Before (end of 2018) (42 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 22 · Other 11 · Liberal Democrats 9
After (end of 2019) (42 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 16 · Other 15 · Liberal Democrats 11
Ward results
Bletchingley And Nutfield1 seat · turnout 34.9%
| Gill Black | Conservative | 683 ✓ |
| Helena Mary Windsor | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 364 |
| Richard Barry Fowler | Liberal Democrats | 341 |
| Linda Ruth Baharier | Labour | 145 |
Burstow, Horne and Outwood1 seat · turnout 34.4%
| Colin Arthur White | Independent | 677 ✓ |
| Lydia Ridge | Conservative | 589 |
| Judy Wilkinson | Liberal Democrats | 134 |
| Catherine Margaret Baart | Green | 129 |
| Fern Warwick-Ching | Labour | 86 |
Chaldon1 seat · turnout 42.7%
| Bob Milton | Conservative | 418 ✓ |
| Neil Martin Parker | Liberal Democrats | 114 |
| Gordon Bailey | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 56 |
| Darron Ward | Labour | 17 |
Dormansland and Felcourt1 seat
| Lesley Susan Steeds | Conservative | 585 ✓ |
| Bridget Marguerite Davey | Independent | 552 |
| Dave Wilkes | Liberal Democrats | 145 |
FELBRIDGE1 seat · turnout 43.1%
| Ken Harwood | Conservative | 489 ✓ |
| Mike Crane | Independent | 175 |
| Becky Peterson | Green | 88 |
Godstone1 seat · turnout 41.3%
| Charlotte Swann | Independent | 1,354 ✓ |
| Nick Childs | Conservative | 266 |
| David Nickols | Liberal Democrats | 83 |
| Barbara Ann Wantling | Labour | 75 |
| Peter James Murphy | Green | 75 |
Limpsfield1 seat · turnout 52.0%
| Claire Lesley Blackwell | Oxted & Limpsfield Residents Group | 1,043 ✓ |
| Richard Mark Adamson | Conservative | 349 |
| Martin Caxton | Liberal Democrats | 89 |
Lingfield and Crowhurst1 seat · turnout 41.5%
| Liz Lockwood | Independent | 887 ✓ |
| Clive Nicholas Jecks | Conservative | 334 |
| Peter James Montagnon | Liberal Democrats | 119 |
OXTED NORTH & TANDRIDGE1 seat · turnout 53.0%
| David Stamp | Oxted & Limpsfield Residents Group | 1,584 ✓ |
| Martin Fisher | Conservative | 578 |
| Sheelagh Diane Crampton | Liberal Democrats | 111 |
| Patrick Joseph Rogers | Labour | 63 |
Oxted South1 seat · turnout 42.6%
| Chris Langton | — | 1,282 ✓ |
| Alan Francis Feesey | Conservative | 334 |
| Helena Elisabeth Forsythe | Social Democratic Party | 148 |
| Che Ramsden | Labour | 142 |
| Jonathan Salisbury | Liberal Democrats | 119 |
Portley1 seat · turnout 31.4%
| Kerry Lee Mansfield | Liberal Democrats | 595 ✓ |
| Sakina Bradbury | Conservative | 276 |
| Mark Adrian Fowler | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 106 |
| Ian Giddings | Labour | 74 |
Tatsfield And Titsey1 seat · turnout 35.5%
| Martin William Allen | Independent | 316 ✓ |
| Alex Standen | Conservative | 132 |
| Carol Dean | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 63 |
| Sarah Jane Stewart | Labour | 34 |
Valley1 seat · turnout 35.6%
| Dorinda Cooper | Liberal Democrats | 647 ✓ |
| Adam Bradbury | Conservative | 179 |
| Judy Moore | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 110 |
| Carron Walker | Labour | 99 |
Warlingham East And Chelsham And Farleigh1 seat · turnout 33.1%
| Celia Caulcott | Liberal Democrats | 796 ✓ |
| Perry Chotai | Conservative | 400 |
| Martin Arthur Haley | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 177 |
| Michael Snowden | Labour | 73 |