Before (end of 2022) (45 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 26 · Green 9 · Other 7 · Liberal Democrats 3
After (end of 2023) (45 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 23 · Green 11 · Other 7 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Labour 1
Ward results
Banstead Village1 seat · turnout 33.0%
| Eddy Humphreys | Conservative | 1,347 ✓ |
| Scott Barrington | Labour | 337 |
| Andrew John Knights | Liberal Democrats | 275 |
| Jennie Pope | Green | 201 |
Chipstead, Kingswood & Woodmansterne1 seat · turnout 32.0%
| Jed Dwight | Conservative | 1,477 ✓ |
| Sophie Louise Rowlands | Green | 308 |
| Chris Salmen | Labour | 286 |
| Mark Johnston | Liberal Democrats | 282 |
Earlswood & Whitebushes1 seat · turnout 33.0%
| Della Nyree Torra | Green | 1,360 ✓ |
| Barbara Thomson | Conservative | 507 |
| Jenny Orchard | Labour | 337 |
| Lexi Lawrence | Liberal Democrats | 123 |
| Shasha Khan | Green | 929 ✓ |
| Tim Peniston-Bird | Conservative | 717 |
| Rex William Giles | Labour | 573 |
| Graham John Burr | Liberal Democrats | 263 |
Horley Central & South1 seat
| Jerry Hudson | Conservative | 840 ✓ |
| Lynnette Easterbrook | Labour | 560 |
| Alan Graham Hirst Mitchell | Green | 267 |
| Stuart Nicholas Holmes | Liberal Democrats | 266 |
| Chris Scott | Reform UK | 174 |
Horley East & Salfords1 seat · turnout 35.0%
| Jason Michael Thorne | Green | 1,019 ✓ |
| Tony Schofield | Conservative | 855 |
| Steel James Horton | Labour | 335 |
| Robin Timothy Lawrence | Liberal Democrats | 211 |
Horley West & Sidlow1 seat
| Richard Biggs | Conservative | 937 ✓ |
| Thomas Turner | Labour | 778 |
| Steve Wotton | Liberal Democrats | 390 |
| Neville Kemp | Green | 236 |
Lower Kingswood, Tadworth & Walton1 seat · turnout 34.0%
| Ben Green | Conservative | 1,617 ✓ |
| Gregory Alec Edwin Ardan | Liberal Democrats | 514 |
| David Anthony Burnley | Labour | 453 |
Meadvale & St John's1 seat · turnout 41.0%
| Steve Kulka | Liberal Democrats | 1,210 ✓ |
| Jonathan Francis White | Conservative | 738 |
| Philippa Mary Martin | Green | 454 |
| John Michael Berge | Labour | 286 |
Nork1 seat
| Gemma Adamson | Nork Residents' Association | 1,345 ✓ |
| Pamela Freeman | Conservative | 615 |
| Calli Mistry | Labour | 191 |
| Flip Bakker | Green | 139 |
| Claude Knights | Liberal Democrats | 76 |
Redhill East1 seat · turnout 33.8%
| Jonathan Christopher St Aubyn Essex | Green | 1,504 ✓ |
| James Bradridge Dodsworth | Conservative | 303 |
| Mark Scott | Labour | 217 |
| Toby Risk | Liberal Democrats | 94 |
Redhill West & Wray Common1 seat · turnout 35.0%
| Mark Peter Smith | Labour | 893 ✓ |
| Ronnie Hutchings | Conservative | 864 |
| Leon Robert Deith | Green | 378 |
| Gemma Mary Roulston | Liberal Democrats | 362 |
Reigate1 seat
| Kate Fairhurst | Conservative | 1,260 ✓ |
| Jemma De Vincenzo | Liberal Democrats | 859 |
| Claire Thorpe | Green | 446 |
| Ian Thirlwall | Labour | 283 |
South Park & Woodhatch1 seat · turnout 37.0%
| James Paul King | Conservative | 1,093 ✓ |
| Natasha Mari Hobbs | Green | 942 |
| Marcus Ward | Labour | 216 |
| Chris Howell | Liberal Democrats | 121 |
| Jill Bray | Tattenham & Preston Residents | 1,237 ✓ |
| Aaron Doherty | Conservative | 291 |
| Steve Boeje | Labour | 282 |
| Moray Carey | Liberal Democrats | 71 |
| Alistair Patrick Galbraith Morten | Green | 69 |