Before (end of 2020) (45 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 30 · Green 6 · Other 6 · Liberal Democrats 3
After (end of 2021) (45 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 28 · Other 7 · Green 7 · Liberal Democrats 3
Ward results
Banstead Village1 seat
| Nadean Moses | Conservative | 1,731 ✓ |
| Rowlands S.L. | Green | 309 |
| Golding J. | Labour | 254 |
| Mark Johnston | Liberal Democrats | 234 |
| M.D. Johnson | Liberal Democrats | 621 |
Earlswood & Whitebushes2 seats
| Booton J. | Green | 1,331 ✓ |
| Della Torra | Green | 1,106 ✓ |
| Thomson B. | Conservative | 799 |
| Chris Reynolds | Conservative | 686 |
| Giles R.W. | Labour | 347 |
| Scott M.R. | Labour | 271 |
Hooley, Merstham & Netherne2 seats
| Frank Kelly | Conservative | 1,423 ✓ |
| Tary M. | Conservative | 1,003 ✓ |
| Aklilu S. | Labour | 745 |
| Abram S. | Green | 554 |
| Thirlwall I. | Labour | 521 |
| Jemma de Vincenzo | Liberal Democrats | 510 |
Horley Central & South1 seat
| Stevens C. | Conservative | 1,381 ✓ |
| Tom Turner | Labour | 631 |
| Watson W.A. | Green | 386 |
Horley East & Salfords2 seats
| Anna King | Conservative | 1,194 ✓ |
| Baker J.P. | Conservative | 1,118 ✓ |
| Shasha Khan | Green | 854 |
| Easterbrook L. | Labour | 529 |
| Latter T. | Labour | 364 |
Horley West & Sidlow1 seat
| Buttironi G. | Conservative | 1,331 ✓ |
| Hughes C.E. | Labour | 612 |
| Geoff Southall | Liberal Democrats | 319 |
| Cooper Z.S. | Conservative | 2,018 ✓ |
| Thompson C.G.A. | Liberal Democrats | 379 |
| Peet J. | Green | 306 |
| Burnley D.A. | Labour | 272 |
Meadvale & St John's1 seat
| Martin Elbourne | Liberal Democrats | 1,226 ✓ |
| Jonathan Francis White | Conservative | 1,102 |
| Mark Smith | Labour | 472 |
| Alastair Richardson | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 53 |
Nork1 seat
| Peter Harp | RES | 1,909 ✓ |
| Jane Illingworth | Conservative | 586 |
| Calli Mistry | Labour | 153 |
| Knights C.J.G. | Liberal Democrats | 103 |
Redhill East1 seat · turnout 38.9%
| Sue Sinden | Green | 1,528 ✓ |
| Manzoor S. | Conservative | 557 |
| Mick Hay | Labour | 273 |
| Sachdeva K. | Conservative | 1,143 ✓ |
| Percy F. | Green | 528 |
| Rosie Norgrove | Labour | 516 |
| Holmes S.N. | Liberal Democrats | 498 |
Reigate1 seat
| Michael Blacker | Conservative | 1,580 ✓ |
| John Vincent | Liberal Democrats | 673 |
| Andrew Proudfoot | Green | 652 |
| Tony Robinson | Labour | 304 |
South Park & Woodhatch1 seat
| Paul Chandler | Green | 1,317 ✓ |
| Rickman S.G.J. | Conservative | 912 |
| Giles L.A. | Labour | 289 |
| Harper B. | RES | 1,226 ✓ |
| Aaron Harris | Conservative | 501 |
| Boeje S. | Labour | 245 |
| Morten A.P.G. | Green | 93 |
| Knights A.J. | Liberal Democrats | 70 |