Before (end of 2020) (84 seats, Open Council Data)
Labour 45 · Liberal Democrats 26 · Green 8 · Other 5
After (end of 2021) (84 seats, Open Council Data)
Labour 40 · Liberal Democrats 29 · Green 13 · Conservative 1 · Other 1
Ward results
Beauchief & Greenhill1 seat
| Thornton S.J. | Liberal Democrats | 1,732 ✓ |
| Cox G. | Labour | 1,695 |
| Finney E.R. | Conservative | 1,070 |
| Glyn Marsden | Green | 686 |
Beighton1 seat · turnout 31.9%
| Ann Woolhouse | Liberal Democrats | 1,441 ✓ |
| Gledhill J. | Labour | 1,399 |
| Clayton S.D. | Conservative | 1,089 |
| Anthony Richard Naylor | Green | 340 |
| Drabble G. | TUSC | 63 |
Birley1 seat · turnout 29.1%
| Lodge B.G. | Labour | 1,848 ✓ |
| Winstone S.D. | Conservative | 1,241 |
| Yearsley A.B.A. | Green | 437 |
| Elwood J.R. | Liberal Democrats | 211 |
Broomhill and Sharrow Vale1 seat · turnout 29.8%
| Brian Holmshaw | Green | 2,653 ✓ |
| Norris A.J. | Labour | 2,576 |
| Oulton T.H. | Conservative | 436 |
| Parkin T. | Liberal Democrats | 326 |
| Foster R. | TUSC | 112 |
Burngreave1 seat · turnout 26.7%
| Safiya Saeed | Labour | 2,576 ✓ |
| Ahmed M.A. | Green | 425 |
| Richard K. | Conservative | 414 |
| Aston M.P. | Liberal Democrats | 169 |
| Jamison J.P. | Independent | 163 |
| Martin A. | YORKS | 101 |
| Harper S. | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 89 |
City1 seat · turnout 17.8%
| Douglas Johnson | Green | 1,230 ✓ |
| Matthew Dwyer | Labour | 796 |
| Higgins E. | Conservative | 168 |
| Mahroof H.A.A. | Liberal Democrats | 82 |
Crookes & Crosspool1 seat
| Ruth Milsom | Labour | 2,602 ✓ |
| Rebecca Atkinson | Liberal Democrats | 2,294 |
| Mulvaney R. | Green | 1,332 |
| Kunaka B.P. | Conservative | 629 |
| G. O'Shanks | YORKS | 123 |
Darnall1 seat · turnout 26.8%
| Iqbal M. | Labour | 2,078 ✓ |
| Asli Mohammed | Liberal Democrats | 641 |
| Pitchfork C. | Conservative | 631 |
| Zayed al-Mahfuz | Green | 203 |
| Spencer D. | TUSC | 132 |
Dore and Totley1 seat · turnout 51.9%
| Ross C.A. | Liberal Democrats | 3,697 ✓ |
| Chinchen S.L. | Conservative | 1,997 |
| Nicholson S.H. | Labour | 1,066 |
| Applebaum D.B. | Green | 959 |
East Ecclesfield1 seat · turnout 34.5%
| Alan Woodcock | Liberal Democrats | 1,498 ✓ |
| Bainbridge A. | Labour | 1,478 |
| Allcroft A.J. | Conservative | 1,344 |
| Alex James Robertson | Yorkshire Party | 264 |
| Stephenson A.A.R. | Green | 244 |
Ecclesall1 seat · turnout 53.7%
| Davison R.N. | Liberal Democrats | 2,904 ✓ |
| Z.J. Sykes | Labour | 2,168 |
| Leman J. | Green | 2,116 |
| Millward G.R. | Conservative | 1,044 |
| Rose C. | WEP | 200 |
| Cowell A.H. | SDP | 86 |
Firth Park1 seat
| Law A. | Labour | 1,896 ✓ |
| Steve Toone | Conservative | 810 |
| M.N. Elliot | Green | 327 |
| A. Worral | Independent | 157 |
| Kingdom A.P. | Liberal Democrats | 153 |
Fulwood1 seat · turnout 48.1%
| Sue Alston | Liberal Democrats | 3,212 ✓ |
| Kennedy J.M. | Labour | 1,510 |
| Strathdee N.J. | Green | 1,170 |
| Saunders C.M. | Conservative | 1,000 |
Gleadless Valley1 seat · turnout 39.2%
| Alexi Dimond | Green | 2,480 ✓ |
| Ridler J.H. | Labour | 1,995 |
| Mustoe A.D.R. | Conservative | 569 |
| Dryden J. | Liberal Democrats | 241 |
| Becky Payne | TUSC | 104 |
