Before (end of 2022) (42 seats, Open Council Data)
Other 21 · Liberal Democrats 11 · Conservative 10
After (end of 2023) (42 seats, Open Council Data)
Other 22 · Liberal Democrats 11 · Conservative 9
Ward results
Bletchingley And Nutfield1 seat · turnout 35.3%
| Helena Mary Windsor | Independent | 594 ✓ |
| Richard Barry Fowler | Liberal Democrats | 407 |
| Mark William Winsbury | Conservative | 368 |
| Linda Ruth Baharier | Labour | 195 |
Chaldon1 seat · turnout 41.2%
| Lewis Mathew Sharp | Conservative | 386 ✓ |
| Neil Martin Parker | Liberal Democrats | 133 |
| Rachel Mary Starling | Green | 43 |
| Nicole Morrigan | Labour | 21 |
Dormansland and Felcourt1 seat
| Nicola O'Riordan | Independent | 456 ✓ |
| Harry Fitzgerald | Conservative | 421 |
| Roger Martin | Liberal Democrats | 143 |
| Caz Lessey | Labour | 76 |
FELBRIDGE1 seat · turnout 35.2%
| Judy Moore | Independent | 247 ✓ |
| Patrick Jolliffe | Conservative | 219 |
| Becky Peterson | Green | 93 |
| Emba Miguel Jones | Labour | 66 |
Godstone1 seat · turnout 30.8%
| Colin Arthur White | Independent | 859 ✓ |
| Keith Robert Ward | Conservative | 242 |
| Paul Anthony Ryan | Labour | 159 |
| Martin Redman | Liberal Democrats | 106 |
Limpsfield1 seat · turnout 43.6%
| Claire Lesley Blackwell | Oxted & Limpsfield Residents Group | 944 ✓ |
| Paul Nicholas Greenhalgh | Conservative | 166 |
| Rupert James McCann | Liberal Democrats | 74 |
| Mark Christopher Dean | Labour | 60 |
Lingfield and Crowhurst1 seat · turnout 37.8%
| Lesley Susan Steeds | Conservative | 477 ✓ |
| Charlotte Swann | Independent | 473 |
| Ryan Michael Howard | Labour | 182 |
| Dave Wilkes | Liberal Democrats | 113 |
OXTED NORTH & TANDRIDGE1 seat · turnout 40.2%
| Peter John Damesick | Oxted & Limpsfield Residents Group | 1,371 ✓ |
| Michael Victor Casebourne | Conservative | 221 |
| Louis Michael Labrosse | Labour | 128 |
| Martin Caxton | Liberal Democrats | 98 |
| Carol Dean | Heritage Party | 15 |
Oxted South1 seat · turnout 36.2%
| Chris Langton | Oxted & Limpsfield Residents Group | 1,099 ✓ |
| Nicolas Rupert Cook | Conservative | 209 |
| David Christopher Halliwell | Labour | 195 |
| Olivia Grierson | Green | 115 |
| Robert Wingate | Liberal Democrats | 75 |
Portley1 seat · turnout 27.6%
| Alun Jones | Liberal Democrats | 553 ✓ |
| Richard John Mark | Conservative | 253 |
| Roy Ian Kelvin Stewart | Labour | 131 |
Tatsfield And Titsey1 seat · turnout 35.2%
| Martin William Allen | Independent | 371 ✓ |
| Harry James Kilgour Millar | Conservative | 124 |
| Nathan Charles Manning | Labour | 48 |
Valley1 seat · turnout 33.8%
| Alun Jones | Liberal Democrats | 684 ✓ |
| Clare Sailing | Conservative | 158 |
| Anne Sheena Watson | Labour | 83 |
Warlingham East And Chelsham And Farleigh1 seat · turnout 32.0%
| Anna Serena Patel | Liberal Democrats | 643 ✓ |
| Nathan Adams | Conservative | 456 |
| Martin Arthur Haley | Independent | 147 |
| Daniel Evans Frank Mann | Labour | 85 |
| Jessica Hibberd | Green | 61 |