Before (end of 2023) (45 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 23 · Green 11 · Other 7 · Liberal Democrats 3 · Labour 1
After (end of 2024) (45 seats, Open Council Data)
Conservative 18 · Green 13 · Other 8 · Liberal Democrats 4 · Labour 2
Ward results
Banstead Village1 seat
| Nadean Moses | Conservative | 1,354 ✓ |
| Chris Salmen | Labour | 417 |
| Anthony Daniel Ross Anderson | Liberal Democrats | 231 |
| Chris Hanson-Graville | Green | 230 |
| Shelly Newton | Conservative | 1,671 ✓ |
| Thomas Frederick Robinson | Labour | 333 |
| Mark Johnston | Liberal Democrats | 320 |
| Christian Oster | Green | 245 |
Earlswood & Whitebushes1 seat
| Gillian Vischer | Green | 1,429 ✓ |
| Trevor Nugent | Conservative | 417 |
| Alistair Wells | Labour | 345 |
| L. Lawrence | Liberal Democrats | 176 |
| Joel Gabriel | Green | 1,011 ✓ |
| Frank Kelly | Conservative | 635 |
| Catherine Mary Barrett | Labour | 533 |
| Cathy Scott | REF | 284 |
| Sonia Holmes | Liberal Democrats | 173 |
Horley Central & South1 seat · turnout 31.5%
| Giorgio Buttironi | Conservative | 781 ✓ |
| Suzy Horton | Green | 595 |
| Lynnette Easterbrook | Labour | 517 |
| Sam Lewin-Mearing | Liberal Democrats | 450 |
Horley East & Salfords1 seat
| Neha Boghani | Green | 1,090 ✓ |
| Taylor Dennis Spencer O'Driscoll | Conservative | 867 |
| Ryan Trevor Ramsey | Labour | 311 |
| Peter Jason Bernard Newton | Liberal Democrats | 272 |
Horley West & Sidlow1 seat
| Steve Wotton | Liberal Democrats | 1,083 ✓ |
| Sujata Das | Conservative | 749 |
| Thomas Turner | Labour | 690 |
| N. Kemp | Green | 174 |
| Zelanie Sue Cooper | Independent | 1,135 ✓ |
| T. Peniston-Bird | Conservative | 1,038 |
| Faye Llewellyn | Labour | 249 |
| Alistair Patrick Galbraith Morten | Green | 220 |
| G. Ardan | Liberal Democrats | 202 |
Meadvale & St John's1 seat · turnout 39.4%
| Martin Elbourne | Liberal Democrats | 970 ✓ |
| J. White | Conservative | 765 |
| N. Hobbs | Green | 481 |
| Rosemary Norgrove | Labour | 431 |
Nork1 seat
| Peter Harp | YORKS | 1,591 ✓ |
| Pamela Freeman | Conservative | 453 |
| Geoffrey Frank Woodhead | Labour | 200 |
| Flip Bakker | Green | 120 |
| Isobel Linda Squire | Liberal Democrats | 69 |
Redhill East1 seat
| Sue Sinden | Green | 1,439 ✓ |
| Elliott James Wragg | Labour | 370 |
| Joan Ofunne Odiachi | Conservative | 367 |
| Moray Carey | Liberal Democrats | 115 |
| J. Orchard | Labour | 1,067 ✓ |
| M. Mendoza | Conservative | 808 |
| Felix Paul Kennedy | Green | 449 |
| G. Roulston | Liberal Democrats | 271 |
Reigate1 seat
| Michael Blacker | Conservative | 1,090 ✓ |
| Jemma de Vincenzo | Liberal Democrats | 1,007 |
| Toby Risk | Green | 668 |
| Mark Scott | Labour | 258 |
South Park & Woodhatch1 seat · turnout 36.3%
| Paul Holmes Chandler | Green | 1,185 ✓ |
| Clem Stevens | Conservative | 486 |
| Liam Castles | Labour | 414 |
| J. Fox | REF | 149 |
| Robin Timothy Lawrence | Liberal Democrats | 107 |
Tattenham Corner & Preston2 seats · turnout 56.8%
| Tim Snuggs | B and D IND | 1,378 ✓ |
| B. Nash | B and D IND | 1,318 ✓ |
| Adrian Freeman | Conservative | 357 |
| Rex William Giles | Labour | 315 |
| Ian Thirlwall | Labour | 226 |
| Rajan Mathew | Conservative | 225 |
| G. Burr | Liberal Democrats | 126 |
| Maureen Robinson | Liberal Democrats | 108 |
| Robert Edward Pye | Green | 107 |