Before (end of 2022) (41 seats, Open Council Data)
Liberal Democrats 24 · Conservative 10 · Other 7
After (end of 2023) (39 seats, Open Council Data)
Liberal Democrats 30 · Other 6 · Conservative 3
Ward results
Ashtead Lanes and Common3 seats · turnout 41.9%
| Chris Hunt | Ashtead Independents | 1,636 ✓ |
| Patricia Wiltshire | Ashtead Independents | 1,553 ✓ |
| David Leslie Hawksworth | Ashtead Independents | 1,534 ✓ |
| Philippa Ruth Shimmin | Liberal Democrats | 488 |
| Amanda Elaine Hartwell | Liberal Democrats | 425 |
| Ross Andrew Compton Moncur | Liberal Democrats | 422 |
| Debbie Cook | Conservative | 284 |
| Gavin Mansfield Newton | Conservative | 265 |
| Susan Gilchrist | Labour | 241 |
Ashtead Park3 seats
| Mary Patricia Cooper | Ashtead Independents | 1,242 ✓ |
| Garry Andrew Graham Stansfield | Ashtead Independents | 1,140 ✓ |
| Gerry Sevenoaks | Ashtead Independents | 970 ✓ |
| Raj Patel | Independent | 706 |
| David James Harper | Independent | 535 |
| Kateryna Cutler | Conservative | 269 |
| Patricia Ann Brown | Green | 264 |
| Andy Smith | Conservative | 253 |
| Veronica Joyce MacLeod | Liberal Democrats | 245 |
| Matthew James Wray | Conservative | 236 |
| Jolanta Waugh | Liberal Democrats | 215 |
| Andrew James Cressy | Liberal Democrats | 200 |
| Steve Eagle | Labour | 136 |
| Gregory Adrian Smith | Green | 118 |
Bookham East and Eastwick Park3 seats · turnout 53.3%
| Elizabeth Daly | Liberal Democrats | 1,577 ✓ |
| Paul Kennedy | Liberal Democrats | 1,568 ✓ |
| Andrew Harold Matthews | Liberal Democrats | 1,467 ✓ |
| Sarah Chambers | Conservative | 994 |
| Richard Swinbank | Conservative | 834 |
| Patrick Humphrey Morrish | Conservative | 800 |
| Emily Joyce Stewart | Green | 176 |
| William Mansfield | Labour | 80 |
Bookham West3 seats · turnout 44.4%
| Monica Josephine Weller | Liberal Democrats | 1,408 ✓ |
| Roger Martin Adams | Liberal Democrats | 1,390 ✓ |
| Christine Mary Miller | Liberal Democrats | 1,256 ✓ |
| Toby Cracknell | Conservative | 725 |
| Richard Moyse | Conservative | 664 |
| Dina Zharova-Berbner | Conservative | 564 |
| Eugene Arthur Michael Suggett | Green | 268 |
Brockham, Betchworth, Buckland, Box Hill and Headley3 seats · turnout 44.4%
| Paul James Potter | Liberal Democrats | 1,217 ✓ |
| Simon Budd | Conservative | 1,139 ✓ |
| Paula Helen Keay | Liberal Democrats | 1,089 ✓ |
| Bradley Luke Nelson | Liberal Democrats | 868 |
| Radia Kesseiri Austin | Conservative | 645 |
| Celia Georgina Tiley | Conservative | 576 |
| Penny Green | Green | 285 |
| Noel Edward Humphrey | Labour | 168 |
Capel, Leigh, Newdigate and Charlwood3 seats · turnout 40.0%
| Lesley Jean Bushnell | Liberal Democrats | 894 ✓ |
| Jo Farrar-Astrop | Liberal Democrats | 810 ✓ |
| Alcia Natalie Loach | Liberal Democrats | 720 ✓ |
| Corinna Osborne-Patterson | Conservative | 698 |
| Tom Baldwin | Conservative | 620 |
| Mark Stephen Saunders | Conservative | 619 |
| Lisa Claire Scott | Green | 604 |
| Roger Abbott | Green | 438 |
| Ken Hollis | Green | 409 |
