Before (end of 2018) (34 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 24 · Other 9 · Liberal Democrats 1
After (end of 2019) (24 seats, Open Council Data)
Other 10 · Conservative 10 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Green 1
Ward results
| Paul Spencer | Independent | 677 ✓ |
| Ian Richard Threlfall | Conservative | 616 ✓ |
| Liz Rowe | Independent | 599 ✓ |
| Stephen Wyrill | Conservative | 510 |
| Richard Heylings | Conservative | 406 |
Colburn2 seats · turnout 21.9%
| Angie Dale | Independent | 392 ✓ |
| Kevin Foster | Green | 307 ✓ |
| Bill Glover | Conservative | 228 |
| Jane Wyrill | Conservative | 74 |
Croft and Middleton Tyas2 seats
| Adrian Thompson | Conservative | 535 ✓ |
| Campbell Dawson | Conservative | 522 ✓ |
| Jane Elizabeth Parlour | Liberal Democrats | 400 |
| Bev Partridge | Independent | 285 |
| Harold John Millar | Liberal Democrats | 265 |
| Kenneth Smith | Labour | 122 |
Gilling West1 seat · turnout 68.9%
| William Heslop | Independent | 440 ✓ |
| Jamie William Graham Cameron | Conservative | 238 |
| John Blackie | Independent | 709 ✓ |
| Pat Kirkbride | Conservative | 128 |
Hipswell2 seats · turnout 22.1%
| Phyllis Cullen | Independent | 326 ✓ |
| Lawrence Grose | Conservative | 192 ✓ |
| Richard Eric Blows | Conservative | 167 |
Leyburn2 seats · turnout 68.2%
| John Amsden | Independent | 742 ✓ |
| Karin Sedgwick | Conservative | 579 ✓ |
| Tony Duff | Conservative | 385 |
| Marian Knowles | Labour | 252 |
| Richard Donald Good | Liberal Democrats | 316 ✓ |
| Ian Scott | Conservative | 236 |
| Robbie Kelly | Green | 81 |
| David Andrew Dixon | Labour | 41 |
Lower Wensleydale1 seat · turnout 48.9%
| Richard Ormston | Conservative | 335 ✓ |
| Lisle Robert Dudley Ryder | Green | 244 |
Melsonby1 seat · turnout 47.9%
| James Wilson-Petch | Conservative | 364 ✓ |
| Philip Knowles | Liberal Democrats | 176 |
Middleham1 seat · turnout 52.5%
| Susan Amanda Fairhurst | Conservative | 406 ✓ |
| Nigel Ivan Hopper | Labour | 107 |
Richmond East1 seat · turnout 32.3%
| Philip David Wicks | Liberal Democrats | 408 ✓ |
| Hazel Leah | Conservative | 266 |
Richmond North1 seat
| Lorraine Hodgson | Independent | 274 ✓ |
| David Johnson | Conservative | 161 |
| Anna Jackson | Green | 58 |
| Gill Page | Labour | 42 |
Richmond West2 seats
| Stuart Parsons | Independent | 703 ✓ |
| Clive Ronald World | Liberal Democrats | 592 ✓ |
| Jo Foster | Liberal Democrats | 350 |
| Dave Dalton | Green | 275 |
| Muriel Rose Blythman | Conservative | 200 |
| Alexander Adam Grose | Conservative | 181 |
Scotton2 seats · turnout 63.6%
| Helen Grant | Independent | 434 ✓ |
| Patricia Middlemiss | Conservative | 335 ✓ |
| Geoffrey Linehan | Conservative | 281 |
| Martin Paul Smith | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 214 |
| Mark Peter Smith | Labour | 123 |
Yoredale1 seat
| Yvonne Peacock | Conservative | 578 ✓ |
| Hugo Keeling Radice | Labour | 138 |