,308 ✓ |
| Richard Mark Riggs | Labour | 647 |
| Jonathan Christopher Liam Hastelow | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 440 |
| Chris Burrows | YORKS | 260 |
| Adam Fletcher Bromfield | Conservative | 212 |
Hoyland Milton1 seat · turnout 24.3%
| Tim Shepherd | Labour | 982 ✓ |
| Daniel Kristoffer Simpson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 701 |
| Donna Marie Cutts | Conservative | 240 |
| Glenn Lawrence | Liberal Democrats | 173 |
| Justin Saxton | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 134 |
Kingstone1 seat · turnout 21.2%
| Kevin George Williams | Labour | 609 ✓ |
| Peter Doyle | Five Star Direct Democracy Party | 490 |
| Peter Gordon Giles | Green | 252 |
| Elizabeth Kate Waters | Liberal Democrats | 125 |
| Jack Miller | Conservative | 107 |
| Angela Waller | Socialist Alternative | 56 |
Monk Bretton1 seat · turnout 26.3%
| Vicky Felton | — | 1,236 ✓ |
| Margaret Sheard | Labour | 660 |
| Ryan Williams | YORKS | 268 |
| George Hill | Conservative | 105 |
North East1 seat · turnout 21.8%
| Anita Cherryholme | Labour | 786 ✓ |
| Raymond Archer | Independent | 712 |
| Tony Devoy | YORKS | 467 |
| Samuel Wilkinson | Conservative | 207 |
Old Town1 seat · turnout 24.6%
| Jo Newing | Labour | 720 ✓ |
| Donald Wood | Independent | 698 |
| Kate Helen Raynor | Green | 259 |
| Kevin Bennett | Liberal Democrats | 191 |
| Clive Watkinson | Conservative | 185 |
Penistone East1 seat · turnout 37.0%
| Paul Hand-Davis | Conservative | 1,359 ✓ |
| Sean Waters | Liberal Democrats | 929 |
| Dave Webster | Labour | 602 |
| Lee Goulding | YORKS | 562 |
Penistone West1 seat · turnout 36.3%
| David Greenhough | Liberal Democrats | 1,583 ✓ |
| Andrew Millner | Conservative | 753 |
| Donald Wood | Independent | 563 |
| Roy Bowser | Labour | 465 |
| Richard Thomas James Trotman | Green | 255 |
Rockingham1 seat · turnout 25.7%
| Chris Lamb | Labour | 803 ✓ |
| Steven Sylvester | Bath Northeast Somerset Independent Group (BIG) | 588 |
| Kevin Riddiough | English Democrats | 274 |
| Michael James Davies | Conservative | 244 |
| Benjamin Luke Holland | Green | 202 |
| Paul Nugent | Liberal Democrats | 88 |
Royston1 seat · turnout 22.9%
| Pauline McCarthy | Labour | 953 ✓ |
| Kirk Harper | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 752 |
| Annabel Wilkinson | Conservative | 225 |
St Helens1 seat · turnout 18.6%
| Jenny Platts | Labour | 901 ✓ |
| Alan Jones | Green | 401 |
| Jacob Graham Griffin | Conservative | 169 |
Stairfoot1 seat · turnout 21.6%
| Andy Gillis | Barnsley Independent Group | 1,057 ✓ |
| Karen Dyson | Labour | 702 |
| Elizabeth Hill | Conservative | 121 |
| James Robert Kitching | Liberal Democrats | 82 |
Wombwell1 seat · turnout 18.1%
| Brenda Eastwood | Labour | 907 ✓ |
| Sharon Gillis | Bath Northeast Somerset Independent Group (BIG) | 414 |
| Jon Seymour | English Democrats Party - Putting England First | 186 |
| Sue Rose | Liberal Democrats | 136 |
| Gareth Thompson | Conservative | 25 |
Worsbrough1 seat · turnout 25.3%
| Jake Michael Lodge | Independent | 948 ✓ |
| Roya Pourali | Labour | 625 |
| Michael Barraclough | Conservative | 181 |
| Sarah Calvert | Liberal Democrats | 147 |