| Laurence Nasskau | Labour | 64 |
Dorking North3 seats
| Hazel Valerie Ann Watson | Liberal Democrats | 1,301 ✓ |
| David John Draper | Liberal Democrats | 1,207 ✓ |
| Elsie Rosam | Liberal Democrats | 1,082 ✓ |
| Christopher Crook | Green | 778 |
| Pat Smith | Green | 642 |
| Sarah Weston Holland | Green | 627 |
| Clare Mary Mansfield | Labour | 339 |
| Michael Foulston | Conservative | 316 |
| Peter Cude | Conservative | 264 |
| Stephen Charles Frost | Conservative | 257 |
Dorking South3 seats · turnout 38.4%
| Margaret Cooksey | Liberal Democrats | 1,301 ✓ |
| Stephen John Cooksey | Liberal Democrats | 1,219 ✓ |
| Nick Wright | Liberal Democrats | 1,185 ✓ |
| Molly Isabella Crook | Green | 445 |
| Roger Keith Jones | Conservative | 413 |
| Lucy Jane Barford | Green | 395 |
| Beccy Gunn | Conservative | 386 |
| Lucinda Sharpe | Conservative | 384 |
| Gerard Martin Bolton | Green | 368 |
Fetcham3 seats · turnout 43.9%
| Raj Haque | Liberal Democrats | 1,426 ✓ |
| Phil Hammond | Liberal Democrats | 1,402 ✓ |
| Caroline Victoria Joseph | Liberal Democrats | 1,311 ✓ |
| Simon Chambers | Conservative | 853 |
| Paul Michael Austin | Conservative | 755 |
| David Norman Berkeley McCorquodale | Conservative | 617 |
| Janet Helen Crook | Green | 219 |
| Dan Creber | Green | 159 |
| Beatrice Heath | Labour | 151 |
Holmwoods and Beare Green3 seats · turnout 36.8%
| Rosemary Margaret Hobbs | Liberal Democrats | 979 ✓ |
| Claire Philomena Malcomson | Liberal Democrats | 879 ✓ |
| Clayton John Wellman | Liberal Democrats | 782 ✓ |
| Leslie Maruziva | Conservative | 607 |
| Lucy Vanora Heidee Botting | Conservative | 546 |
| David Mir | Conservative | 524 |
| John Francis Roche | Green | 224 |
| Emily Anne Auckland | Green | 198 |
| Fiona Louise Case | Green | 162 |
| Christine Mary Foster | Labour | 158 |
Leatherhead North3 seats · turnout 24.5%
| Keira Vyvyan-Robinson | Liberal Democrats | 689 ✓ |
| Ben Wall | Liberal Democrats | 661 ✓ |
| Benjamin Wear | Liberal Democrats | 624 ✓ |
| Aaron Gibbs | Conservative | 368 |
| Alan William Gibbs | Conservative | 330 |
| Mir Maqdoom Hai Qamer Ali | Conservative | 302 |
| Sally Jane Stewart | Green | 267 |
Leatherhead South3 seats · turnout 69.6%
| Bridget Kendrick | Liberal Democrats | 960 ✓ |
| Joanna Slater | Conservative | 852 ✓ |
| James Chambers | Conservative | 831 ✓ |
| Gareth John Parsons | Liberal Democrats | 779 |
| Henry Peter Elcock-Haskins | Conservative | 754 |
| Nick O'Shea | Liberal Democrats | 700 |
| Melissa Jane Awcock | Green | 301 |
| Ann Clark | Labour | 207 |
| Joanna Kathryn Sherring | Green | 151 |
Mickleham, Westcott and Okewood3 seats · turnout 42.6%
| Chris Budleigh | Liberal Democrats | 1,180 ✓ |
| Abhiram Magesh | Liberal Democrats | 1,108 ✓ |
| Leah Rose Mursaleen-Plank | Liberal Democrats | 1,106 ✓ |
| Mike Hebberd | Conservative | 769 |
| Duncan Campbell Irvine | Conservative | 703 |
| Gavin Timothy Charles Musgrave | Conservative | 684 |
| James John Lawrence Poke | Green | 372 |
| David Leonard Szachno-Hodgkinson | Green | 260 |