Before (end of 2022) (35 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 22 · Labour 11 · Other 2
After (end of 2023) (35 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 17 · Labour 15 · Other 3
Ward results
Arley & Whitacre3 seats · turnout 31.9%
| Jodie Gosling | Labour | 767 ✓ |
| Michaela Louise Jackson | Labour | 623 ✓ |
| Nigel Turley | Labour | 594 ✓ |
| Heather Norgrove | Conservative | 507 |
| Christopher Paul Jones | Conservative | 462 |
| Kerry Parker | Conservative | 419 |
| Peter Downes | Heritage Party | 152 |
| P. Downes | HER | 151 |
Atherstone Central2 seats · turnout 21.6%
| Neil Dirveiks | Labour | 413 ✓ |
| Rachel Taylor | Labour | 403 ✓ |
| Mark Jodda Jordan | Conservative | 216 |
| Paulina Cecilia Gurney | Conservative | 184 |
Atherstone North2 seats · turnout 27.0%
| Ray Jarvis | Conservative | 394 ✓ |
| Mejar Singh | Conservative | 378 ✓ |
| Derek Nicholas Alfred Pickard | Labour | 369 |
| Joshua Laurence Smith | Labour | 350 |
Atherstone South & Mancetter2 seats · turnout 29.8%
| Martin Keith Barnett | Labour | 453 ✓ |
| Denise Sandra Clews | Conservative | 421 ✓ |
| Michael Edward Stanley | Labour | 401 |
| Tony Clews | Conservative | 399 |
Baddesley & Grendon2 seats · turnout 32.9%
| Andy Wright | Conservative | 637 ✓ |
| Bernadette Davey | Conservative | 583 ✓ |
| Martin Alan Sharp | Labour | 482 |
| Nathan John Sweet | Labour | 432 |
Coleshill North2 seats · turnout 31.1%
| Jane Farrow | Labour | 400 ✓ |
| Peter John Fowler | Conservative | 369 ✓ |
| Adam Ray Ian Richardson | Labour | 339 |
| Colin Lewis | Conservative | 315 |
Coleshill South2 seats · turnout 30.1%
| Caroline Symonds | Conservative | 533 ✓ |
| Colin Charles Hayfield | Conservative | 416 ✓ |
| Alistair Brett | Labour | 305 |
| Keith Brian Brown | Labour | 304 |
Curdworth2 seats · turnout 35.3%
| Sandra Anne Smith | Conservative | 566 ✓ |
| Martin Lee Watson | Conservative | 521 ✓ |
| Celia Banner | Labour | 220 |
| Michael Desmond Banner | Labour | 171 |
| Josh Harris | Green | 160 |
Dordon2 seats · turnout 27.5%
| Byron John Lewis Melia | Independent | 411 ✓ |
| Davina Mary Ridley | Independent | 361 ✓ |
| Peter Frank Morson | Labour | 218 |
| Alexandra Catherine Elizabeth Phillips | Labour | 173 |
Fillongley2 seats · turnout 30.3%
| Mark Simpson | Conservative | 597 ✓ |
| David Wright | Conservative | 566 ✓ |
| David Wright | Conservative | 556 ✓ |
| John Brendan Doyle | Labour | 225 |
| Daniel Hodkinson | Labour | 215 |
Hartshill2 seats · turnout 30.1%
| Margaret Bell | Conservative | 436 ✓ |
| Katie-Rose Mary Hobley | Labour | 412 ✓ |
| Elinor Parsons | Labour | 345 |
| Marli Parker | Conservative | 325 |
Hurley & Wood End2 seats · turnout 29.8%
| Owen George Phillips | Labour | 521 ✓ |
| John Kennoway Given | Conservative | 360 |
| Damien Holt | Conservative | 302 |
Kingsbury2 seats · turnout 32.4%
| Andy Jenns | Conservative | 589 ✓ |
| Andy Jenns | Conservative | 569 ✓ |
| Debbie Bates | Conservative | 410 ✓ |
| Philip Michael Leslie Page | Labour | 222 |
| Smita Kaur Jalaf | Labour | 175 |
| Suzanne Claire Ayasamy | Independent | 111 |
Newton Regis & Warton2 seats · turnout 34.2%
| David Humphreys | Conservative | 526 ✓ |
| Brynnen Elizabeth Ririe | Labour | 525 ✓ |
| Marian Humphreys | Conservative | 520 |
| Faye Whapples | Labour | 494 |
Polesworth East2 seats · turnout 29.3%
| David Parsons | Labour | 532 ✓ |
| Neil Henry Chapman | Labour | 401 ✓ |
| Dan Hancocks | Conservative | 326 |
| Jack Ken Bayley | Conservative | 269 |
Polesworth West2 seats · turnout 28.4%
| Emma Louise Whapples | Labour | 403 ✓ |
| Michael Edward Osborne | Labour | 394 ✓ |
| Suzanne Mary Hancocks | Conservative | 297 |
| Sue Hanratty | Conservative | 283 |
Water Orton2 seats · turnout 33.4%
| Steve Stuart | Independent | 433 ✓ |
| Dave Reilly | Conservative | 384 ✓ |
| Michael Peter Lee | Conservative | 335 |
| Felicitas Antoinette Freeman | Independent | 292 |
| Thomas Patrick Foley | Labour | 164 |
| John Andrew Broughton | Labour | 89 |