Graves Park1 seat · turnout 63.0%
| Auckland I. | Liberal Democrats | 2,357 ✓ |
| Edd Mustill | Labour | 1,815 |
| Critchlow L.E. | Green | 1,168 |
| Seun Ajao | Conservative | 677 |
Hillsborough1 seat · turnout 58.2%
| Christine Gilligan Kubo | Green | 2,337 ✓ |
| Bob Johnson | Labour | 2,013 |
| Lesley Blyth | Conservative | 906 |
| William Sapwell | Liberal Democrats | 314 |
| Calvert A.J.C. | TUSC | 80 |
Manor Castle1 seat · turnout 22.3%
| Andrew Murphy | Labour | 1,567 ✓ |
| R. Flagg-Abbey | Green | 642 |
| I.G. Walker | Conservative | 578 |
| Jessica Carrington | YORKS | 303 |
| Kenning S.J. | Liberal Democrats | 134 |
| Tice A. | TUSC | 104 |
Mosborough1 seat · turnout 35.8%
| Tony Downing | Labour | 1,964 ✓ |
| Kurtis Jenson Crossthorn | Liberal Democrats | 1,744 |
| Finney M.T. | Conservative | 892 |
| White J.A. | Green | 220 |
| Wood A. | REF | 89 |
Nether Edge and Sharrow1 seat · turnout 40.0%
| Raouf M.A. | Green | 3,102 ✓ |
| Slater G.E. | Labour | 2,200 |
| Joshua Chapman | Conservative | 553 |
| White P.A. | Liberal Democrats | 385 |
| Johnston H. | TUSC | 192 |
| Kennedy J.F. | YORKS | 122 |
Park & Arbourthorne1 seat
| Sophie Wilson | Labour | 1,860 ✓ |
| Blyth R. | Conservative | 1,051 |
| Dillner D. | Green | 572 |
| Shaddock P.A. | Liberal Democrats | 288 |
Richmond2 seats · turnout 27.4%
| Barker D.C. | Labour | 1,828 ✓ |
| Mike Drabble | Labour | 1,378 ✓ |
| Lord C. | Conservative | 995 |
| O'Brien D. | Conservative | 926 |
| Hartley C.S. | Green | 513 |
| Burns R.W. | REF | 408 |
| Kus B. | REF | 387 |
| Ward E.C. | Green | 277 |
| Ross S.E. | Liberal Democrats | 163 |
| Pattie E.M. | Liberal Democrats | 129 |
Shiregreen and Brightside1 seat · turnout 23.7%
| Peter Price | Labour | 1,803 ✓ |
| Steane Z.M. | Conservative | 991 |
| Pennefather M.J. | Green | 310 |
| Leek D.W. | Liberal Democrats | 204 |
Southey1 seat · turnout 22.8%
| Damms T. | Labour | 1,745 ✓ |
| May A. | Conservative | 800 |
| Hards A.P. | Green | 374 |
| Reiss R. | Liberal Democrats | 150 |
| Lee M. | REF | 134 |
Stannington1 seat · turnout 41.3%
| Williams R.N. | Liberal Democrats | 1,900 ✓ |
| Craig Gamble Pugh | Labour | 1,737 |
| Liddle L.T.B. | Conservative | 1,486 |
| Sweet C.E.A. | Green | 710 |
| Virgo M.J. | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 165 |
Stocksbridge & Upper Don1 seat
| Chinchen L.R. | Conservative | 1,822 ✓ |
| Banes L.A.J. | Labour | 1,325 |
| Brelsford M.C. | Liberal Democrats | 1,317 |
| Willington D. | Green | 596 |
| Clarkson J. | Independent | 522 |
| Davies D. | REF | 78 |
Walkley1 seat · turnout 38.4%
| Little B.J. | Green | 2,774 ✓ |
| Fran Belbin | Labour | 2,290 |
| Evelyn Millward | Conservative | 592 |
| Akbar I. | Liberal Democrats | 213 |
| Butler A. | WEP | 90 |
| Hibbert J. | TUSC | 72 |
West Ecclesfield1 seat · turnout 36.1%
| Whitaker A.C. | Liberal Democrats | 1,752 ✓ |
| Hurst A. | Labour | 1,361 |
| Kevin Mahoney | Conservative | 889 |
| Ogle J. | YORKS | 352 |
| John Booker | REF | 331 |
| Kathy Ashton | Green | 266 |
Woodhouse1 seat · turnout 28.8%
| Mick Rooney | Labour | 2,106 ✓ |
| Gregory G.C. | Conservative | 1,155 |
| Hardy L.K. | Green | 337 |
| Charles Philip Edwardson | Liberal Democrats | 213 |
